Munster Junior Cup 2006/07

Printable View

Show 40 post(s) from this thread on one page

06/04/2007, 10:31 AM
Noddy

clonmel know they won't win the appeal. so whats the point in appealing they don't have a leg to stand on.
06/04/2007, 7:24 PM
the only 1

clonmels keeper is illegal as well he played with st,pats
06/04/2007, 11:43 PM
lim abroad

every year there seems to be issue's with illegal ex loi players,i agree that pike are well within their rights to appeal,i just can't understand how clubs still make this mistake
07/04/2007, 6:04 AM
Town Fan

Quote:

Originally Posted by the only 1

clonmels keeper is illegal as well he played with st,pats

He is not the same Richie Ryan
07/04/2007, 1:49 PM
the only 1

Quote:

Originally Posted by Town Fan

He is not the same Richie Ryan

makes no difference does it?:) heard yere players are rightly ****ed off over this not turning up for games how could ye be so thick 2illegal players
07/04/2007, 2:03 PM
oscar

Quote:

Originally Posted by Roadend

That's not the point, if you break the rules you suffer the consequences. What would be the point of having rules in the first place if every time someone broke them we'd say "ah sure replay the game, they broke the rules but who wants to progress after the they were kicked out because of cheating"
Honestly you have no grounds for an argument whatsoever.

i stand corrected
10/04/2007, 7:29 AM
tipp man

Having listened to Tipp FM last night it would appear that Clonmel Town are resolved to fight this all the way!
10/04/2007, 8:27 AM
Noddy

on what grounds? what is going to be there reason/excuse?
11/04/2007, 1:49 PM
allab

anyone know when we'll know the outcome of clonmels appeal??
11/04/2007, 2:40 PM
Limeref

How Long?

Quote:

Originally Posted by allab

anyone know when we'll know the outcome of clonmels appeal??

Rule 30 of the FAI rule book deals with appeals.

Clonmel had 4 days from the time they received notification of the MFA decision with regard to Pikes protest to Lodge their appeal.

The FAI has 14 days to hear this appeal

The determination is issued within 3 days of the appeal being heard.

Cost €500 (refunded if appeal is sucessfull)
Total 21 days

Any party affected by the FAI decision can then go to arbitration (Rule 31 of the FAI rulebook)

A request for arbitration must be made within 10 days from the date of receiving the FAI decision (above)

An arbitrator hears the case with 10 days of receipt of the request.

A determination is made with 5 days

Cost €5,000
Total 25 days

Overall it could take 46 days or by my reckoning until May 21/22/23 to resolve!
11/04/2007, 5:04 PM
abbeyvale

Fixture

Sunday April 15th

MJC Semi Final
Leeside FC v Ballynanty Rovers (3pm Midleton)
11/04/2007, 6:15 PM
Town Fan

Quote:

Originally Posted by tipp man

Having listened to Tipp FM last night it would appear that Clonmel Town are resolved to fight this all the way!

I missed that, what was said? I heard that Town have decided not to appeal
11/04/2007, 7:52 PM
macca

There is alot of talk about appeal s, Clonmel ,Pike etc...What about the other team s Lee Side,Maymount,Balla du they get a mention.Who going to be the first team in the final.Any prediction s.
12/04/2007, 1:11 AM
the only 1

Quote:

Originally Posted by Town Fan

I missed that, what was said? I heard that Town have decided not to appeal

if you read clonmels report on the game on there website they havent kielys or coady name on the team sheet comical:D :D
12/04/2007, 11:44 AM
C.T.F.C

1 out of 3 isnt bad I suppose

Quote:

Originally Posted by the only 1

clonmels keeper is illegal as well he played with st,pats

Incorrect

Quote:

Originally Posted by the only 1

makes no difference does it?heard yere players are rightly ****ed off over this not turning up for games how could ye be so thick 2illegal players

Again incorrect Of course the players are gutted about this but as for not turning up for games??? You might want to quote sources other than the voices in your head.

