Bertie & the Catholic Church

Printable View

Show 40 post(s) from this thread on one page

11/11/2005, 3:37 PM
Green Army Girl

Quote:

Originally Posted by anto1208

and i followed it up by calling all religions cults as not to offened just one religion , i see no difference and im still waitng for you to explain the difference ?

cults belive in god ,
cults meet up to talk about there god and to pray to him
cults hand over there money to there leaders to live extravagant lifestyles

you belive in god
you meet up to talk about god and to pray to god
you hand over money to the church so the pope can live in a massive house in his own country:rolleyes: with a bowling alley , swimming pool and enough money a jewlery to feed the whole world

they seem pretty similar to me , i hope you can explain a few difference's

They are similar but then you could call football fans a cult.

They meet up watch a match talk to their mates.

Chant their fav teams anthems

Hand over money to the FAI who we all know have mansions.

But you wouldnt call this a cult because when it comes down to it the word cult is associated with bad things so i dont appreciate people calling my religion a cult there is plenty of other alternatives. Any way your free to leave our catholic cult
11/11/2005, 3:40 PM
Green Army Girl

[QUOTE=anto1208]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Green Army Girl

assumption that it pratices the art of cover up ... did you really say that .. its not an assumption its a fact ... maybe the fact you still dont believe in this cover up proves my brain washed theory .

as i said before i used to be a catolic but when i heard about this when i learned of the industrial schools the magdeline laundries i said thats it these people are nt good people they arent doing Gods work ,i cant make excusses for them and i had to leave all the so called good priest should do the same .

Now look who is trying to brain wash me by putting words in my mouth and the assumption part was that you assumed EVERYBODY was in on it when im sure maybe one or two CATHOLIC priests didnt know.
11/11/2005, 3:41 PM
anto1208

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tired&Emotional

Do a google on it or something....I don't have the time (I have to go boozing in about 10) or, at this stage the will, to educate you on religion, religious cults etc. You could try a past Leaving Cert English higher paper - there must have be a compare & contrast essay question on this before....:rolleyes:

just one difference so ,no cant think of any can you , you cant find one thats why you arent answering nothing to do with the time .

before you point out that cults kill people ill say crusades :rolleyes:
11/11/2005, 3:42 PM
hamish

Kids are told lies everyday even by us like there is a santa..[/QUOTE]

WHAAAAAA???????:eek:

Santa is lies????

My birthday is 25th December

You've just ruined Christmas, ya horrible thing

Nasty. horrible, cruel GAG

Snivel, sob, bo hoo hoo........

No Santy for Hamish and it's GAG's fault

:p :D
11/11/2005, 3:45 PM
Peadar

Quote:

Originally Posted by sirhamish

My birthday is 25th December

You and your niece? That's mad!
11/11/2005, 3:46 PM
Green Army Girl

Quote:

Originally Posted by sirhamish

Kids are told lies everyday even by us like there is a santa..

WHAAAAAA???????

Santa is lies????

My birthday is 25th December

You've just ruined Christmas, ya horrible thing

Nasty. horrible, cruel GAG

Snivel, sob, bo hoo hoo........

No Santy for Hamish and it's GAG's fault

[/QUOTE]

Santa must have been a catholic with all these lies :eek::D
11/11/2005, 3:50 PM
Tired&Emotional

Quote:

Originally Posted by anto1208

just one difference so ,no cant think of any can you , you cant find one thats why you arent answering nothing to do with the time .

before you point out that cults kill people ill say crusades :rolleyes:

It's 16.45 on a Friday evening FFS....I don't work for this Forum....I'm off for a night of drunken debauchery.....and then straight to confession on Monday morning!!:D

Later.....
11/11/2005, 3:50 PM
anto1208

[QUOTE=Green Army Girl]

Quote:

Originally Posted by anto1208

Now look who is trying to brain wash me by putting words in my mouth and the assumption part was that you assumed EVERYBODY was in on it when im sure maybe one or two CATHOLIC priests didnt know.

but my point is they know now , you know now yet you still choose to be a part of it . not only that but you want them to still have a say in our schools .

how can we trust them ever again ? it would be different if the vatican kicked them out of the church , helped the victim but it didnt it turned its back on the victims to protect itself .
11/11/2005, 3:52 PM
John83

Quote:

Originally Posted by Green Army Girl

Santa must have been a catholic with all these lies :eek::D

Can you not format a post properly? The sloppy way you've quoted there makes it look like sirhamish wrote something you did, and then like you've responded with what he posted. I thought he'd gone and double-posted there for a minute. That, at least, I could have understood. :rolleyes:
11/11/2005, 3:55 PM
anto1208

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tired&Emotional

It's 16.45 on a Friday evening FFS....I don't work for this Forum....I'm off for a night of drunken debauchery.....and then straight to confession on Monday morning

Later.....

i rest my case not one single point :rolleyes:

next time dont get so offended unless you know what your getting offended about :rolleyes:

and the joy from my point of veiw, is you have to forgive me !!:cool:
11/11/2005, 3:56 PM
Green Army Girl

Quote:

Originally Posted by John83

Can you not format a post properly? The sloppy way you've quoted there makes it look like sirhamish wrote something you did, and then like you've responded with what he posted. I thought he'd gone and double-posted there for a minute. That, at least, I could have understood. :rolleyes:

I do apologise for my posts not being up to your standards but to be honest i dont give a f*ck
11/11/2005, 3:58 PM
Green Army Girl

[QUOTE=anto1208]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Green Army Girl

but my point is they know now , you know now yet you still choose to be a part of it . not only that but you want them to still have a say in our schools .

how can we trust them ever again ? it would be different if the vatican kicked them out of the church , helped the victim but it didnt it turned its back on the victims to protect itself .

