Originally Posted by
pineapple stu
I think you're both simultaneously getting the point and not getting it.
Yes, inventing a new club for the league is more likely to lead to failure. We've seen that lots of times here. But I think few enough people are arguing that point.
And yes, you're right that it takes ambition for a club to step up.
But the pros of doing so have to be weighed against the cons. Look at Tralee Dynamoes, who were an existing club with ambition. They left the Kerry District League to join the A Championship, with views of stepping up to the First Division in due course. To do so meant changing their season from Sept-May to Mar-Oct. But after three years, the FAI scrapped the A Championship and refused Tralee's application to join the First Division. So Tralee had to rejoin the Kerry District League - but at the bottom, three divisions below where they had been, and change their season back to Sept-May, which meant (I think) that for eight months they had no games at all. It took them years to get back to where they had been.
Compare that with, say, Larne who in 2007/08 realised they were in above their level, but were able to just opt for relegation one level for the following season.
There's a huge difference between those two. The point of a proper pyramid is to encourage ambition. The LoI structure actively ****s over clubs who look to step up by removing their safety net back down if required, even to the extent of leaving them almost a whole year without a match, and setting the club back years. Why would a club risk that? And this is the point - you have to weigh the pros and the cons.
This has created the unfortunate position that local leagues are now a de facto height of ambition - being LSL champions means far more than it should do for example, and clubs are often happy to have just local ambitions. The LoI is a blind spot for them because of the risks going up there entails. So the structure here is so bad that it is now self-perpetuating.
But get rid of that fundamental barrier to ambition that exists in the LoI, and you will find plenty of clubs like H&W here. A lack of clubs is not the issue here; it's the lack of a structure to encourage ambition.