Quote:

Originally Posted by the only 1

if you read clonmels report on the game on there website they havent kielys or coady name on the team sheet comical

Finally he gets one right:rolleyes: In a last ditch attempt to save their season Town have decided to make the players disappear by not including them on the teamsheet. Of course if you read the precedding report they are both mentioned in it: Must be a very slow news day in your part of the world:confused: You can go and put your big wodden spoon away now.
12/04/2007, 11:52 AM
zizu's head

Quote:

Originally Posted by C.T.F.C

Incorrect

Again incorrect Of course the players are gutted about this but as for not turning up for games??? You might want to quote sources other than the voices in your head.

Finally he gets one right In a last ditch attempt to save their season Town have decided to make the players disappear by not including them on the teamsheet. Of course if you read the precedding report they are both mentioned in it: Must be a very slow news day in your part of the world You can go and put your big wodden spoon away now.

:D :D
12/04/2007, 4:43 PM
the only 1

Quote:

Originally Posted by C.T.F.C

Incorrect

Again incorrect Of course the players are gutted about this but as for not turning up for games??? You might want to quote sources other than the voices in your head.

Finally he gets one right In a last ditch attempt to save their season Town have decided to make the players disappear by not including them on the teamsheet. Of course if you read the precedding report they are both mentioned in it: Must be a very slow news day in your part of the world:confused: You can go and put your big wodden spoon away now.

you cares ye are out:) :)
12/04/2007, 5:42 PM
jug2004

Who cares I think its quiet funny actually that he managed to make a pl****r out ya really!!!:D :D :D
12/04/2007, 7:09 PM
the hoops

bit sad that clonmel are still checking mjc site
12/04/2007, 9:42 PM
balls

obviously there sad. they were in last 3 mjc finals and name was written on it this year again. there best junior team in munster by a mile. pike probably bottle it yet anyway as usual and get beat in semi or final
13/04/2007, 10:59 AM
the hoops

Quote:

Originally Posted by balls

obviously there sad. they were in last 3 mjc finals and name was written on it this year again. there best junior team in munster by a mile. pike probably bottle it yet anyway as usual and get beat in semi or final

maybe they will but they have a better chance than clonmel:cool:
13/04/2007, 11:24 AM
silvercircle

Quote:

Originally Posted by the hoops

maybe they will but they have a better chance than clonmel:cool:

give it a rest hoops..the CTFC players + supporters are a decent crowd..a mistake was made they paid the price....personally I think if they were still in it they would have won it easily.
13/04/2007, 1:26 PM
themerryman

Quote:

Originally Posted by silvercircle

give it a rest hoops..the CTFC players + supporters are a decent crowd..a mistake was made they paid the price....personally I think if they were still in it they would have won it easily.

but their not so they wont , come on the pikers..:)
13/04/2007, 2:21 PM
jug2004

christ hoops....its easily known why so many people don't like pike in the country, specially with you writin this bull, but then again it seems true what every junior team in the country says about u too the way ya carry on!!;)
15/04/2007, 4:01 PM
mulla

balla 1 leeside 0
15/04/2007, 7:03 PM
Super Rovers

Quote:

Originally Posted by mulla

balla 1 leeside 0

who scored the balla goal
15/04/2007, 8:02 PM
mulla

Quote:

Originally Posted by Super Rovers

who scored the balla goal

tom daly
15/04/2007, 9:52 PM
balls

should be all limerick final so. fair play to balla for getting to final
16/04/2007, 6:07 AM
leather

Well done Balla
16/04/2007, 7:58 AM
Dirk Diggler

Well done balla. Hopefully we can join ye in the final.
16/04/2007, 6:59 PM
macca

I would like to say well done to Balla.I was at the game ,that was one of the best team performance s i have seen in a while.Lee side are a fine outfit but just could not break done Balla s back four.The ref deserve s a mention ,he was fair to both side s .Lets hope its an all limerick final.If so Jackman park should be where the game is played?????
17/04/2007, 10:43 AM
halo16

