2023 Season, Arrivals and Departures

Lots of talk about Rovers paying a big fee to Sligo for Keena but i cant see it tbh.
He looks like a decent player for sure but he has 18 goals and 3 assists with a few penos thrown in there.
Gaffney has 10 goals and 8 assisys with no penos.
I m not saying i wouldnt like Keena but he has had 1 good season, i would nt be paying a big fee for him.

Colm Whelan is out of contract from UCD but i have no idea when he would be back from his cruciate.....
I think it was May when he did it so should be ok for start of next season if hes lucky maybe

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by sbgawa

Colm Whelan is out of contract from UCD but i have no idea when he would be back from his cruciate.....
I think it was May when he did it so should be ok for start of next season if hes lucky maybe

---

Probably not out of the question that he re-signs for UCD and looks to move in the summer I guess.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by pineapple stu

Probably not out of the question that he re-signs for UCD and looks to move in the summer I guess.

---

Fair point i hadnt considered that as all the talk was about where he was going but that might be a way for him to prove himself and get a better long term deal

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by sbgawa

Lots of talk about Rovers paying a big fee to Sligo for Keena but i cant see it tbh.
He looks like a decent player for sure but he has 18 goals and 3 assists with a few penos thrown in there.
Gaffney has 10 goals and 8 assisys with no penos.
I m not saying i wouldnt like Keena but he has had 1 good season, i would nt be paying a big fee for him.

Colm Whelan is out of contract from UCD but i have no idea when he would be back from his cruciate.....
I think it was May when he did it so should be ok for start of next season if hes lucky maybe

---

Gaffney has 10 goals in the best team in the league , Keena got 18 in a mid table side you'd expect him to get at least 7 or 8 more over a season if playing for Shamrock Rovers , plus he's a lot younger . If he did well at Rovers they could recoup there money in a season or two if he moved back across the water.

keena isnt as well rounded aa gaffney.

clarke gone from shels. wonder where he'll end up

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jd2793

clarke gone from shels. wonder where he'll end up

---

Be a good back up option for Dundalk if Cherrie finishes up…..

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by joey B

Be a good back up option for Dundalk if Cherrie finishes up…..

---

He had issues with O'Donnell with us in 2020 and O'Donnell pretty much drove him out of the club. While I'd never say it won't happen but it'd be unlikely.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by sbgawa

Lots of talk about Rovers paying a big fee to Sligo for Keena but i cant see it tbh.
He looks like a decent player for sure but he has 18 goals and 3 assists with a few penos thrown in there.
Gaffney has 10 goals and 8 assisys with no penos.
I m not saying i wouldnt like Keena but he has had 1 good season, i would nt be paying a big fee for him.

Colm Whelan is out of contract from UCD but i have no idea when he would be back from his cruciate.....
I think it was May when he did it so should be ok for start of next season if hes lucky maybe

---

Thinking about this earlier, at the peak of DFC under Kenny, he never really paid a fee for too many players and never overboard for a striker. Possibly Kilduff was 20k from Rovers but came via on loan at Pats, 20k again I think for Horgan from Cork City, Hoban was free, McMillan out of contract and also free, but bizarrely 40k for Dylan Connolly, and even more crazy made that back on the transfer to AFC Wimbledon.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by oriel

Thinking about this earlier, at the peak of DFC under Kenny, he never really paid a fee for too many players and never overboard for a striker. Possibly Kilduff was 20k from Rovers but came via on loan at Pats, 20k again I think for Horgan from Cork City, Hoban was free, McMillan out of contract and also free, but bizarrely 40k for Dylan Connolly, and even more crazy made that back on the transfer to AFC Wimbledon.

---

Kilduff was never on loan at Pats, he signed permanently at Pats on a free from rovers ahead of the 2015 season and was sold to Dundalk that summer after struggling for form/minutes behind Fagan

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by 2 Year Contract

Kilduff was never on loan at Pats, he signed permanently at Pats on a free from rovers ahead of the 2015 season and was sold to Dundalk that summer after struggling for form/minutes behind Fagan

---

Sorry my bad then, but still say the transfer fee was modest, def under 20k. His 2 goals alone in the EL group stage earned around 750k, he had a great 2016.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by oriel

Sorry my bad then, but still say the transfer fee was modest, def under 20k. His 2 goals alone in the EL group stage earned around 750k, he had a great 2016.

