Printable View
I have never, ever witnessed a scene like the one Nesta described above. If anything, I've seen more scorn the other way (and by that, I mean a tiny amount).
We're also way off the OP. Does anyone know, with anything approaching certainty, of a club that has an interest in trying to get into the FD? GUST obviously want back in, we've know that for a while, but anyone else? Is it just the FAI going through the motions?
Damn UCD fans looking for evidence based information - will i get away without referencing? Its all on the attendance thread....
Taken from week 19
Tallaght: 2927
Sligo: 2621
Cork: 1979
Limerick: 1942
Top 4 attendances at the to 4 grounds.
Dundalk: 1760
Derry: 1588
Bohs: 1552
Pats: 1368
Shels: 1041
Bray: 959
Drogs: 893
UCD: 420
Ok Pats are a fly in the ointment with a decent ground and top of the league - just a strange one when european games indicate an ability to attract more.
Dundalk (excluding away section), Derry, Bohs, and Shels for one reason or another are mediocre grounds with the Brandywell the best of the three. Bray and Drogs next. With UCD again an odd one to call as the Bowl is fine for purpose but small, open and lacking atmosphere - Drogs ground is in a bad state but generates a cracking atmosphere so there are variable to consider!
I know weve move off thread but Super Sundays on Sky ive seen plenty of incidents ive described and not being resident in Dundalk it is not just a Dundalk experience!Quote:
Originally Posted by NeverFeltBetter
Up to this season you would get strange looks and questions off people if you sat in a pub in a limerick fc jersey. Do you really support them? Thought they were ****e? Does anyone actually go to games?
Now a lot more people seem to find it a bit more understanding why you'd go to a limerick match. Better facilities, better players, a higher standard. Slowly but surely more people are coming around to the fact that limerick fc represent their city. A bit of success like a cup or title challenge could really see it take off.
Typical for us though just as we start to take off and get more press the hurlers win the Munster title and are in the all Ireland semi-finals, totally dominating the local press and attention of the public.
Has their been any attempt to revive the clubs that went to the wall ? (kilkenny, kildare, Monaghan etc )
Is this invitation just a stab in the dark that their just might be a club willing to step up ? surly the first division cannot survive the way it is.
Monaghan have a team in an Ulster league don't they?
An attempt by who? Kildare and Monaghan ran by small committees who found out they couldn't do the job properly. Kilkenny was a one man club to all intents and purpposes. Fine man, but that's never going to be a way to run a club.Quote:
Originally Posted by Kiki Balboa
Oh and if the barrier to any club joining is a 19k affiliation fee, then they shouldn't be looking at playing in a national league anyway.
You've completely missed the point though. You've said the clubs with the best attendances have the best grounds, therefore good grounds are vital. But the clubs with the best attendances also have "Rovers" in their name, so similar logic would show it's vital to have "Rovers" in your club's name.Quote:
Originally Posted by Nesta99
You've shown no correlation between having a decent ground and having high attendances. That's my point.
I don't doubt that ground improvements are good for the league in general, but you can't just show a coincidence and say that there's causation. Maybe it's because the clubs have the best attendances - and therefore more money, helped by European qualification, that they have better grounds?
Can Premier Division clubs enter B teams into the first division?
What i siad was that the clubs with the best grounds have the highest attendences with no mention of a good ground being vital - i acknowledged that there are variables and animolies to this but it is a factual point going on the information that is in the attendances thread is it not? Causition or co-incidence has nothing to do with the point i was making.
I was making the point that perception is the predominant issue with LoI and while there are many many theories on how perception can be improved; some of those theories put into action eg summer season, the only feasable 'quick fix' that i can see is to get the Sky treatment similar to where other sports have been reinvigorated, darts being the example i used.
Secondary to that infrastructure plays a role to perception, in particular when comparisons are constanly there in the forms of SPL, lower English league grounds and indeed some of the Irish league grounds! as an aside more than anything i noted the better gates in LoI are at the better stadia. Such infrastructure is not feasably improvable in most part in the foreasble future - hence my sky sports opinion in making it trendy is one of the few open options. The basis of a sellable product is there.
Yes i agree with you that if UCD had the best ground in the league that would not necessarily improve gates as in some cases a club is what is and there is limited scope to grow. It is quite difficult to prove that improved facilities has not caused improved gates at the top 4 examples given either. To suggest that it may only be co-incidence that improved attendance for Limerick happened and is not due to Thomand is not very scientific either. Sligo are constantly improving and expanding the seating capacity at the Showgrounds and have sold out a number of times, greater capacity = bigger attendence for sell outs. If Dundalk improve the away section more away fans would attend(all boycotting fans would be happy to return) - causation or co-incidence?
I havent missed you point nor have stated something that isnt backed up unles i was giving a personal opinion!
On topic I do think that some former league members should be approached to see if there is a possibility to return. Monaghan is a good example where they could do something similar to Wexford Youths bringing players throught the local setup. Newbridge, Tralee, Kilkenny, GUST, Fanad, Navan maybe, Castlebar, Thurles, Mullingar, Cavan Town, Carlow? could have involvement in some guise if incentivised with, for example, amatuer membership fee for those fielding amatuer teams? How to structure a league is another story but imo Junior clubs should have a more direct route to Senior football and it should be a finincial benefit not a cost burden therefore a restructuring of not only membership fees but also prize monies. all ifs and buts i know but if junior football thought there might be even just a few quid for them in a restructuring they may not be so quick to outvote senior clubs on proper nationwide footbaling issues.
Would the lack of promotion/relegation have any impact on the status of the league? Would it put places in UEFA competitions in jeopardy?Quote:
Originally Posted by TheBoss
FIFA has a section in its statutes about sporting integrity which mentions the principle of promotion and relegation. This may be why the FAI is so set against a one-division league.
I tend to glance over most posts on this site but Cavan Town got my attention. Seriously? I can't be arsed with reading your post in full but it's probably pure moon man stuff. Cavan Town!Quote:
Originally Posted by Nesta99
One thing you could be sure of with Cavan Town is they're never going to spend beyond their means.
Note the question mark after the sentence! Cootehill more to your likeing then?
I can see it now, Cavan Town UltrasQuote:
Originally Posted by Sean South
They needn't be worried about that. The FAI have a great track record of wilfully ignoring dodgy finances.Quote:
Originally Posted by Charlie Darwin
I meant more in terms of the Revenue. I doubt any LSL clubs document any of the payments they make to players and all concerned would like to keep it that way.Quote:
Originally Posted by gufcfan
So a armature club just happens to have €19k lying about before they even consider other expenses like wages, food, travelling, accommodation, match day expenses?Quote:
Originally Posted by Dodge
Where exactly does this €19k go anyhow?
Regarding the invitation for new clubs this is just the FAI's lazy half assed attempt to say they tried to solve the problem. They do this and don't have to sit down with the club and actually discuss the problem..
From going to college in Cavan I can safely say there will never be a LOI team in Cavan. They don'y even know what the LOI is and thats no joke.
Outside of Dublin, there should be a close correlation between the various schoolboy leagues and league of Ireland clubs. Football at schoolboy has a very high participation rate and is well organised in many cases. In the north east, Drogheda are going quite a bit of work with Meath clubs, while Dundalk have worked to develop links with clubs in south Monaghan and east Cavan. The lack of money in the game and the failure of the FAI to understand the importance of a proper pyramid structure is hampering these efforts.