Originally Posted by
Gather round
Indeed, I'm 100% Irish. Presumably you are too. Clearly no-one can be 101% thus.
My assertions were pretty much self-evident. You chose to avoid them because they contradict your version of Irishness. Which, if you'll forgive me, is exclusive and a bit simplistic.
Er, quite. I made quite clear my lack of any identity with the modern Irish Republic state. I have lived in it, and visit regularly, but could say the same of Germany.
Not quite. I recognise your identity as real (valid?) enough, but it isn't definitive because there are other Irish identities which are equally valid.
No offence taken, but this is just baloney. Your identity isn't superior to anyone else's. It's just your identity. At the crudest level, a means of distinguishing your group of people from others.
No-one's saying they are identical. What do you seem to be saying and claiming is some sort of exclusive right, like a trade mark, to be Irish. I'm rejecting this as self-eivdently wrong and so fairly absurd.
No, it would be equally correct. All you're doing is finding increasingly convoluted ways to repeat over and over that 'our side are better [ie, more Irish] than themmuns'. You aren't. We're all equally Irish.
You go ahead and distinguish if you must, it's a free country. Or rather, two free countries.
Less an argument than a crude prejudice. Ulster Unionism as a political movement has one basic objective which it has achieved pretty well since the 1920s: staying out of the Irish Free State/ Republic. Who cares what Wolfe Tone and Henry Joy did 200 years ago?
You do realise that support for republicanism in Britain overall (ie a Republic of Britain, not Sinn Fein) is currently running at about 15%? While I imagine it's rather lower than that amongst Ulster unionists, probably not at the 0.001% level you exaggerate for effect above. Put simply, unionists don't want to be forced out of their own country- that doesn't make us all slavish monarchists.
Your whole attitude to this issue- exclusive and dismissive as self-described above does you no favors. For all the effort at legal, psychological and other high-falutin' explanation your analysis is pretty simplistic. And indeed denial. Any further up the Egyptian river and you'd be looking down from the snows of Kilimanjaro.
I predict you will finish second with 22 or 23 points and enter the play-offs, as alas for you Sweden are likely to qualify automaticaly as the best runner-up.