Conor Hourihane in there I see!
Printable View
Conor Hourihane in there I see!
Article in FLW, encouraging Middlesboro to sign free agent Manning despite his defensive shortcomings; includes stats and infographic from Foresseaball, describing Manning as " The best Non-PL Loan Championship left back in 22-23".
Middlesbrough: Michael Carrick should swoop for free agent to find Ryan Giles solution (footballleagueworld.co.uk)
In a sense irrelevant, because the Ireland manager refuses to call him up. But I wish him well as a product of the Irish league system.
He did call him up and Manning refused call up. If Cannon gets criticism for turning down call so should ManningQuote:
Originally Posted by Trequartista20
It's completely different. Cannon is deciding weather he wishes to represent ireland or England in no way is that similar to manning unless he is in the process of switching allegiancesQuote:
Originally Posted by Razors left peg
So what's Mannings excuse?Quote:
Originally Posted by liamoo11
Is he justified in sulking because he was left out previously? If that's the case he needs to remind himself he's a Championship level player and not Champions League. Should Wes Houlihan have turned down call ups after he was left out for far too long?
Is Manning justified because he is looking for a club and doesn't want to get injured? In which case should Gary Breen have not played a WC in 2002 without a club?
Roy Keane was vilified for years for walking out on a call up, is Manning refusing to play for Kenny because it's personal between them like Keane and McCarthy?
Or is Manning excused cos ye just don't like Kenny?
Yes.Quote:
Originally Posted by Razors left peg
There’s wanting Kenny gone and there’s losing all sense of reason… some posters on here would want to come up for oxygen. The stuff on here and the O’Shea thread is just bizarre.
Comment withdrawn.
Insightful as alwaysQuote:
Originally Posted by Snapshot
Whoever thought he'd be off to Real Madrid?! (Even allowing for hyperbole)
I apologize if the sarcasm was too complicated for you to understandQuote:
Originally Posted by pineapple stu
Hence my bit in brackets.
Even allowing for that, your comment doesn't reflect anyone's views in the thread I think
I believe theres a view by some that hes better than he isQuote:
Originally Posted by pineapple stu
Literally created the most chances of any player in the championship last season...Quote:
Originally Posted by Razors left peg
I don't think anyone has ever even suggested he'd get a top half Premier move though.
I think people are aware our full-backs are ageing and O'Dowda wasn't great in Greece (arguably playing out of position) so probably one of the top-performing fullbacks in the Championship deserves a squad call-up
That doesn't mean we think he's the reincarnation of Cafu like
Fair play, with that you'd think he would have got a move to the Premiership instead of continuing his journeyman career in Championship.Quote:
Originally Posted by CSAD
One of the excuses going around when he turned down the call up for the Greece game was that he was out of contract so didnt want to risk injury. Glad for him that he didnt risk it, might never have gotten such a big move if he was injured.
He was called up. He turned it down!Quote:
Originally Posted by pineapple stu
Russel Martin said he turned down two Premiership clubs in favour of Southampton.
Probably deserved a call-up many times before that.
Seems a decent move though, assuming Southampton use their parachute payments to go straight back up. Though they don't seem the best run of clubs, so will wait and see how they get on.
Probably Luton and Sheffield United. Unless Livramento or Walker Peters leaves this summer I don't see him starting come August. Walker Peters moved from RB to LB when they bought Livramento and would except both to start if neither leave this summer. Livramento is linked with Newcastle but wants assurances about playing time and Trippier I think captained them last season.Quote:
Originally Posted by LurcherLover
If thats the case, I wonder the reasoning for turning down them clubs unless he's been told by Martin that he's guaranteed game time or something along them lines and/or see's himself getting more gametime with Southampton. I seen the Livramento/Newcastle link last week but nothing since. Would be beneficial from an Ireland perspective if it goes through obviously. Livramsnto to Newcastle, Larios loaned out, KWP back in RB and Manning ahead of Perraud at LB?Quote:
Originally Posted by JR89
And that's a good excuse for him to turn down call up this time?Quote:
Originally Posted by pineapple stu
Look I think he's fine, solid enough player who has never really impressed me any time I've watched. He's not very quick and I don't think he's a very good defender. He's is a good footballer given that he's a midfielder by trade, but I don't think he solves our left back problem
Ah he kind of is thoughQuote:
Originally Posted by pineapple stu
Usually Irish ambition it seems.Quote:
Originally Posted by LurcherLover
They were very effective at identifying high potential players who could keep them in a respectable league position and then sell for good money. The wheels came off that recently, as they inevitably will, but I wouldn't write them off just yet.Quote:
Originally Posted by pineapple stu
Next season which one of Luton, Sheffield United, and Southampton is mostly to be a PL team? Not every move to the PL is a good move. Southampton is the better move if you want to be playing PL for a few years.Quote:
Originally Posted by CSAD
Who said it was?Quote:
Originally Posted by Razors left peg
Point is your sarky comment about people who thought he was going to Madrid was daft, even allowing for sarcasm/hyperbole.
