Keane back to Spurs!

Printable View

Show 40 post(s) from this thread on one page

02/02/2009, 9:40 PM
tricky_colour

Quote:

Originally Posted by Greenbod

This is an interesting one. As far as I know.....(I may be wrong), Keane would be entitled to a medal were Liverpool to win the league. Would he be allowed play in the last game for Spurs? I mean he could score an o.g to secure himself a winners medal (theoretically).

Going by the results of his previous attempts to score for Liverpool I don't think there is much chance of that happening ;)
02/02/2009, 9:46 PM
tricky_colour

Of course this could be part of a big masterplan by Benitez, to buy the striker of the team Liverpool will face on the last day of the season, then sell him back.

Would Keane also recieve some sort of financial bous if Liverpool win?
02/02/2009, 9:50 PM
NeilMcD

Quote:

Originally Posted by stojkovic

United have scored ONE more goal than Liverpool this season, ONE.

United have the best defensive record in the league.

But dont let the facts cloud your views.

Nothing wrong with having a good defensive record. Utds attitude to games is more attacking than Benitez. In addition Utd have played most of the top four if not all the top four away from home. They have also played many of the other top teams away from home. If you check at the end of the season Utd will have more goals than Liverpool, they have also played one less game than Liverpool. They will win the league with more points more goals and less goals conceded than Liverpool. They will do this buy attacking teams and having a good defensive record. Liverpool fail to beat poor teams at home and some times away because they are not encouraged to take risks. Those are the facts.
02/02/2009, 10:04 PM
seanfhear

Quote:

Originally Posted by NeilMcD

Nothing wrong with having a good defensive record. Utds attitude to games is more attacking than Benitez. In addition Utd have played most of the top four if not all the top four away from home. They have also played many of the other top teams away from home. If you check at the end of the season Utd will have more goals than Liverpool, they have also played one less game than Liverpool. They will win the league with more points more goals and less goals conceded than Liverpool. They will do this buy attacking teams and having a good defensive record. Liverpool fail to beat poor teams at home and some times away because they are not encouraged to take risks. Those are the facts.

You just saved me a load of typing.
02/02/2009, 10:07 PM
rambler14

All I hope is that he didn't sell his house in London!
02/02/2009, 10:11 PM
Maroon 7

Quote:

Originally Posted by NeilMcD

Nothing wrong with having a good defensive record. Utds attitude to games is more attacking than Benitez. In addition Utd have played most of the top four if not all the top four away from home. They have also played many of the other top teams away from home.

So have Liverpool in fairness apart from playing United themselves. They've already been to Chelsea, Arsenal, Villa, Everton, etc.
02/02/2009, 10:13 PM
NeilMcD

Quote:

Originally Posted by rambler14

All I hope is that he didn't sell his house in London!

Why not the market has shot down since then so for his sake he would have been better off selling it and renting for a while in London and not buying for until late next year.
02/02/2009, 10:18 PM
Torn-Ado

Quote:

Originally Posted by Razors left peg

Looks like Defoe is going to be out for a long time, some reports saying for rest of season. Either way Robbie is a better player than Defoe anyway. Defoe is a good finisher but very lazy in my opinion

Just after seeing there that he is out until April. Didn't think it was that serious an injury.
02/02/2009, 10:24 PM
EastTerracer

Quote:

Originally Posted by dr_peepee

Elroy and Stuttgart88... There was a fork in the road. If heading back to Spurs wasn't the easy way what was??? Do you not agree that Spurs=Comfort zone for Robbie Keane?

Genuinely I don't think this is Robbie's choice. I think he would have preferred to stay at Liverpool and fight for his place but he could only do that if he was going to be given a chance. All his sources in the press were suggesting last week that he wanted to stay.

Robbie didn't ask for the transfer - Liverpool told him we've agreed a fee with Tottenham and Rafa has no doubt told him he didn't want him. As far as I can see he was forced out.

There is no doubt he had some shocking games for Liverpool but in the last six weeks (the Everton Cup game apart) I think he was getting it together and had started to get a few goals. That's what makes it so strange that he wasn't getting a look in.

