Originally Posted by
Spudulika
Brooklyn - One of the weakest Irish offerings, if it can be called Irish. I am an admirer of Colm Tobin's prose, though have yet to see him pulled up on his self-loathing and issues with his homeland, that aside, he would be terrified to have his name associated with this made for tv mess. Saoirse Ronan has had a couple of good outings, this is nowhere near good. Domhnall Gleeson, likewise, is a terrific actor, but here he is wasted. Going to see this movie I was excited and eager, I'd bought what PR had been selling. I began to be unsettled when I saw the mish mash of backing the movie needed to be made, never a good sign.. Aside from Julie Walters' over-acting (which was always ready to raise a smile), the movie is torturous, with stilted unrealistic dialogue and "twists", and sadly lacking in charm. Anyone conned into seeing it by sepia coloured images of Ireland or the US/Canada, will feel deeply upset. In the Odeon cinema where I saw this 2 weeks ago, patrons leaving grumbled from "That was a waste of 9 euros" to "That was terrible". What could and should have been an excellent offering is a poorly designed, dud of a dogs dinner.
I came out thinking, unless you have had a full frontal lobotomy, you'll feel cheated by this. If your other half invites you to see it, know your love is being tested and if you survive until the end it's breakfast in bed for life!
1/10 (the 1 I'll give for Julie Walters, and the fact that the movie ended)