They had a change of ownership in early 2022 though, so I think that's played a good part in the wheels coming off. Which means that yeah, don't write off their promotion chances yet, but the possibility of a downward trend has to be there too.Quote:
Originally Posted by John83
It was intended to be daft and a massive over exaggeration, while also making the point of how over rated he is by some. Your inability to understand that and getting upset cos "no one said he was going to Madrid" is pretty funny. Of course no one fcuking said that, cos he's a decent Championship level player at best. He's always the one people fart on about around squad time, because we always focus on players left out. O'Dowda wasn't great in Greece, although I blame Lenihan as much as him for the 2nd goal, but I don't think there's much difference between him and Manning. If either are picked it's a weakness in the defense that good teams can get at. Doherty is our best option there until someone like Adaramola or Bagan kicks onQuote:
Originally Posted by pineapple stu
If you want to make the point that Manning's transfer suggests he's not able to add much over O'Dowda, you could do that without picking an argument that makes everyone reading it dumber for the experience.
A throw away joke was taken to heart by another poster, having to explain it was obviously stupid, but not my fault other people need it spelled outQuote:
Originally Posted by John83
So, when he ended his post with "(even allowing for hyperbole)", that suggests to you that he took it to heart? Could it be, just maybe, that you are also guilty of what you accuse him? Could it be that I am asking you to discuss the player without casting shade anyone who rates him differently from you, leading to stupid bickering?
Apologies if I’m wrong Razor, but this is my takeQuote:
Originally Posted by John83
Razor likes Stephen Kenny
Stephen Kenny doesn’t rate Ryan Manning
Some people criticise Stephen Kenny for not historically picking Ryan Manning
Razor uses Ryan Manning’s recent withdrawal from the squad as a covert tool to attack anti kennyites and the player himself
My view is Stephen is a utter idiot for not utilising Ryan Manning at any stage and Ryan Manning is bang out of other for pulling out of the last squad
It's actually nothing to do with Kenny to be honest. We have always manufactured outrage over certain players being left out. In my opinion the last time it was legitimately justified was Wes and Andy Reid being left out. There have been other players that people have gotten upset about since, I got annoyed that Hodge wasn't called up last year and I was was wrong.
The Manning thing annoys me because I believe he's in the same bracket as O'Dowda and McClean. They're grand, nothing to get upset about if one is picked over the other, but yet its made to be a bit topic when Manning isn't picked. Even today you can look at any sports page that's talking about Manning to Southampton and the majority of comments are about him not getting picked for Ireland as if he's a top end player.
And yet I think it's massively glossed over that he turned down a call up to this last squad. Everyone lost their mind about Tom Cannon and ignored Manning. Roy Keane still gets abuse "for turning his back on his country", yet we are supposed to be ok with Manning because he was left out previously so he's allowed have a sulk. Wes Houlihan as I said had the most legitimate grievance of recent years for being left out and yet he turned up whenever he was picked.
Diggs you say that Kenny is an utter idiot for not using him more, that's an opinion. We all have players we like more than others, I like Idah more than most, but I can also agree that Idah is of a similar level to all our options other than Ferguson right now and it's not a scandal when he's not picked. Manning is a Championship player being kept out by 2 other Championship left backs and an a Premiership right back who can double as left back. I don't think that warrants labeling anyone as an utter idiot for not picking him regularly. And by the way, he has been called up to squads, maybe in those training sessions he hasn't impressed, he hasn't impressed me much when I've seen him play games.
So no, its nothing to do with pro or anti Kenny, it's frustration at nonsense.
Utter idiot was too far and I withdrawthat actuallyQuote:
Originally Posted by Razors left peg
In relation to "Manning is a Championship player being kept out by 2 other Championship left backs and an a Premiership right back"
Manning was on the championship team of the season
The premisership right back is needed at right back and James mcclean isnt the player he was. I assume the second player is O'Dowda ? well unless Greece was just a bad day at the office then im not sure about him.
Yeah I was talking about O'Dowda, he was poor in Greece, but he was good in other games before that, and as I've said I give Lenihan just as much blame for the goal as O'Dowda.
Edit: and yes Manning was in team of season, I still don't think he's a good defender, but as I keep saying it's not that he's been completely ignored. He was picked and he is the one who refused to turn up.
All our usual wing-backs - McClean, Brady, Stevens, Doherty and Coleman - are getting on and we urgently need to work out who the replacements are. For the last while, it seems Browne and O'Dowda are in pole position there, but I think they're both playing out of position at wing-backs.Quote:
Originally Posted by Diggs246
Meanwhile, yeah, one of the best performers in that position in the Championship regularly gets overlooked for a place in the squad, let alone the team. And you could add in McNamara or others too.
If Southampton come back up - as teams with parachute payments often do - I think he's done alright. And I agree with JR that Southampton could turn out to be a better move than Premier Luton/Sheffield United in the medium term.
Assist for Manning today as its 1-1 against Sinclair Armstrongs QPR.
Another assistQuote:
Originally Posted by SkStu
This guy is not the answer. Poor start again for Southampton tonight. Is there a worse defense in the championship right now?