If he had played for Liverpool under a different manager I think he would have had every chance of succeeding at Liverpool.
02/02/2009, 10:29 PM
eirebhoy

Quote:

Originally Posted by dr_peepee

Elroy and Stuttgart88... There was a fork in the road. If heading back to Spurs wasn't the easy way what was??? Do you not agree that Spurs=Comfort zone for Robbie Keane?

I've no doubt he would have ended up there or there abouts eventually, but so soon?? I know he was never gonna be a legend, but I'm telling ye Peter Crouch is gonna be recieved better at Anfeild than Keane ever will now.. Rightly so, too based on what was seen in Red... That's what galling for me.

Regardless of how he got there and whether Benitez liked it or not Keane would have got games between now and May. Benitez doesn't know if he wants a sh!t or a haircut from one minute to the next.... He'd have got in. His career wouldn't have been on hold. A whole four months??? We're talking Hours even minutes toward the end of the window and what depth have Liverpool got? His Ireland place is secure? No major tournament in the Summer?

Alonso was treated just as bad just as publicly by Benitez. And compare contrast all ye want, but if he'd wanted after what was said/printed/admited had he made all the right noises, Alonso could have left Liverpool for a fraction of the price he's valued at to spite Rafa. But he didn't. I firmly believe Alonso plays, and plays well, for Liverool in spite of Benitez not for him.

It was all to fight for there for Robbie, but he took the first option out. He's gone down in my estimation and with respect to most of yiz, nothing I read thus far, or I believe anything I read going forward is going to change that... Robbie Keane'll get the same cheer as Kevin Doyle or any other Irish player in Croker from me. Not a decibel more or less.

Good post in fairness. As much as I'd have loved Maloney back at Celtic, I was disappointed he wanted to leave Villa as I didn't want him seen as a failure there. I think that's similar but for some reason I don't care about Keane being seen a failure at Liverpool.
03/02/2009, 12:11 AM
Closed Account

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ciaran

Doesn't this make Keane the most expensive player in combined transfers in the history of the game?

I doubt it? Whats his current total?

Anelka is on about 86million. Think he replaced Seba Veron when he moved to Chelsea.(on the money stakes, not literally)
03/02/2009, 12:30 AM
John83

Quote:

Originally Posted by joe_denilson

I doubt it? Whats his current total?

Anelka is on about 86million. Think he replaced Seba Veron when he moved to Chelsea.(on the money stakes, not literally)

Wolves-Coventry-Inter-Leeds-Spurs-Liverpool-Spurs
6+13+12+7+19+12 = STG�71M*
One more transfer and he might do it.

*Figures from his wikipedia article.
03/02/2009, 8:55 AM
old git

Quote:

Originally Posted by shakermaker1982

Keane heading back to WHL with his tail between his legs. Robbie has discovered to his cost that the grass isn't always greener. Looking forward to finding out on his views on old rat face Benitez.

yeah should be very intresting to see what keane says about benitez.. on the other side what will spurs fans think of robbie judas keane returning less than six months after joining his boyhood dream club an oppurtunity he could not turn down :D:D
03/02/2009, 9:28 AM
old git

Quote:

Originally Posted by Noelys Guitar

Last game of the season for Spurs is Liverpool away! Imagine if Liverpool are within 3 points of United (or the more likely scenario of fighting for a champions league place). Keane could come back to haunt them.

i'm sure liverpool put clause in deal that keane cannot play in this match ... ::confused: if not it could be a disaster for benitiz
03/02/2009, 9:28 AM
DeLorean

Quote:

Originally Posted by old git

yeah should be very intresting to see what keane says about benitez.. on the other side what will spurs fans think of robbie judas keane returning less than six months after joining his boyhood dream club an oppurtunity he could not turn down :D:D

They interviewed quite a few of them on Sky Sports News last night and they were thrilled to have him back. The way they see it he's a legend at the club and they have him back for less than they sold him. A couple said they were a bit disappointed with him leaving but are still glad he's back. Anyway when Spurs played Pool in the PL earlier in the season Keane got a rousing reception from the Spurs fans. It started in a few boos but was completely drowned out by the rest of the crowd who actually stood up in applause.
03/02/2009, 10:09 AM
lionelhutz

