Maybe it might be worth a go getting in an experienced manager who is not a former Irish international. I'm thinking of somone like George Graham or Trappitoni.
Any thoughts?
Printable View
Maybe it might be worth a go getting in an experienced manager who is not a former Irish international. I'm thinking of somone like George Graham or Trappitoni.
Any thoughts?
If Trappitoni can't hack it with Italy don't think he'd be too successful with Ireland.Quote:
Originally posted by nelo
Maybe it might be worth a go getting in an experienced manager who is not a former Irish international. I'm thinking of somone like George Graham or Trappitoni.
Any thoughts?
Any "foreign" manager would likely take a good while to figure out the players available to him...
what about Philippe Trousier - anyone know what he's up to these days?
...auditioning for Harry Potter, wasn't it? :DQuote:
Originally posted by joe
what about Philippe Trousier - anyone know what he's up to these days?
Donie
Who is deleting my posts?
I dunno. Thats the problem with sacking McCarthy- who would want the job?
Cant really see any well-experienced manager from the top flights of any country putting up with some of the rubbish the FAi deal out.
Thats the bare bones of it. I´m sure there are better organised sunday league sides. It´s walking into a lions den to take that job.Quote:
Originally posted by Magoo
Cant really see any well-experienced manager from the top flights of any country putting up with some of the rubbish the FAi deal out.
having said that all the same that still leaves the two boys - Brian Kerr and Joe Kinnear - left 'cos i reckon they would defo consider the offer. I'd rather Kinnear meself.
Can Kinnear handle it though, with his heart problems and all? Plus, he achieved success with Wimbledon by playing the longball. Do we really want to go back to the longball days?
dunno how much he is on now but the reason kinnear didnt take the job in 96 was cos he would have to take an 80 percent pay cut and he was managing wimbledon at the time . So it shows that whoever takes over from mick whenever he goes will have to do the job cos of a desire to do it not for any financial gain
I was very much in favour of Kinnear in96, but I dunno if he´s be the right man for the job now.Quote:
Originally posted by brine2
Can Kinnear handle it though, with his heart problems and all? Plus, he achieved success with Wimbledon by playing the longball. Do we really want to go back to the longball days?
The crucial factor to consider when selecting a suitable candidate for the Irish job is how the candiate would cope with the limited resources available.
With this in mind I feel O'Leary would be unsuitable - he spent a huge amount of money at Leeds and won nothing.
Not sure a top continental manager like Trappatoni would work either. Granted he would leave he likes of McCarthy for dead in terms of tactical nous but like it or not the manager needs to have an indepth knowledge of the Premier league and equally importantly the lower divisions when many of our younger players are playing. I also feel he is unproven with limited resources.
On the other hand someone like Kinnear has achieved plenty on a tight budget at Wimbledon. While they were never the most attractive to watch they were better than the Wimbledon of the Dave Basset days.
I'd be reluctant to move Kerr from work he is doing at the under age level. The last thing we need right now is the conveyor belt to stop. We are getting a reasonable number of players coming through the underage structure and Kerr is crucial to that process. The FAI have screwed up plenty lately but their continuing commitment to fielding as many underage teams as possible should be applauded.
I am refering to the English Premier league.Quote:
Originally posted by dosullivan
.....Not sure a top continental manager like Trappatoni would work either. Granted he would leave he likes of McCarthy for dead in terms of tactical nous but like it or not the manager needs to have an indepth knowledge of the Premier league and equally importantly the lower divisions when many of our younger players are playing. I also feel he is unproven with limited resources.
Hold on a minute, Italy didn't have a great World Cup but other than Brazil no major team did. Over the last 25 years, Trapittoni has won eight league titles, a European Cup, a Cup Winners' Cup, three Uefa Cups, the European/South American Cup and two Italian Cups. With the exception of Alex Ferguson no other current club manager in the world has a record quite like that. And we are going to sign a manager directly from a club in all likelyhood.Quote:
Originally posted by pete
If Trappitoni can't hack it with Italy don't think he'd be too successful with Ireland.
I feel we need to broaden our horizons and sign someone with real experience and a real record. I think the FAI also need to bring in some technical experiance to rearrange their whole bloody organisation, someone who knows how to run a professional association from the grass up.
We need an experienced technical director working behind the scenes, if even on a part time basis.
As for Joe Kinnear current ability, last year he took over the Luton job which was pretty messy at the time. In 1 season alone he transformed the clubs fortunes and got them promoted. He is the best of the Irish talent out there, but really we should consider international help if possible.
Being devils advocate for a while here but................didn't he have tons of cash to just buy players at Juventus?Quote:
Originally posted by nelo
Hold on a minute, Italy didn't have a great World Cup but other than Brazil no major team did. Over the last 25 years, Trapittoni has won eight league titles, a European Cup, a Cup Winners' Cup, three Uefa Cups, the European/South American Cup and two Italian Cups. With the exception of Alex Ferguson no other current club manager in the world has a record quite like that.
Agreed, Trap's record compares VERY favourably with ANY manager EVER in the history of the game. Still though, would he really want to take on a job as s**t as the Irish hotseat? Very much doubt it when the money, lifestyle etc are way better elsewhere.
Murphy Out Now!!!
McCarthy Out Now!!!
Yeah, I can't see him taking the job, even if the FAI did offer it to him.
Of course he wouldn't, he'd be absolutely mad to. Currently managing Ireland is the job from Hell. It's nice to dream though.Quote:
Originally posted by Schumi
Yeah, I can't see him taking the job, even if the FAI did offer it to him.
Murphy Out Now!!!
McCarthy Out Now!!!