I suppose some people find it easier to forgive thats one of my catholic traits.

I think if every priest resigned then they would be seen as guilty and thats no right
11/11/2005, 3:59 PM
John83

Quote:

Originally Posted by Green Army Girl

Now look who is trying to brain wash me by putting words in my mouth and the assumption part was that you assumed EVERYBODY was in on it when im sure maybe one or two CATHOLIC priests didnt know.

There was a piece in the Tribune two weeks ago about a priest who was Dean at Maynooth (I think) and who brought some news of abuse up to the bishops. He was told to take a year away, then his bishop followed him to Rome and told him he couldn't leave Rome without the man's resignation. His career was destroyed because he reported evidence of abuse to the senior clergy in this country.

Sure, there were plenty of good priests, but feic all of them spoke out, leaving those few who were decent enough to do so hung out to dry. An organisation that's rotten to the core doesn't change overnight.
11/11/2005, 4:01 PM
hamish

Quote:

Originally Posted by Peadar

You and your niece? That's mad!

Great planning Peadar!!!:D

I'll be 52 and Bubbles 20.

Really feeling 52 these days.:eek:
11/11/2005, 4:05 PM
Schumi

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tired&Emotional

i think any responsible parent would, nay should, be taking their children to mass to give them a start in morals, faith etc

What a disgraceful statement. Anyone who doesn't believe in a 'god' is inherently incapable of teaching their children any morals? The only reason that people don't go around doing whatever they want is because some 2000-year-old book tells them not to? What a sad way to live your life.
11/11/2005, 4:08 PM
Green Army Girl

Quote:

Originally Posted by John83

There was a piece in the Tribune two weeks ago about a priest who was Dean at Maynooth (I think) and who brought some news of abuse up to the bishops. He was told to take a year away, then his bishop followed him to Rome and told him he couldn't leave Rome without the man's resignation. His career was destroyed because he reported evidence of abuse to the senior clergy in this country.

Sure, there were plenty of good priests, but feic all of them spoke out, leaving those few who were decent enough to do so hung out to dry. An organisation that's rotten to the core doesn't change overnight.

Do you know im tired of repeating this i never said that there wasnt a cover up obviously there was but this is one story. Its hard for a girl that has been raped to tell anyone and im sure its hard to come to terms with what you might have seen of course you should come forward everytime but it was one priest not the whole of the clergy.

I agree with you that things wont change over night wish i didnt (cos that last mail about my post being all over the place could have been pm to me).But if you feel so strongly about the church never recovering dont kick a man while there down and if that is the case the church are finished then youve got your wish.
11/11/2005, 4:14 PM
hamish

Quote:

Originally Posted by Green Army Girl

to be honest i dont give a f*ck

Still sulking GAG - and it's all your fault.

Don't worry about any technical deficiencies - I'm the worst at that crack in Footyland so you're not the worst.

I've been reading all the above posts. Very good debating. I feel sorry for the priests that really are pastors and are tagged with the "we're all molesters" tags. In the year leading up to my Mum's death, a young local priest used to visit her regularly (ok, ok that's his vocation) - she found him a great comfort.
I was also sick but he never tried to prosletize - if I wanted comfort, he was there if I needed it. I didn't.
It's the arrogant "doff your hat to me if I meet you on the street" shower that I can't stand. One tried to pull that stunt with me not that many years ago and I told him "How do you know what religion I am?" He said back, "I thought you were an RC, did you not see my clothing and show some respect?" I said, "I'm wearing a long black coat, black shirt, black slacks, black shoes - you should have shown respect to me - I could be a Vicar - now fcuk off with yourself - you're in the wrong era - it's not the 50s anymore. You earn repect". I walked off and left him steaming there. the arrogant pr!ck.

The biggest thing that really p!ssed me off was when the current pope issued a dictat to the US bishops NOT to disclose any data to the US courts that might put more paedophiles in trouble. That was an utter, obscene, appalling disgrace and he is no candidate for such an exalted position.
11/11/2005, 4:20 PM
John83
Quote:

Originally Posted by Green Army Girl

Do you know im tired of repeating this i never said that there wasnt a cover up obviously there was but this is one story.

This is one story alright - about the truely rotten state of the entire upper tier clergy in this country.

Quote:

I agree with you that things wont change over night wish i didnt (cos that last mail about my post being all over the place could have been pm to me).

I've read that sentance four times. It still makes no sense. You wish you didn't agree with me that things won't change overnight because I publicly gave out about your post? :confused:

Quote:

But if you feel so strongly about the church never recovering dont kick a man while there down and if that is the case the church are finished then youve got your wish.

Tell me, where did I
- Say that I thought that the church would never recover?
- Kick the church while it is down? :confused:
- Suggest I'd wish the church to be finished?
11/11/2005, 4:31 PM
anto1208

[QUOTE=Green Army Girl]but it was one priest not the whole of the clergy.

I think if every priest resigned then they would be seen as guilty and thats no right

QUOTE]

we all understand it wasnt the whole clergy that abused the kids but it was the whole clergy that covered it up all the way to the top .

i think that if a priest came out and said im so sickened by all this that i cant be part of the church anymore , they wouldnt be seen as guilty at all quite the opposite he would be seen as a man with great moral fibre and currage to stand up and say this isnt right .

the abusers should be locked up in jails not moved parish .
11/11/2005, 10:06 PM
Thunderblaster

If you are unhappy with the Catholic Church, there are other religions out there. There is nobody stopping anybody from converting. Then again, Bertie Ahern could have pledged his allegiance to the 19th Church of the Jesus Christ of Craggy Island.:D

Show 40 post(s) from this thread on one page