Re: Re: ......................................
Quote:
Originally posted by DruggyDrog
Hibs were set up by Irish businessmen, who then tried to restrict the numbers of irish joining (basically because most Irish were toopoor!).
Celtic were set up for the poor. Big difference in terms of becoming part of a community. The links between Ireland and the east end of glasgow go back way before any football club was founded, so the links existed befoer 1888. As has already been said, people aren't going to change their minds on this issue, so I'll just leave it at that!!
What a load of misconstrued madey up pish. If anything, it was the other way around. Hibernian were found by Catholic Priests, under the auspices of the CYMS, Celtic were formed by Catholic Businessmen who saw a good idea and copied it, signing Hibs players and even the Hibs supporting Brother Walfrid in their first 'season'.
Did you know, Brother Walfrid and his charitable arm lasted only a very short time at Celtic?
'Restrict the Irish membership', that is a laughable and totally ridiculous stsatement. Go on, tell me where you got that one. The founders of my club were, to a man, Irish Catholics living in Scotland. Can Celtic say the same?
Re: Re: ......................................
Quote:
Originally posted by DruggyDrog
Hibs were set up by Irish businessmen, who then tried to restrict the numbers of irish joining (basically because most Irish were toopoor!).
Celtic were set up for the poor. Big difference in terms of becoming part of a community. The links between Ireland and the east end of glasgow go back way before any football club was founded, so the links existed befoer 1888. As has already been said, people aren't going to change their minds on this issue, so I'll just leave it at that!!
http://www.foot.ie/t11886.htm
I'm sorry to destroy you're rather confused version of history but there is a brief description of Hibs origins on this other thread.
The thought that Hibs were set up by Irish businessman, who then decided to restrict the numbers of 'poor Irish' is quite laughable:D
I'd agree Celtic were indeed set up in 1888 for the noble reason of feeding the hungry poor of the East End of Glasgow, though by the time Scottish football went professional in 1890, Celtic were a limited liability company where profit and loss was the dominant factor.
I see nothing inherently wrong in that, as by the time Hibs were re-established in 1893, they were also a limited liabilty company.
Neither club, as I can see can claim any right to some 'moral high ground', they both just adapted to professional football and the change in society in late Victorian Britain.
Re: ......................................
Quote:
Originally posted by A face
[B]
Burn the Wolfetones .... god no .... they are a great band. Legends even ..... great stuff the tones like !! :D
So you're not going to burn all Celtic fans then :rolleyes:
Re: Re: ......................................
Quote:
Originally posted by DruggyDrog
Hibs were set up by Irish businessmen,
Celtic were set up for the poor. Big difference in terms of becoming part of a community.
Other way round.