it would require something of an apology/admission of error from Trappatoni to acknowledge that Reid does, in fact, have something to offer despite the Irish managers attempts to call an end to his career.
Aint gonna happen in my opinion.
Printable View
it would require something of an apology/admission of error from Trappatoni to acknowledge that Reid does, in fact, have something to offer despite the Irish managers attempts to call an end to his career.
Aint gonna happen in my opinion.
ya another one he fecked up ;) :D
i knew someone would get it... :D
Funny though, given that early in Trap's tenure Reid was one guy he'd have in the team any time.
Trap's system was built with Reid as the first name on the teamsheet, imo. The problem we've had is because the same system has been used with vastly inferior players. Reid + Whelan was light years ahead of Whelan + Green or Andrews or Gibson. He should start against Macedonia.It's insane to think otherwise. Just go watch a tape of the Georgia and Montenegro away games.
But the system was there before Reid walked into the team.
How many times has he been seriously injured while playing for Ireland? twice?
He should never have played the Montenegro game. But even at 75 percent fitness he was MOTM. In 50 years time our grandchildren will look back at us and laugh about how we ever stood for Whelan and Green.Quote:
Originally Posted by geysir
Didn't he injure himself during the game, after 30mins or so?
With hindsight it would have been wiser to rest him and not expect him to be up to playing 2 hard games inside a few days.
Needs must and all that Geysir.
Georgia is one of the very few 'away' games we have won of mediocre opposition.
in 150 yrs time some guy is gonna be doing like a google search for steven reid(dunno mayb hes his far into the future relative) and hell stumble onto this thread and be under the impression his distant ancestor was on the games greats
The Georgia game was finished when Steven took the field against Montenegro.Quote:
Originally Posted by paul_oshea
Don't underestimate how good he was/is. Man Yoo wanted him at one point, don't forget. He played in the 2002 World Cup at a young age also. He's not amazing but compared to Green or Andrews he is.Quote:
Originally Posted by irishultra
http://www.sundaymercury.net/midland...6331-28286010/
Yep, about 10 mins in the Saudi game!Quote:
Originally Posted by Yard of Pace
Reid is fit again but it still appears that two games a week is beyond his capabilities at the moment. His playing time has been carefully managed by both Di Matteo and Hodgson since he got back in the team and it would be a ludicrous decision for him to take on the extra strain of international football right now. Perhaps in a year if he's managed to steer clear of injury in that time.
nope, he didn't play against Saudi Arabia, actually that was the only group game he didn't play inQuote:
Originally Posted by Stuttgart88
from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2002_FI...ld_Cup_Group_E
came on against Cameroon in the 77th minute
came on against Germany in the 73rd minute
Didn't play against Saudi Arabia or Spain
Now Stutts
I remember him gearing up for a free kick in that game. Looked like he was aiming for the back of a net back in Dublin.Quote:
Originally Posted by tetsujin1979
It's hardly that much strain. I don't buy this giving up international football to prolong club career stuff. John Giles says the same. He's a fit young man not even 30. Of course he can play an extra few games a year.Quote:
Originally Posted by Charlie Darwin
You're talking like he's pulled his hamstring a couple of times...Quote:
Originally Posted by Yard of Pace
He's a 'fit young man' who suffers from chronic back strains and has incurred two almost career ending knee injuries in the last four seasons. So, no, he can't just play an extra few games a year. Reid (much like McGrath or King) needs to treated with kid gloves. He didn't give up international football just to prolong a club career, he likely did it simply to secure one.
Well it's not about age but injuries. The club has access to all of his medical information and they have been resting him every few games and that's with the club only playing one game a week. We don't even know how much he can train.Quote:
Originally Posted by Yard of Pace
Giles tends to compare midfielders to his standards. Unfortunately none of our CMs are built as strong as a brick shíthouse, have ambipedlar ability, tackle like a bulldozer, can excel at both attacking and defending, or could stroke the ball 50m to land purposefully on the 10th blade of grass in from the touchline. Despite the fact that players cover twice as much ground as players did in his day, Giles thinks every player should be able to play weekly, along with a game midweek. Susceptibility to injury or needing recovery time is not a consideration.
