thought Pip Keogh was superb in his first season with us and was criminally underused by AM in his second season and should have never have being let go to Bray! I thought he was a brilliant passer!
Printable View
Ronan Finn didn’t make your list? Surely the best ever three we had in the middle was Finn. O’Donnell. Towell ?
For one season only in 2015. Finn was taken in to replace Towell who was expected to move but he stayed on for one more season.
Shields was / is excellent at what he does, the ultimate team player, but on sheer skill these 3 for me were the best in the central role. Best ever left side had to be Barry Kehoe, he won 2 league titles and one cup (one double) but he gets the nod ahead of Daryl Horgan as Kehoe played and gave the same outstanding performances in some dreadful DFC seasons.
Going back to the 70’s and 80’s a Tommy McConville by a mile the best central defender. He also had a fair collection of full Ireland caps all won while playing LOI.
Best keeper. Tough one to pick from Richie Blackmore (3 leagues and 3 cups, 1 double) and unbeaten in Europe at home from 1976 to 1981 - ended with defeat to Liverpool in 1982, (
missed qualifying only one season and played 2 rounds on quite a few. Also Alan O’Neill (2 leagues, 1 double) but poor record in Europe. Only one notable result, 1-1 away to Honved.
Then we have Gary Rogers with his record equaling appearances and 3 leagues and 2 cups (1 double) has won a little less than Blackmore (for now) but he played the most ever Euro games as a GK for the club and in the group stages.
It looks like worst ever 23 man squad would be far more interesting some shocking names getting thrown around as a joke.
When you see the list of names for various clubs, some damn good footballers have played in the LOI and I have been lucky enough to be attending LOI games since 96 to have seen a lot of them in action. It would make an interesting debate on a live match night on RTE. Wondering how a LOI greatest team of 1990's v Noughties V Present day would line up ?
One season wonder! Im not bitter at all at the way he left of course. Nah seriously while we certainly missed him when he left I will stick with my midfield selection. Drop a striker and add a midfielder if it were allowed then Id probably have included him. Paul Patterson, John Ryan, and Ian Ferguson were on the shortlist too...
Keepers: John Walsh, Ciaran Gallagher, James Gallagher
Defenders : Keith Cowan, Stuart Gauld, Jonathan Minnock, Ray Kenny, Declan Boyle, Neil Fitzhenry, Shaun Holmes
Midfielders : John G McGettigan, Donal O Brien, Fergal Harkin, Tom Mohan, Johnny Kenny, Michael Funston, Noel Melvin, Paddy McGrenaghan, Paddy McCourt, Pierce Walsh
Forwards : Kevin McHugh, Johnny Speak, Conor Gethins
Am sure I missed some I would include on second thoughts..
Edit: just subbed in Shaun Holmes for Ronnie Murphy
Been thinking about this for a while, and keep chopping and changing, but here goes.
Goalkeepers:
Ciaran Gallagher, James Gallagher, Gavin Cullen
Defenders:
Johnny Minnock, Declan Boyle, Shane Bradley, Pascal Vaudequin, Ciaran Coll, Ray Kenny, Keith Cowan, Eloka Asokuh
Midfield:
Michael Funston, Fergal Harkin, Tom Mohan, Johnny Kenny, Paddy McGrenaghan, Donal O'Brien, Tony Shields, Paddy McCourt
Forwards:
Kevin McHugh, Conor Gethins, Johnny Speak, Stephen Parkhouse
Pretty sure it's the same one.....
I'd say so.. he played for a lot of clubs. Joined us along with Noel Melvin and Pierce Walsh (I think) when Monaghan United had a meltdown and was part of getting us promoted.
Goalkeepers:
Ciaran Gallagher, James Gallagher, Richard Brush
Defenders:
Johnny Minnock, Declan Boyle, Shane Bradley, Pascal Vaudequin, Dee McNulty, Keith Cowan, Eloka Asokuh
Midfield:
Michael Funston, Fergal Harkin, Tom Mohan, Niall Bonnar, Paddy McGrenaghan, Donal O'Brien, Raymond Foy, Paddy McCourt
Forwards:
Kevin McHugh, Conor Gethins, Johnny Speak, Stephen Parkhouse, James Mulligan
From 1994 (when I became a regular) on.
Barry Ryan Brendan Clarke, Trevor Wood
Ger O'Brien, Ian Bermingham, Trevor Croly, John McDonnell, Packie Lynch, Colin Hawkins, Kenny Browne
Eddie Gormley, Keith Fahey, Martin Russell, Paul Osam, Conan Byrne, Greg Bolger, Killian Brennan, Dave Mulcahy
Chris Forrester, Charles Mbabazi Livingstone, Christy Fagan, Trevor Molloy, Ricky O'Flaherty
GK Brian Murphy, Shane Supple, Dermot O'Neill
DF Robbie Best, Jacko McDonagh, Derek Pender, Darragh Leahy, Shaun Maher, Tony O'Connor, Eamon Gregg.
MDF Kevin Hunt, Paul Doolin, Pat Byrne, Mark Rutherford, Gino lawless, Dave Tilson, Brian Mooney, Ashley Grimes,
FWD Glen Crowe, Jason Byrne, Turlough O'Connor, Jackie Jameson, Tony Cousins
Straight off the top of my head (would probably change a few if I gave it further thought).