Poll: Dolan or Collins

Now that Collins has taken over at St.Pats, who do y'all think will be more successful
- Dolan at Cork or Collins at St.Pats -
Personally, I'd have to go for Dolan!

In fairness the question should be who's going to do better Cork or pats?

I've tipped Cork for the league but I'd cry if Dolan came back to Pats.

If we finish in the top 4 next year Collins will have done great

And we'd be dissapointed with fourth.
I wouldn't be expecting City to even worry Bohs though.
They're far ahead as Dolan has admitted.
We could push Shels for second definitely though.
Answer = Dolan.

Different starting positions.... Cork aren't that far from being a great team, infact bar the away form they would be, however pats could still have been in the playoff right till the last day....

Success for collins would be top fours, whereas Dolan has to be looking to make a decent tilt at the title....

Personally I think that both could be relatively successful next season...

I hope that Dolan will be the more successful of the two but for fear of jinxing us I'll reserve judgement.:)

tut tut.
Some on colm.
Sitting on the fence ain't all its cracked up to be on the comfort front.
The fence has spikes. . . . .
and splinters don't ya know.
What am i on about?
Give me an avatar.
City are twice the team Pats are.

Sitting on the Fence??? Chrissss......Youse all have a nice Semi-D on it! ;)
Cork finished a lot higher last Season than Pats but both sides have good squads. I reckon Pat in a fresh environment will flourish where as Collins as a fresh face might suprise.
I do feel Managers make a lot of difference to how Teams fair, contrary to above opinion.

Make a decision a stick to it, now, before the Season starts! ;)

In their new positions, who do you think will enjoy a more successful first season, and elaborate how you define 'success' in this instance?

I voted Pat.
Success is an FAI cup and a very close battle with Bohs for the title. I reckon Shels will drop off this year.

I'd have Collins, he's unproven, but Dolan is a proven waffler and poor tactician.