Quote:

Originally Posted by old git

i'm sure liverpool put clause in deal that keane cannot play in this match ... ::confused: if not it could be a disaster for benitiz

I don't think you're allowed put a clause like that in a permanent move. I've seen it many a time in loan moves but not permanent ones. Would that be right?
03/02/2009, 10:25 AM
limerickblue

The Spurs fans will be delighted to have one of there legends back at the club,he did score more 80 goals.
Nobody can blame a player for jumping at the oppurtunity to play for there boyhood club, I would jump at the chance to play for my boyhood team Doncaster rovers.
I also think that this transfer can not come at a better time for Ireland as at least Keane will get some shooting practise on the field now:p , before our little game in Italy, The only good thing about him being at Liverpool is at least he had liitle chane of getting injured.
03/02/2009, 10:40 AM
Den Perry

The only good thing about him being at Liverpool is at least he had liitle chane of getting injured.[/QUOTE].....

but he did have to live there...
03/02/2009, 11:11 AM
DeLorean

Quote:

Originally Posted by lionelhutz

I don't think you're allowed put a clause like that in a permanent move. I've seen it many a time in loan moves but not permanent ones. Would that be right?

Yes, and the loan deals are more clear cut now as well, u can't play against the team that owns u, simple as that.
03/02/2009, 11:14 AM
drummerboy

Despite Keane scoring over 100 goals for Spurs there is still a minority of the supporters who regard him as “The Green Judas”. However I think he will be well received by most of the supporters.
03/02/2009, 11:34 AM
paul_oshea

would be killer if keane played in that game scored 2 goals and denied liverpool top spot. Would absoloutely love it.
03/02/2009, 12:15 PM
endabob1

Liverpool won't be within 10 points of Utd by then so it will be irrelevant.

There is a large minority who are not jumping up and down at the return of the "green Judas" personally I'm happy he's back but until defoe was signed off for the rest of the season I didn't see the sense in it
03/02/2009, 12:26 PM
Paddywhackspurs

Keano

Oh happy days :d:d:d:d:d:d
03/02/2009, 12:39 PM
Scram

Quote:

Originally Posted by paul_oshea

would be killer if keane played in that game scored 2 goals and denied liverpool top spot. Would absoloutely love it.

A bitter and twisted wish...................I was hoping for a hat trick with the same result! :)

Until Benitez leaves Liverpool I wish them no luck. The way he treated Robbie was appalling.
03/02/2009, 1:16 PM
tricky_colour

I wonder who took his spot in the car park and whether he will get it back?
03/02/2009, 1:50 PM
rambler14

What number will he be?
03/02/2009, 2:11 PM
limerickblue

I heard that jaime o. hara left a number 7 liverpool shirt in his locker, I guess he will never want to see number 7 again anyway.
Liverpool havnt had a good number 7 in awhile
03/02/2009, 2:12 PM
rambler14

He was 7 at Leeds, Inter and Liverpool and he was crap so never agian IMO.
03/02/2009, 3:34 PM
Greenbod

Quote:

Originally Posted by aidz1

ideally i would love to see keane score goals in the green jersey of ireland.....

that goes without saying..............the context of the conversation was his move from Liverpool to Spurs.
03/02/2009, 3:38 PM
ArdeeBhoy

More fool, Robbie!

But then the grass wasn't greener when he went to play with the big boys.

Just hope it sees an improvement in his abject form for Ireland ??
03/02/2009, 3:59 PM
sadloserkid

Played for two big clubs in his career and has failed utterly at both (circumstances will be forgotten in time). Taking the Irish glasses off for a second he'll have to go down as one of the great Premiership flops surely?
03/02/2009, 4:02 PM
irishfan86

Quote:

Originally Posted by sadloserkid

Played for two big clubs in his career and has failed utterly at both (circumstances will be forgotten in time). Taking the Irish glasses off for a second he'll have to go down as one of the great Premiership flops surely?

I think the majority of neutral opinion sides with Robbie.

