It's junior soccer not the premiership.What about if a referee doesnt give a penalty,does give a penalty.allows a goal that was offside stand.You cant appeal these decisions.You get on with it.Quote:
Originally Posted by gaidin
Printable View
It's junior soccer not the premiership.What about if a referee doesnt give a penalty,does give a penalty.allows a goal that was offside stand.You cant appeal these decisions.You get on with it.Quote:
Originally Posted by gaidin
Junior or Premiership it doesn't matter. If people are allowed to break the rules when they want then whats the point in even playing football.
jesus, just when i was going to collect my winnings!
balla played shannon after the granville game two weeks ago (i think it was in the cup), and granville again in the league - how many matches did he get and did he play against shannon and granville
Just back from training...we have heard nothing about this as far as we know we are getting the cup sunday morning this has put a downer on the season...torres09 you came last week and , claimed "balla to do star a favour????????????????????????????" which they certainly didn't last night, so back it up where are you getting your "info" from. Myabe your right i hope your not clearly.
So was this player suspended for the shannon game also and could they object to that result? This is going to get messy.
Abbeyvale's silence is deafening...
Congrats to Croom on staying up. Very impressive form shown in the run in.
Have heard now there is a rumbling of something happening...we are not going to be getting the cup on Sunday...but ya if he was suspended against us aswell and played then of course we'll put
in an appeal/objection/ or whatever is protocal... Between this and the whole pike situation in the FAI the soccer in Limerick has gone ars*ways...why can't a sending off for two yellow mean you miss your next game regardless straight red you miss your next game and then after the refs report further action can be decided....
It's just so frustrating to have been crowned champions and now this...we were offered the cup last night at shelbourne park but because we weren't all there we decided to wait till Sunday.
Happy Friday
Sending off is an automatic one match ban and when they get the refs report two yellows is another one added on.
A straight red is a three match ban and im sorry to tell you this shannon man but its too late for ye to object as the time frame has passed for any objection.
Dont know anything about an objection lads.Quote:
Originally Posted by torres09
We got confimation last night that there is an objection gone in.......Quote:
Originally Posted by abbeyvale
Balla played Granville last Thursday evening 29th April, which was there last game played before they played Star, so if he was sent off v Granville he would have been illegal v Star as you automatically miss the next game after being sent off, maybe thats what the objection is about, but like I said I haven't heard anything about it from our club, so as it stands congrats to Shannon.Quote:
Originally Posted by torres09
Quick question....what would the outcome be if he was illegal? would Star be awarded the 3pts?
Well there wouldn't be much point appealing if you weren't going to get the three points.Quote:
Originally Posted by abbeyvale
True, but could the LDMC force a replay?Quote:
Originally Posted by shannonman
(Max Pts) Team Pl W D L F A Pts
Shannon Town 22 14 4 4 49 25 46.......Promoted
Star Rvs 22 13 6 3 59 28 45............Promoted
Caherdavin Celtic 21 11 6 4 45 22 39
Summerville Rvs 22 10 7 5 35 19 37
Granville Rgs 22 10 5 7 33 25 35
Charleville 21 8 5 8 29 28 29
Janesboro B 22 8 4 10 37 52 28
Ballynanty Rvs 22 7 6 9 37 36 27
Croom Utd 22 8 3 11 38 57 27
Prospect Priory 22 7 2 13 22 35 23
Dromore Celtic 22 6 3 13 30 45 21...............Relegated
Herbertstown 22 3 1 18 21 53 10...............Relegated
Result
Thursday 06/05/10
Janesboro 2-1 Prospect Priory
Caherdavin Celtic ?-? Charleville, (anyone have this result?)
Granville Rgs 0-1 Summerville Rvs,
Ballynanty Rvs 0-0 Star Rvs,
Dromore Celtic 1-2 Croom Utd,
Doubt that...seems pretty cut and shut..if they played an illegal player then ye'll the three points and be champions if not it stays as it is now....Quote:
Originally Posted by abbeyvale
cant wait to see what way the LDMC deal with this mess, will balla have any punishment from this. I mean its not like they didnt know he was sent off therefore illegal to play against star. there can be no winner from this its not the right way to win the league or lose it. both teams shannon and star will in some way feel robbed after putting in a great effort to win the league for the last 8 months.Quote:
Originally Posted by shannonman
Got some info on this...The player WAS sent off against Granville but it was the cup game which was played 3 weeks ago. Since then Balla have played Shannon, Granville and Star in the league. The player did NOT play against Shannon as Balla thought this was his 1 game automatic suspension. They didnt get any letter from LDMC to say he was suspended for anymore games so he played against Granville and then Star in the league..
