Quote:
Originally Posted by
nigel-harps1954
I did this simply because I don't think there's many decent keepers in the Division. Barry Ryan is well over-rated from what I see. Made an absolute howler up in Finn Park this season.
Gallagher is a flapper in my own experience of him.
Wouldn't rate him any higher than Graham Doyle, Packie Holden, Pat Jennings or Ger Hanley tbh. (I know Hanley isn't long back.)
Barry has his flaws (who are you telling?! :) ) but in a Division of poor keepers he could certainly argue his case as the best one.
Quote:
Harps went on a 10 game unbeaten run, largely due to Keith Cowan returning from injury. Back line was solid as a back line can be for those 10 games.
In those ten games Harps conceded 11 goals.
In the same period Limerick conceded 5.
Quote:
Brian McCarthy I've seen play 4 times this season, all 4 games he was top class.
Must have been four off days.
I've seen a lot of Brian.
Lovely guy, fairly good in the air (as you'd expect!!) but on the ground, on the turn and on the run, he's a bit suspect.
We didn't call him Bambi for nothing.
Quote:
Only because of his name are you putting him down. He has the eye for a pass he has always had, vision and first touch are second to none.
All well and good but he has no legs.
Maybe I'm wrong but he'd genuinely struggle to make the Limerick team I reckon.
Dave O'Leary was walking around Flancare with him inside his pocket last Saturday.
Quote:
Because it was by a long way the weakest part of the Limerick team this season.
Limerick have conceded 17 goals in 27 games.
In the process they've kept 14 (FOURTEEN) clean sheets.
Quote:
Again, never shone against Harps, which is what I've seen of him this season.
Don't get me wrong.
I don't rate Peter White at all, he broke our hearts trying to make a footballer out of him.
But he deserves a lot of credit for popping up with a lot of crucial goals despite his limitations.
Quote:
For the record, Ciaran Coll is one of the best young players in the league. Harps or not, bias or none, I stand by this firmly.
Best left back in the First Division by a long margin
See it's just silly.
Because of Harps bias.
Is he better than Shane Tracy by "a long margin" or "by a mile"
Of course he isn't.