He was either a pawn in a contract negotiation, or Benitez really didn't know what player he was buying.
03/02/2009, 4:13 PM
DeLorean

Quote:

Originally Posted by sadloserkid

Taking the Irish glasses off for a second he'll have to go down as one of the great Premiership flops surely?

Yes, an absolute legend at the club where he spent the majority of his PL days. 110 goals in 293 PL games and God knows how many of those games he came on/went off as sub. One of the great PL flops indeed, I'd have him third behind Jo and Ade Akinbiyi
03/02/2009, 4:26 PM
jbyrne

Quote:

Originally Posted by sadloserkid

Played for two big clubs in his career and has failed utterly at both (circumstances will be forgotten in time). Taking the Irish glasses off for a second he'll have to go down as one of the great Premiership flops surely?

what drivel
03/02/2009, 5:32 PM
Stuttgart88

Benitez was just on BBC radio saying that Keane couldn't handle the pressure of a big club.

It's not as if Benitez did anything to take the pressure off him. My opinion of Benitez is even lower today than it was yesterday.

I think any no. 10 type forward would struggle at Liverpool under Benitez. It's all about Torres and Gerrard up there with no room for anyone else with a strong personality.

Dirk Kuyt is mediocrity personified (though his early season form was very good). Ryan Babbel is a talented player who has done eff all at Liverpool and Benitez' full back purchases have typically been rubbish. It seems that Benitez is prepared to treat some players differently to others.

By the way, Robbie is nowhere near a favourite Irish player of mine so I'm resaonably objective.
03/02/2009, 7:15 PM
Morbo

Quote:

Originally Posted by dr_peepee

If he goes through with it I'm finished with him...

I'm sure Keane will be heartbroken, I didn't realise ye were an item

Quote:

Originally Posted by dr_peepee

I'd say you were right if it were this time next year and we had a major tournament looming... He has nothing to loose by trying to stick it out and do himself justice at the club. His Irish place is secure. Despite Liverpools treatment of him they're still light up front and have an injury prone main man (thus far this season). Gerard has some of the feild stuff to deal with. There's Champions league, FA Cup and league games left so there's plenty of oppertunities to give Benitez a metaphorical two fingers. Rafas not in a position to ignore him totally purely from players perspective. Yeah it's true Rafa's had cheap shots at him. Only when he'd everyone fit?? And how often has that happened.You have to be man enough to power through it.. Big enough to admint that you have under performed.... And he has under performed.

We may not have a major tournament looming but we got major qualification games comming up against Italy and Bulgaria and I for one am glad that he will be getting first team football rather than rotting away in the Liverpool reserves. Its true that he had some poor games but even when he played well he was virtually guaranteed to be subbed around the 60 minute mark whilst players playing much worse than him like Kuyt were untouchable. Even when he started to hit a bit of form and score 3 goals in 2 games, what does Benitez do? Bench him. The final straw was dropping him from the bench against Chelsea, it was obvious that Keane was never going to get a fair shot under Benetez and in my opinion it was the best thing for both him and Ireland to get the hell out of there.

He will be 29 in the summer and he probably only has a few years left at the top of his game, he can't be wasting half a season sitting in the reserves hoping that Betitez will be gone in the summer and what if he doesn't go? time is precious at this stage of his career and for me its a no-brainer to move to a club where you will get first team football. It may be the easy option but IMO it is also the smart option, I also don't give a crap how he is remembered at Anfield, all that matters to me is that he will be sharp for the upcomming qualifiers.
03/02/2009, 7:22 PM
NeilMcD

Great post Morbo, hit the nail on the head.
03/02/2009, 7:25 PM
DeLorean

Quote:

Originally Posted by NeilMcD

Great post Morbo, hit the nail on the head.

I'll echo that
03/02/2009, 7:27 PM
Sligo Hornet

Quote:

Originally Posted by paul_oshea

would be killer if keane played in that game scored 2 goals and denied liverpool top spot. Would absoloutely love it.

So would I!!!..........apart from the fact I hate Spurs:(
03/02/2009, 9:13 PM
rambler14

It's like he never left.
Robbie will captain Spurs whenever Ledley King isn't playing which won't be very often!

Show 40 post(s) from this thread on one page