I remember the Shamrock Rovers team of the mid 80s. Drogheda had just won the League Cup and paraded the trophy before the home game against Rovers at United Park. Rovers then proceeded to beat us 6-0. (Or possibly even 7-0? - it's a distant memory). However, that Rovers team never really did the business in Europe.
Shelbourne in 2004 were a decent side, no doubt about it. However, having been at the game in Tallaght on Thursday, I think this Dundalk team is the best of the lot. They also seem to be getting better and better in Europe. Having watched them quite a bit, I felt they took an awful battering in Belarus and were lucky to get away with a 1-0 defeat. Also, they had some dodgy moments in the earlier qualifying round in Iceland. (I didn't see the home game against Bate). I was at the match against Legia in Dublin, and thought they played well, and were a bit unlucky to lose. But they were just phenomenal against Macabbi. To play a possession-based passing game as well as they do, and to carry it with it with such skill and consistency on the European stage is unprecedented for an Irish team. Stephen Kenny deserves a vast amount of credit.