Printable View
Guys your opinions on the teams for both games barring injury of course??
Would you go with a moe attack mind team against wales ??
My team would be
Given
Finnan Mc Shane Dunne O'Shea
Kilbane Ireland Carsley Duff
Keane Doyle (Folan) ...folan if doyle is out , and for the surprise factor
I'd have Douglas instead of Ireland and maybe Harte instead of O'SheaQuote:
Originally Posted by bwagner
Also I would use both Mc geady and Hunt as impact players
Given,
Finnan, Dunne, McShane, Harte,
McGeady, Ireland, Carsley, Duff,
Keane, Doyle.
It's a toss-up between Harte and JOSH for who starts at left-full. Both are equally useless.
I'd have Kelly at left back ahead of Harte or O'Shea. Other than that agree with bwagner.
--------------Given----------------
Finnan----Dunne--McShane----O'Shea
McGeady--Carsley---Douglas---Duff
-----------Keane---Doyle----------
--------------Given----------------
Kelly----Dunne--McShane----Finnan
McGeady--Carsley---Ireland---Duff
-----------Keane---Doyle----------
I'd go along with thatQuote:
Originally Posted by eirebhoy
If all fit and available
Given
Finnan, McShane, Dunne (because of lack of alternatives), Kelly
McGeady, Miller, Ireland, Duff
Doyle, Morrisson
Subs: Douglas, Hunt, O'Dea, Keane, Henderson
I'd go along with that.Quote:
Originally Posted by eirebhoy
-----------------Given---------------
--------McShane Dunne O'Brien-------
Finnan Harte
Carsley Ireland
Duff
Ward Keane
Erm, neither in the squadQuote:
Originally Posted by LFC in Exile
Why would you only include Dunne because of a lack of alternatives?
Very light weight midfield!!! Miller and Ireland are tiny.Quote:
Originally Posted by LFC in Exile
The team I think Stan should pick
Given
Finnan-McShane-Dunne-Kelly
Duff-Carsley-O'Shea-Hunt
Keane-Doyle
*** NEWSFLASH ***
IRISH MANAGER PICKS FINNAN AT RIGHT BACK SHOCKER.
Kelly at left full is important for his pace as Bellamy will drift that side with Giggs on left unless Giggs plays centre for Wales. Stevie will cope with either.
Carsley and O'Shea for work-rate. \Douglas will be playing 3rd Division nxt year, so no. Hunt will buzz like Houghton and should be first choice on the left in place of Duff. If Duff not doing it on the right, get McGeady on double quick. If Keane won't stay up and keeps dropping, drop him and get Stokesy on, he's got alot to prove lately.
That team will win 3-0 assuming they don't listen to their manager and captain.
But Stan will pick a totally different team, maybe Finnan on the left wing.
i might be crazy, but i'd start O'Dea over McShane. I think O'Dea might turn out to be the better prospect, only reason i'd have McShane in over him is that he's had a few caps.
Given
Finnan-O'Dea-Dunne-Kelly
Duff-Carsley-Ireland-Hunt
Keane-Doyle
I like Stephen Ireland's passing ability even though he's lightweight. O' Shea is just pants.
Given
Kelly, Dunne, McShane, Finnan
Duff, Carsley, Ireland, Kilbane
Keane, Doyle if fit otherwise I'd go with stokes
Are you serious ? !!Quote:
Originally Posted by stojkovic
I agree about O'Dea, if he is good enough for the San Siro surely he is good enough for Croker. I'd start McGeady tho ahead of Hunt, i know it may sound like i'm just going for them as they are Celtic players but I think that they are the best options. Although I would like to see Hunt introduced.Quote:
Originally Posted by The Legend
bearing in mind lack of other options how about o'dea at left back?
excuse my ignorance but what formation do the welsh usually play... do they not play a 3-5-2 or something?
Given
Kelly-O'Dea-Dunne-Finnan
McGeady-Carsley-Kilbane-Duff
Stokes-Doyle