This could turn out bad for Balla cos if they lose all those points they could get relegated
This is going to get very messy so....but that said..he served a game ban(against us) then surely if they dont recieve a letter then thats it....Im pretty niave on the rules and regulations
if he did not play against shannon and that was his next game then that would have been his automatic 1 match ban.if they got no confirmation from ldmc then he was ok to play against star.:ball::ball::island:Quote:
Originally Posted by gaidin
Ya thats what they are saying..LDMC sent them no confirmation of any ban so his automatic game was against shannon which he didnt play in...LDMC should get this sorted as soon as possible..
It looks like the referee put in no report otherwise Balla would have got something in writing if this is the case the player was free to play away.
What makes you say the referee put in no report?
are you on the ldmc committee??..lolQuote:
Originally Posted by shannonman
Lads to be honest, I dont care what happens, as long as we got promoted, the medals are dust collectors and the trophy is an excuse for a **** up, so its all the one really.............it would have been a different story if we needed the 3pts to win promotion, but lets be honest about, when we are playing Prem next season nobody remembers who came up as champions or runners up from 1A.Quote:
Originally Posted by blueboy2
Fair enough AV but someone clearly does care...enough to make an objection....and now this drags on instead of getting the trophy tomorrow we are now playing a waiting game...which if ye have a case is fair enough but if not it just seems petty... We have become fairly well aquainted Alan and I think we are pretty honest when we come to what we say on here you have to see our point of view and how frustrating it has become as I said if ye have a case fair enough but if not someone needs to have a look at themselves.Quote:
Originally Posted by abbeyvale
al lets be honest here everyone likes to go up as champions especially when ye had it in yere own hands.you went on many a **** up too.:DQuote:
Originally Posted by abbeyvale
Caherdavin 7-0 Charleville.Quote:
Originally Posted by abbeyvale
Charleville B are much stronger than their A team from what ive seen. Can see a lot of the B team moving up to A next season.
I will put it straight to ye lads NO REPORT NO BAN if the whole of the L.D.M.C. was at the match when the player was sent off theres nothing they could do until they got it in writing.
Good luck to both teams yere up i wouldent be worried about who won the league if i was ye i would be worried about where yere going to get the players to keep ye up there.
Who said there was no report?Quote:
Originally Posted by blueboy2
Did the LDMC say there was no report?
Has anyone asked the ref did he submit a report and if he didn't, why not and if he did where did it go?
Agree promotion is the aim for any competitive team and the prize of going to prem is a good one but when you look back on your football its gotta be nice to say i won something because winning medals in the prem is no easy task when you dont have the resources of the top teams, Most teams that go prem struggle within a year or two and slip back down to 1A or worse look at abbey those guys will still be looking at 1A winners medals but the club is in freefall....Quote:
Originally Posted by serpico
If balla played an illegal player then Star are right to appeal the decision but if the appeal is incorrect and the player served his ban already then at least it shows that people give a sh#t
shannonman. have ye heard anything yet from league ... when will decision be made about objectionQuote:
Originally Posted by shannonman
Heard nothing...i would assume a decision will be made tonight....not sure thoughQuote:
Originally Posted by old git
(Max Pts) Team Pl W D L F A Pts
Shannon Town 22 14 4 4 49 25 46.......Promoted
Star Rvs 22 13 6 3 59 28 45............Promoted
Caherdavin Celtic 22 12 6 4 52 22 42
Summerville Rvs 22 10 7 5 35 19 37
Granville Rgs 22 10 5 7 33 25 35
Charleville 22 8 5 9 29 35 29
Janesboro B 22 8 4 10 37 52 28
Ballynanty Rvs 22 7 6 9 37 36 27
Croom Utd 22 8 3 11 38 57 27
Prospect Priory 22 7 2 13 22 35 23
Dromore Celtic 22 6 3 13 30 45 21...............Relegated
Herbertstown 22 3 1 18 21 53 10...............Relegated
Final Table prior to objection being resolved.
Any update with the objection? Have the LDMC looked at it?
I was told it'll be next Monday before we know anything...Quote:
Originally Posted by gaidin
You'd wonder why so long.
They have to go through all the Referees reports and check and see what was sent out fines and suspensions and the dates on them.
Heard Star just "won" the league....
Quote:
Originally Posted by shannonman
Fair and square?
The biggest waste of peoples time this season.A meaningless objection which results in a huge anti-climax in the second highest division in Limerick.Must feel sorry for Shannon Town who did absoloutely nothing wrong and ended up with more points after 22 games!!! Bad form really.Where will the managerless Star go and collect the trophy and after 9 months of football and hard slogging it's a shame that it ends like this.I think they would have gained more respect if they did the right thing and leave Shannon enjoy the league victory.I guess the 48 hr objection time is surely gone is it??Quote:
Originally Posted by shannonman
Quote:
Originally Posted by shannonman
This is an absolute joke, the limerick commity have ruined another good season of football, nothing new there then!!