game over for hibs 4-1 down gerry kelly and mc carthy for town time to go for pintsQuote:
Originally Posted by old git
Printable View
game over for hibs 4-1 down gerry kelly and mc carthy for town time to go for pintsQuote:
Originally Posted by old git
Do you have the teams by any chance ?
Kilmallock 2 Mungret 1 mungret better team in the first half kilmallock by far the better in the second tough game screamer from Paul Doona for the winner
Not a bad game of football, good atmosphere & entertaining. town won comfortably in the end massive gap between both squads. credit to hibs, this bunch of players showed heart & desire to play for the shirt. I really hope that they stick with this group of players.Quote:
Originally Posted by old git
Lets be honest showing great heart for the club won't get results!!! Hibs got a 1-0 win against the same town squad at the start of the season..getting the players back to keep them up should be a priority...
ah hello how can they get players back to keep them up with 3 games to go ?Quote:
Originally Posted by Coolcat
From what I heard the hibs team that played earlier on in the season is not there now so try and get the players back that would make the team some bit stronger.If the club gets relegated it'll only get worse!!
How can they get them back please explain ? What has changed with club that would bring them back a lot of them just stopped playing and a few others run off to other clubs when the going got toughQuote:
Originally Posted by Coolcat
Just think that with a club struggling the way it is,surely the ones that stopped playing could be asked to come back to give the club some chance of getting points in last 3 or 4 games..
I assume by that you mean Davy Wall/Philly Purcell/Darren Whelan/Jamie Cullen, I heard last night Darren Whelan/Philly Purcell were told when they signed that they would be spending most of their time from the bench? Can anyone confirm that? Old Git?Quote:
Originally Posted by Coolcat
Does Davy wall not play anymore no?
Ya not sure if that's all the names but would they have made a difference to the team against town?
melon your three ex team mates above should be startin every week for hibs if they were told by manager at the time they would be bench warmers a huge mistake by him !Quote:
Originally Posted by AC Melon
Are you seriously advocating that hibs management should run after the same players who got the club where they are now, 'rats deserting a sinking ship'. So what if the club get relegated, from what I seen the other night it will only be for 1 season. I would rather struggle in 1B than go running after those prima donnas.Quote:
Originally Posted by Coolcat
I don't know where' rats deserting a sinking ship' comes in.As ac melon was saying were the players not needed?And if the club does go down I'm not sure about coming back up with whats there cause it took a good squad of players under Davy wall to win 1B the last time..
Go begging players that walked away to come back? Ha ha thats what they want. They dont want to play leave them off. Rather get relegated with a group of lads with a bit of heart and interest that go asking any of them to come backQuote:
Originally Posted by Coolcat
Shannon town won comfortably in the end and so they should have as they were up against a hibs team with 8 b team players in the starting 11 and 3 more on the subs bench. They tried there best but they were playing division 3a football only a few months ago.......its a big ask. There is probably only quirkey,jack kelly and maybe fred who would get in Shannon towns squad and there is at least 6 teams better than Shannon town in the division so it was always going to be tough to stay in division.And as Coolcat said it took a very good squad of players to win 1b under davy wall.
U heard this melon? From who? Jamie cullen played for hibs last week and the week before. Darren whelan played a few weeks ago aswell?Quote:
Originally Posted by AC Melon
I heard it off a player who was in the team this season! Im not insinuating that its true im asking if anyone can tell me its true? as I was told Pa Tierney told Whelers and Philly Purcell that most of their playing time would be coming off the bence?Quote:
Originally Posted by Side Cutter
No this didn't happen. Whats the name of said player?Quote:
Originally Posted by AC Melon
Im not going to name and shame on this, but it was a squad member this season. Sure if its not true that the end of it! Apologies for bringing it up, just couldn't believe it when I heard it but now you confirmed it isn't true just goes down as another "rumour" around Shannon!
'No smoke without fire'I have to say I heard the same as ac melon!! The main thing is the club needs to stay in 1a with the incentive of the derby against town!!!
Yeah hopefully they do, caherconlish have 2 tough games next so hibs should stay up, thought the performance against Shannon town was good and the scoreline didn't reflect on the game, not a great game itself but only my opinion.Quote:
Originally Posted by Coolcat
Think hibs should stay up. then draw a line under this season and rebuild with only 1 team next season and maybe new management?
Heard they are going trying bringing in Moyes after he gets the sack at United:p No i think you are right, draw a line under what has been a bad two years for the club and try and get a few heads in for pre season. Staying up has to be the main priority though and with Town playing Caherconlish tomorrow hopefully they can do us a favour and beat them. Hope they show the same desire they showed against us and im sure they will!Quote:
Originally Posted by don't panic
I think they will but also heard today they are missing a few bodies 2moro .. alot depends on what team caherconlish send they can be good or brutal..Quote:
Originally Posted by Hibs7772
Who are they meant to be missing? You'd think with the big squad Town have that they will be able to cope and beat caherconlish no matter what team they bring out especially on there home turf.Quote:
Originally Posted by Second
Just heard 2/3 lads on evening and 1 lad getting married saturday so wont be available tuesday..could be all crap talk too.Quote:
Originally Posted by Hibs7772
im sure they will give it everything they have. You say they are looking to bring in a few head. I hope they and other clubs have learned from mistakes of the past and not just sign anyone who has a reputation of leaving after a few games. Also do you not think that questions should be asked about the people who are running the club .Quote:
Originally Posted by Hibs7772
You don't want to sign players who have a rep of leaving when the going gets tough but you also want to sign good players so there has to be a happy medium i think. As far as asking questions of the people running the club, maybe you have a point but at the same time when a host of players that are signed leave the club what are you suppose to do? You can't blame the people running the club for that!Quote:
Originally Posted by don't panic
cant really blame people runnin club for players leaving and if they stopped caring about club there would be no more hibs ? People tend to forget on amalgamation that all the park people have run away from new club they were involved in setting up so lets not blame current set up at hibs for everythingQuote:
Originally Posted by don't panic
Think its reasonable to ask questions also why have all the park people left. Club seems to be going nowhere so think they are fair questions.Quote:
Originally Posted by old git
fair point but i cant understand if people who were so commited to forming a new club with hopes of improving juniour and underage football can just walk away and lets not forget they were involved at committe level so would have a big say in club decisions ?Quote:
Originally Posted by don't panic
What questions do you want to ask? Only the park lads can answer why they left. If you know any of them you should ask them?? What are the other questions you want answers to??Quote:
Originally Posted by don't panic
Not gonna criticise individuals but feel that the amalgamation has not worked out. I personally believe that club should go back to Clare league under the Newton name.
Shannon Town 4-1 Caherconlish, Sean Burke and Adrian Carew got 2 of Town's goals, not sure who got the other 2
Good result for us! Town put out a much changed team to the team that played us on Saturday but fair play to them still came out comfortable winners. Caherconlish have 3 or 4 good individual players that would get in most starting 11's in 1A IMO .. just don't seem to play as a team at all
Sorry i dont understand? You said questions should be asked? You haven't asked any of these questions? What are the questions you want to ask? If you think newtown should go back to the clare league why dont you do something about it? Who do you want to address this situation?Quote:
Originally Posted by don't panic
Gerry kelly and chippy scored too.. although chippy's was more an og by keeperQuote:
Originally Posted by Hibs7772
I feel by asking questions might leave good people open to criticism. Unfortunately I think the Newtown days are gone but would be right behind the idea.
you brought it up in the first place don't panic ? you may as well ask the questions now I'd be intrested to see what the questions are and what answers you get on here .. first off the newtown days are long long gone that may answer one question ?Quote:
Originally Posted by don't panic