Alright lads, fair enough
There is some real nonsense on this thread. Trapatonni was the person who brought Reid's Ireland career into question not the player himself. Steven Reid on his injury post Trapatonni's comments. Reid said: 'I couldn't really believe what I was hearing. The cartilage isn't gone. It's fine. In fact, the surgery's been a total success. The rehabilitation was always going to take nine or 10 months and I've done everything by the book.
'I've actually played six or seven games in the last two months, four or five with the reserves as well as our Carling Cup matches against Gillingham and Nottingham Forest. And I haven't had a problem with the knee. Unfortunately, I've just had a couple of niggly issues, first with a hamstring, and now this Achilles.
'The comments amazed me. I'm more positive now about my fitness than I've been in a long time. I'd just like the supporters to know I'm feeling great and looking forward to getting back playing in another week or so.' People were writing off Duff on here a couple of weeks back (again based on the Trapatonni's ill-informed comments). Reid just played a full 90 mins with no problems. We have a spate of real injuries and Reid should be recalled.
Hear, hearQuote:
Originally Posted by Noelys Guitar
Is it too obvious to say 'Reid is retired' at this point?Quote:
Originally Posted by Noelys Guitar
Look I'd love to see him back, but the idea he retired because Trap hurt his feelings is ridiculous. He made that decision himself, probably to concentrate on regaining and maintaining club fitness.
If he's feels fully fit (and it appears so) great, but it's still his responsibility to inform management that he wants to be considered for selection. A 'maybe I would in an emergency' style answer isn't going to cut it for me.
We don't have a lack of options at central midfield or right back. We have a shortage of quality at centre mid, but we do have several emerging options. All those options have made it unequivocally clear they are available to play for Ireland. Reid can do the same, if he wishes.
If there was an injury crisis, then maybe management should make the call. But until then, I think it has to come from the player. Managers should focus on picking those who definitely want to be picked.
Should he become available, then welcome back. But would he warrant a place at centre mid? Has he played there much (or at all) for West Brom? Reid, on his day at CM, would be a shoe-in but are we sure he can do the job? Seems like it'd be a bit of punt, though I'm not intrinsically against going for it. Wouldn't have him as a right back, would rather have Foley, Coleman or even Kelly given a run there.
I kind of agree SvD, but at the same time a pro-active call from Trap or Tardelli along the lines of "the group is entering a critical stage, would you like to be involved?" would be a pretty easy and wise thing to do, and in Reid's case I think dialogue should be ongoing. I honestly think a special case for Reid could be made for calling him up for the finals or the play-offs (if we manage it - big if) given how defendable his decision to retire was. Totally different to Stephen Fruitcake.
However, if young McCarthy shows up then it's much of a muchness. Reid AND McCarthy could be tasty though.
His retirement is certainly defendable and Reid was a great servant considering the toll international football has taken on his career. I certainly wouldn't blame him whatever decision he made. Perhaps a subtle feeling out of things wouldn't be amiss, especially coming to the end of the campaign. Still others, like Lee Carsley, were happy to reaffirm a commitment and I don't see why Reid can't do the same if he really wanted to return.Quote:
Originally Posted by Stuttgart88
Suppose my overall feeling is Trap should be looking at the options already there, like McCarthy. The fact he chooses neither is what's frustrating.
just scored a thumping header from a corner against Arsenal. 3 minutes in. Great header. West Brom v Arsenal, the game of choice in Canada this morning.
Reid just scored his first Premier League goal in almost 5 years - a header against Arsenal in the first 5 minutes.
Reid and McCarthy in midfield......*daydreams*
Is he playing in midfield or at right back today? And how is he playing?
Right full according to Sky Sports
There's a short piece on Reid in The Weekly News (the grandmother gets it!). He says ("jokes" it actually says) that he thinks that at 30 his days marauding in midfield are behind him and he's settled into playing right-back. Doesn't mention Ireland but he says he's just happy to be playing every week now.
Personally I'd love to see him back but it sounds like he's content right now. That said, with Paul Green out for a lengthy spell, does that qualify as the emergency needed to bring Reid back?
off after 45mins with injury. Not sure what ii was but he walked off himself no bother.
Great block from Reidy.
he's having a good game. Id love to see him back in the Irish squad.
Me too. But let's not start that war.
I havent the time or resources for another war anyway. This defense of Robbie Keane is taking its toll. Some say its unwinnable, some say why even bother but I say I cant stand by and watch these atrocities occur...
Well, we're all behind you