No in the individual battles against Toure he was out-muscled, over-powered and out-paced. He looked slow against Tevez too one on one. Whatever about keane he was never out-muscled and I know toure is a man-mountain and a one off but still. McCarthy did a great job holding and being a free outlet throughout the game.
There is no comparison, Mcclean is a lot more one trick pony. McManaman had a lot of poor final balls or over playing, a bit like McGeady, but he has a lot of skill.