Printable View
Did anybody see this match tonight and the penalty awarded to Milan:eek: ?
I can honestly say it was probably the worst refereeing decision i've ever seen. Glad to see Bayern get the goal at the end though and Gattuso complaining to the referee!! What goes around, comes around:D
When you see it several times it was a brutal decision all right, but these are becoming a regular feature of football games now, especially in games that are put under TV microscope.Quote:
Originally Posted by kev mcq
I have never been sure whether technology should be used, but certainly when you see tonights decision I think I would support use of technology in these cases.
I have posted something like this ages ago, but when we go to live games, we all have an immediate view as to whether an incident is a penalty of not and your view depends on a number of things which I believe are in ths order:
- the team you are supporting
- how much you love/hate the team against who the decision is given
- the vantage point from which you see the incident
- the score in the game at the time
Last week Ireland conceeded a stonewall penalty against Slovakia. How did we react? - Well played Dunne/McShane! - Get up you fu*kin Sloakian waster! etc. etc. Had exactly the same decision been given at the other end of the field, how do you think we would have reacted?
Referees have one shot at making a call and generally they get it right. Had that same decision been made in the Liverpool game tonight with them 3-0 up and 5 minutes to go, nobody would have been that bothered it hadn't been given.
Had a tenner on a Liverpool/AC Milan double. Shít happpens once again.
Yep, the referee's task is almost impossible with diving etc and pundits and managers on their backs.
For goals and penalties the only answer is the video ref. Even those aren't foolproof with different interpretations, especially of hand balls.
The interesting thing about that peno was that Kaka didn't run over to the ref when Lucio tackled him. The commentators said he had actually gone to take the corner.
I think when incidents like that happen you have to gage people's reactions. No matter what, alot of the teams conceding the peno will protest but the fact that the Milan players didn't protest says alot, imo.
Terrible penalty decision, great game though. Bayern were lucky not to be hammered, only for those two saves from the keeper it could have been 3-0 or 4-0.
Shocking decision to be honest. Was a really good game though. Sets it up very nicely for the second leg.
Watched the highlights after we gave PSV a lesson in football. Have to say, I thought it was an excellent game overall, some of the passing by Milan was outstanding but German sides particularly Bayern and never beaten. The 2nd leg is going to be something special. Penalty decision was terrible but I must say I do like that referee overall, he lets things flow. He has the potential to become a top referee and europe hasnt really had one since Collina was retired.
referee aint great in the roma-man utd game tonight either
Were you there at the Bray UCD Cup QF a few years ago when Pip hauled the UCD player down inside the box?Quote:
Originally Posted by Superhoops
It was 3-2 at the time and it was in the last minute. Even from where we were in the Shed we could see it was a blatant peno. We all groaned and we were genuinely surprised that it wasn't given. That was such a huge decision and for the life of me I'll never know why the ref didn't give the peno. It was such a crucial decision.
What did he do wrong?Quote:
Originally Posted by feo123
i thought the ref in the roma utd game was good. dunno what fergie was bitching about
:DQuote:
Originally Posted by Superhoops
I called that at the time and until the replays (for most), the other 5 people in the room with me refused to say it was anything but a dive..blatent penalty from a mile off :D
Whiskey head is just making sure the referee is going to be a 100% homer next tues cos united are up against it. He could have no arguements about the sending off, Ginger comitted about 6 yellow card fouls up to that point.Quote:
Originally Posted by SeaniesRedArmy
Also he may feel a little annoyed cos his clubs is gonna have to fork out some dosh to uefa as a result of the disgraceful behaviour of their fans for the 2nd euro away in a row (and they still sing songs about our behaviour which has been perfect for many seasons now). Brave men those mancs!!
Hope to god Roma do what they did against Lyon.
Gilardino scored a legit goal to make it 2-0 but was ruled offside. Justice was done with the peno. Milan should have won by 2 or 3, Bayern were poor. I suppose it makes for a much better 2nd leg as who wants to watch Liverpool-PSV? :)Quote:
Originally Posted by kev mcq