Quote:
Originally Posted by NeilMcD
I'd like to see McGeady given a full game on the right hand side.
Printable View
Quote:
Originally Posted by NeilMcD
I'd like to see McGeady given a full game on the right hand side.
With left back being a problem why not play Finnan there? He's a much better option than anyone else for that position and we have more solid players to play right back than we do left back.
Quote:
Originally Posted by colster
I agree. I know that he's been playing on the left side for Celtic but he seems to equally comfortable on either side and he's definitely worth a start in a few friendlies. With him on the right and duff on the left we'd have 2 wingers playing that are nearly as comfortable on their supposed weak side as they are on their stronger side. They could swap sides to great effect during the course of matches just to keep the opposition full backs on their toes. I know this is something we tried under Kerr with varying degrees of success but the difference here is that he was trying it with Kilbane or more often Andy Reid. Both of these players are very one sided which diminished the attacking threat if they were attacking down the right side during the course of a match. If the defender has to face a player that is equally comfortable on either side it poses him with a much more difficult situation. I don't think it should be underestimated how much of a plus having 2 wingers on the opposing flanks that are so comfortable on either foot could be to us.
Stick Joey O'Brien on the right side of midfield
Mcgeady for right midfield surely?
Definetly in with a big shout.....Quote:
Originally Posted by as_i_say
Given
Finnan Dunne ? O Shea
J O Brien Ireland S Reid Duff
Robbie Keane Doyle
My new look Ireland team, 3 new starters and I'd throw them straight in. I'd have O'Shea over Kilbane any day at LB which doesn't say much about either player.
I'm not sold on O'Brien at the back, this is one position we do need reinforcing.
While Dunne has had the more outstanding games, O'Brien has never set a foot wrong for Ireland and doesn't deserved to be dropped.
Errr, much as I'd like 2 Duffs, we've only got the one!Quote:
Originally Posted by shakermaker1982
sorry must be still asleep I meant Robbie Keane!!!
Quote:
Originally Posted by eirebhoy
I'm just going on club form. I've seen O'Brien as solid as a rock and then other games he's rocking and is a huge liability. Dunne is not the quickest defender in the world but he has been outstanding for City this season. Have we got any young lads coming through that might play at CB? Any Paul McGrath offspring ready to wear the green shirt? Fingers crossed!!
We have Paddy McCarthy and Paul McShane but I'd prefer to stick with O'Brien until he puts a foot wrong for us. He has been doing well for Pompey this season. He wasn't great against Birmingham but Chris Sutton could make any defender look bad. ;)
I think McGeady could have a great role as an impact sub in the next campaign.
mc geady changed the game when he came on for celtic against motherwell i feel this is what is needed
Heading over for the game aginast Sweden. I hope Stan starts the following team, which is a mixture of youth and experience.
Given
J O'Brien Dunne A O'Brien O'Shea
Finnan S Reid Ireland Duff
Keane Doyle
For Sewden I'd go with:
Given
Finnan
Dunne(Capt)
O'Brien
O'Shea
McGeady
S.Reid
G.Kavanagh
Duff
K.Doyle
R.Keane
I'd like to see..S.Ireland, P.McCarthy,J.O'Brien,play some part against the Sewdes.
Fair enuff, either mine above or this team would give sweden a good game.Quote:
Originally Posted by Dublin12
you obviously dont see enough of the premiership this season. By his own standards and the standards of premiership defenders Dunne has had a very poor season, has been beaten my many attackers and has also been hesitant. However Richard Dunne may not be, as you correctly say, the quickest defender in the world, but he is very quick and as quick as most strikers, hes exceptional over a few yards in most situations, i think people automatically think hes big so hes slow.Quote:
Originally Posted by shakermaker1982
Whats the point in that, looks very like the same players who have failedQuote:
Originally Posted by NeilMcD
miserably in the last 3 years..:confused:
Time to try out some new faces!!
Quote:
Originally Posted by NeilMcD
Quote:
Originally Posted by Condex
Well Doyler's in there and the rest are on the bench!!
Don't think you could throw in all the new faces from the off in fairness - they'll need time to grow into the squad and then the starting 11...imo