I love the expression "Pre Madonna"! Before we were blessed with "Holiday" were footballers different?
I personally wouldn't have Ireland in the starting XI - I think Andy Reid is better suited to a central role or an advanced midfield / playmaking role if we ditch 442. But anyone who thinks our midfield is our strongest point at the moment is seriously deluded.
I honestly think AOB is a bigger loss. I'm perfectly happy with a Dunne / O'Shea combo, but in either's absence I'd be really worried and we need experienced cover.