---

Yeah you’re right there, think I remember hearing at the time that it was either 20 or 15k. Worked out for all parties as he’d have been on his way out of pats for free a couple of months later regardless. Just one of those transfers that didn’t work out. There was a number of underwhelming strikers at pats around that time, Dinny Corocoran was signed as Kilduff's replacement the following season and through his performances ended up restricting himself to substitute appearances, scoring a grand total of 0 league goals, off the back of being one of the league's top goalscorers with Sligo the previous year. On the topic of Corcoran, he announced his retirement from LOI football the other day, he was great for Bohs and is a member of the LOI 100 goals club

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by sbgawa

Fair point i hadnt considered that as all the talk was about where he was going but that might be a way for him to prove himself and get a better long term deal

---

Extratime have Whelan as resigned for UCD on their transfers summary now.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by 2 Year Contract

Yeah you’re right there, think I remember hearing at the time that it was either 20 or 15k. Worked out for all parties as he’d have been on his way out of pats for free a couple of months later regardless. Just one of those transfers that didn’t work out. There was a number of underwhelming strikers at pats around that time, Dinny Corocoran was signed as Kilduff's replacement the following season and through his performances ended up restricting himself to substitute appearances, scoring a grand total of 0 league goals, off the back of being one of the league's top goalscorers with Sligo the previous year. On the topic of Corcoran, he announced his retirement from LOI football the other day, he was great for Bohs and is a member of the LOI 100 goals club

---

Would love to see that list if it's available anywhere

https://wexfordfc.ie/latest-news/139...senior-manager

James Keddy appointed Wexford manager…..

https://shelbournefc.ie/five-players-depart-the-reds/

5 players depart Shels, Brendan Clarke, Aaron O’Driscoll, Dan Carr, Josh Giurgi, and Dan Hawkins.

Interesting to note on Extratime squad signing tracker that Colm Whelan is listed as re-signed by UCD. That's really unusual, as normally UCD publish nothing until about a week before the new season starts

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by joey B

https://shelbournefc.ie/five-players-depart-the-reds/

5 players depart Shels, Brendan Clarke, Aaron O’Driscoll, Dan Carr, Josh Giurgi, and Dan Hawkins.

---

Interesting - thought Giurgi was considered one of their highest-regarded prospects?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by culloty82

Interesting - thought Giurgi was considered one of their highest-regarded prospects?

---

They only signed him from Norwich in the summer but he was only given 2 starts in the league (and was subbed on 5 times)

Giurgi never got much of a look in since he signed. Brendan Clarke will be a big loss but won't be upset over the others going especially Carr. Did very little all season and never looked like he cared when he was on the pitch.

Luke Byrne has been confirmed as signed up for 2023.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by The Bowler

Interesting to note on Extratime squad signing tracker that Colm Whelan is listed as re-signed by UCD. That's really unusual, as normally UCD publish nothing until about a week before the new season starts

---

I know that just from a Pats perspective some aspects of that list is inaccurate, so may be the case for other clubs too.

Shelbourne sign Conor Kearns,he was shocking in the play off against Waterford but not sure how he played in general last season......

Kyle Robinson off to Shels , Ben MCcrmack probably out the door next

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Glen Of Aherlow

Kyle Robinson off to Shels , Ben MCcrmack probably out the door next

---

pls send him down the m8 to cork

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jd2793

pls send him down the m8 to cork

---

If he leave he'll be a great signing for someone , be gutted to see him go

Robinson apparently had awful attitude issues this season, didn't even feature for the u19s for the rest of the season after he'd caused some kind of falling out. Shame as he looks a talent.

McCormack seems a bit inevitable, doesn't look like Clancy hugely took to him over the course of the season despite having his moments here and then. Would love for him to stay though as there's a serious player there.

