Either that or they are not particularly keen to get involved.Quote:
Originally Posted by EalingGreen
Printable View
Either that or they are not particularly keen to get involved.Quote:
Originally Posted by EalingGreen
Quote:
Originally Posted by EalingGreen
"And it is also my guess that this policy decision is not an easy one, otherwise they would have nailed it down one way or another long before now."
They well not be particularly keen, but they have no choice in the matter, since FIFA is the only body which can adjudicate between two of its Membership Associations when they are in dispute over a matter such as this.Quote:
Originally Posted by Maroon 7
And they are doubtless aware that if the FAI goes ahead and includes Gibson in a e.g. a Euro Qualifier and their opponents consider that they (ROI) may have fielded an ineligible player, then those opponents will surely appeal and FIFA will have to decide before it happens again.
Quote:
Originally Posted by EalingGreen
On that famous ANNEX 2
you leave out the important bit from the FIFA conference, the annex is not for players already covered by article 15.3
http://www.fifa.com/aboutfifa/federa...sid=92699.html
And it is not used against players who fall under 15.3
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tuff Paddy
+1
This thread should have stopped after 3 pages max. Its the same points over and over and over...
He can't play for anyone else now, can we close off this thread now?
Think we should now that the matter has reached a satisfactory conclusion.:)
I see all guests are blocked from viewing ourweecountry.com today. They must be fuming after Gibson played last night and have banned outsiders.
Could have been some wum gloating over Darron.
Reminds me of that Marine played by Jack Nicholson shouting to some poncy lawyer,
'You want the truth - you can't handle the truth'.
Well said, whenever I see Ealing Green at the top of a post I don't bother reading it any more.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tuff Paddy
wow god forbid anyone have a different opinion to you on a forum!!!!:mad:Quote:
Originally Posted by Tuff Paddy
if you dont like it dont read it. but dont try speak for anyone but yourself.
Well seeing as Darron made his debut for us last night it's a non issue and I will do as others have suggested and close the thread
I see the Gibson thread has been locked on the logic that he's played for us now and so that must be OK.
This is not a very powerful argument. The system seems to be self certifying with FIFA having the ability to retrospectively punish. It's a bit like filling in a tax return you cant say later well that's what my form said so it must be true.
Anyway thougth it might be good to have a thread for Gibson the player, thought he looked OK last night just worried about what his career over the next 12-24 months will look like, dont see him getting many matches at Old Trafford so possibly a loan move to e.g Birmingham
cavan_man, i think FIFA are being quite on the matter, because they were waiting to see if the IFAs bluff would be called. Now that he has played for us, the IFA might just leave it, and hence no sore head for FIFA. And its all cleared up. On the other hand you could be right.....but are the IFA that petty, probably.Quote:
This is not a very powerful argument. The system seems to be self certifying with FIFA having the ability to retrospectively punish. It's a bit like filling in a tax return you cant say later well that's what my form said so it must be true.
Dont let this start the, OMG gibson is a revelation, all that sensationalism. A decent prospect that is all for now.Quote:
Anyway thougth it might be good to have a thread for Gibson the player, thought he looked OK last night just worried about what his career over the next 12-24 months will look like, dont see him getting many matches at Old Trafford so possibly a loan move to e.g Birmingham
I would chew both my own legs off if FIFA were ever to rule against Gibson playing for ROI. It is nonsense to think that this would ever be the case no matter what some of the bitter shower up North think or say.Quote:
Originally Posted by paul_oshea
Jaysus YI....are you a closet Cannibal.....you will "eat your own head " in another thread!:D............is the diet getting to you...?Quote:
Originally Posted by youngirish
If FIFA were going to do something they would have done it by now. He's been in ROI youth teams for years and neither he nor the FAI made any bones about the fact that he was going to get a senior cap sooner rather than later.
I think he's got lots of potential but obviously it's early days for him. Good too that he's a central midfielder as since Keane and Holland retired we've been a bit short in the middle of the park. He seems confident, assured on the ball and has a good shot on him and unlike some of our other midfielders he's got a bit of physical presence about him too. He's a big lad. Not the quickest I'd say but not slow either.
Need him to develop now and gain experience.
agree Maroon - will be shocked if FIFA tried to prevent Gibson playing for ROI - mr worthington needs to forget about it and move on - he is fighting a lost cause imo
Will all this resurface if/when Marc Wilson, Rory Harkin, or any other player who's changed allegiance, gets called into the senior squad?
i dont see why it was locked other than the fact there seems to be a clique on here who seem to want to stifle any debate. if people dont want to debate it anymore why do they read it?
There is nothing left to debate, he can't play for the North anymore, so why keep it open?Quote:
Originally Posted by Billsthoughts