Quote:

Originally Posted by macca

I would like to say well done to Balla.I was at the game ,that was one of the best team performance s i have seen in a while.Lee side are a fine outfit but just could not break done Balla s back four.The ref deserve s a mention ,he was fair to both side s .Lets hope its an all limerick final.If so Jackman park should be where the game is played?????

would be a shame alrite to have to travel to turners cross if its an all limerick final.it would arguably be one of the best supported finals in a long time.balla always bring a great crowd and pike wouldnt be badly supported either.would be a great occasion for limerick soccer.still though,we might be all jumping the gun a small bit.still a semi to be played
17/04/2007, 12:17 PM
the only 1

Quote:

Originally Posted by halo16

would be a shame alrite to have to travel to turners cross if its an all limerick final.it would arguably be one of the best supported finals in a long time.balla always bring a great crowd and pike wouldnt be badly supported either.would be a great occasion for limerick soccer.still though,we might be all jumping the gun a small bit.still a semi to be played

when is the other semi on?
17/04/2007, 2:38 PM
Tipp Man 2

Quote:

Originally Posted by silvercircle

give it a rest hoops..the CTFC players + supporters are a decent crowd..a mistake was made they paid the price....personally I think if they were still in it they would have won it easily.

Town have appealed to FAI and will go to arbitration if needed so nothing set in stone yet lads
17/04/2007, 3:06 PM
the hoops

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tipp Man 2

Town have appealed to FAI and will go to arbitration if needed so nothing set in stone yet lads

lads ye had 2illegal players plus kiely was illegal against rockmount in the previous round the chap that was down there with ye admitted ye were wrong playing kiely whats yere grounds for appeal ye made a mistake or two:rolleyes:
17/04/2007, 5:21 PM
C.T.F.C

Basis for appeal

Town are appealing this decision on the basis that the punishment does not fit the crime. The club made an honest and genuine mistake and were stunned at the severity of the sanction imposed. The MJC could have fined the club and ordered a replay and avoided all this nonsense. The club will examine its position after each step of the appeal process but has not ruled out taking it beyond the arbitration stage if a satisfactory resolution cannot be reached. If this fiasco does nothing else it may force the MJC to amend the ludicris rule whereby a returning EL player can compete in all competitions bar the provincial cup.
18/04/2007, 6:49 AM
the only 1

Quote:

Originally Posted by C.T.F.C

Town are appealing this decision on the basis that the punishment does not fit the crime. The club made an honest and genuine mistake and were stunned at the severity of the sanction imposed. The MJC could have fined the club and ordered a replay and avoided all this nonsense. The club will examine its position after each step of the appeal process but has not ruled out taking it beyond the arbitration stage if a satisfactory resolution cannot be reached. If this fiasco does nothing else it may force the MJC to amend the ludicris rule whereby a returning EL player can compete in all competitions bar the provincial cup.

do you not mean 2 honest mistakes coady was illegal as well
18/04/2007, 6:54 AM
backodanet

Quote:

Originally Posted by C.T.F.C

If this fiasco does nothing else it may force the MJC to amend the ludicris rule whereby a returning EL player can compete in all competitions bar the provincial cup.

i think there (MJC) point was they would not change the rule mid season so from next season (junior season) a returning EL players will be allowed to play
18/04/2007, 7:32 AM
MitreSize5

have you forgotten your player that didnt serve his suspension.

Its all well and good saying your going to arrbritation until they have their hand out for the 5K
18/04/2007, 8:06 AM
abbeyvale

Quote:

Originally Posted by the hoops

lads ye had 2illegal players plus kiely was illegal against rockmount in the previous round the chap that was down there with ye admitted ye were wrong playing kiely whats yere grounds for appeal ye made a mistake or two:rolleyes:

Surely Rockmount could have a case then as well???
Why not let Rockmount take Clonmels slot and let them play Pike in the 1/4 final???

Show 40 post(s) from this thread on one page

All times are GMT. The time now is 8:41 AM.