Robinson along with Moylan both impressed with Wexford in 2021 and the rest is history for us with Moylan. Jack and a number of others would have vetted Robinson's character and ability to Duff happy with that signing as a prospect

Not sure about the Kearns signing if he is going to be number 1 replacing Clarke. From the times I seen him at UCD one of these keepers who can pull off eye catching saves one minute and giving fans a panic attack the next minute

Tyreke Wilson is a decent predictable signing with his brother JR with us and being a left back with Conor Kane recovering from his injury

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by culloty82

Interesting - thought Giurgi was considered one of their highest-regarded prospects?

---

Didn't see much of him but didn't look developed enough yet to suggest he was ready for Premier Division. I think he would be a worthwhile signing for a number of First Division teams

Interesting pick ups by Shels... Dont know too much about Robinson, but I like that Shels have other options than Boyd. Boyd scores goals ,but isnt a footballer - his touch is terrible and struggles to bring others into the game, and then spends whole games diving on the floor anytime the ball comes close to him.

I think there is a real player in Wilson. One bad season at Bohs - I wouldnt write him off at all. Wouldnt have minded him at Dundalk. I thought Kane was Shels best player last season, so maybe getting game time will tough for him.

Still, those transfers dont suggest a lot of money is on the way in Shels.

Chris Lyons departs Drogheda,hes from Bray and played there before so I'd say that would be an obvious pick up for them........
https://twitter.com/DroghedaUnited/s...78517253345282

Andrew Quinn latest signing by Shels tonight from Drogheda, heard that one rumoured on Sunday. Duff certainly not wasting time and sticking with developing young players

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kiki Balboa

I think there is a real player in Wilson. One bad season at Bohs - I wouldnt write him off at all. Wouldnt have minded him at Dundalk. I thought Kane was Shels best player last season, so maybe getting game time will tough for him.

---

Wilson had 2 bad seasons at Bohs. Just didn't suit playing in a back 4. In his first season He ended up being beaten for his starting position by Breslin who he was brought in to try to improve on. He only won his position back after it was all but confirmed Breslin was going to pats and even then Breslin started ahead of him frequently enough. As for his general play over the 2 years he was constantly beaten at the back post for headers, positioning was poor and he wasn't pacey enough to recover from it. Combine that with being weak in a tackle he was far from an ideal fullback. He has a decent left foot but that's the extent of the positives I saw from his time at Bohs. Maybe the switch to playing in 5 at the back will suit him but I think Bohs are in a better place with Kirk as their left back.

quinn is a good pick up for shels. dont rate kearns at all , decent first division keeper imo.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by total hoofball

Andrew Quinn latest signing by Shels tonight from Drogheda, heard that one rumoured on Sunday. Duff certainly not wasting time and sticking with developing young players

---

Damn - great player - sooner the better we bottom out if we have investors or not so we can begin signing players - Quinn is a brilliant lad and annoyed to see him gone.

The first Kerry update here - Billy Dennehy stated in an interview with Radio Kerry that Matt Keane attended the first senior training session this week, and he'll become a free agent on the 1st of December.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by joey B

Chris Lyons departs Drogheda,hes from Bray and played there before so I'd say that would be an obvious pick up for them........
https://twitter.com/DroghedaUnited/s...78517253345282

---

Surely Lyons is to good for Bray ??
Id almost have him at Rovers to offer us something different

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by sbgawa

Surely Lyons is to good for Bray ??
Id almost have him at Rovers to offer us something different

---

can't see Bray paying what he would want. In fact, I'm still damn confused by what Ian Ryan is doing at Bray, they have no money, and Devlin hanging around like a bad smell. If he's still there by seasons end I will be amazed.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by sbgawa

Surely Lyons is to good for Bray ??
Id almost have him at Rovers to offer us something different

---

I’m not sure,always thought of him as a good First division striker that wasn’t quite good enough for the Premier division….

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by sbgawa

Surely Lyons is to good for Bray ??
Id almost have him at Rovers to offer us something different

---

You did have him at rovers

Jamie Lennon signed up on new deal