Printable View
I see that Cardiff are riding high on top of the Championship and McPhail is a regular in centre-mid.
Has anyone seen him play?
I remember when he was a youngster with the Leeds "dream team" Harry Kewell described him as the most skilful player at the club.
Considering how weak we are in midfield, could he be an option in the near future?
I see no reason he cannot be at least a squad player like Miller or Douglas.
I remember not too long ago that I was lambasted on this forum for suggesting that this could be a huge season for McPhail and that he could well force his way back into the reckoning if he performs consistently.
Well I think his time has come now. By all accounts he's been a star in the middle of the park for Cardiff so far this season and he is definitely the type of midfielder we are looking for. He could well be a perfect partner for the all-action Reid in that he's always looking for the ball and can bring our creative players (McGeady/Duff/Keane) into the game more often with his accurate passing.
Surely he would be worth a shot next month against a lesser team?
Coaches have always been suspicious of McPhail, in that he has a wonderful touch and a perfect pass but is unreliable tracking back. I've always liked his style of play, though, and thought that if you have players to cover him, he can turn a game.
Then again, I don't remember the Championship being the place where you can get away with not being able to tackle, maybe he's improved? I don't think we have any Cardiff viewers here to confirm this, do we?
For several years now, we've struggled to beat teams and have always lacked any real creativity, with the obvious exception of Duff. Why not bring McPhail into the squad? He has as much to offer as plenty of those that are there already and it will surely do loads for his confidence.
Sounds exactly like the player he replaced at Cardiff, Jason Koumas. :) I haven't seen McPhail play in a couple of years.Quote:
Originally Posted by Donal81
dunno how he went from being the great white hope of irish football to bein a total "dont let him near the squad" player. he cant be any worse than the shams we have at the mo.
I think he was unlucky in that our midfield was full up when he was playing brilliantly for Leeds.Quote:
Originally Posted by Billsthoughts
He went down the pan fairly quickly after that and, in fairness, why should Kerr have picked him, considering he was two tiers away from the top level? Now he's doing the business in the Championship, he's definitely worth another look.
He could bring something new to the team, unlike Carsley or Connolly.
I've come to the rescue.
Have seen him in every home match this season, and he has been great.Moving around, linking well with the wingers and the two lads up top, excellent on the ball (he was tormenting David Dunn and Nafti on Saturday), and is a better left footed centre midfield alternative to Kilbane.However, there is one suspicion - against West Brom, he went a bit quiet after half time, something that he has been accused of in the past.
On the whole though, he deserves another chance, because he does look top notch now.
Also, on another note, Willo Flood is also looking god in the cameos he has had, great pace on him.Hopefully will see more great displays from him for the remainder of teh season.
He played against Nigeria at The Valley and was utterly crap & at that point I thought he should be put out to grass. But playing well week in week out in The Championship is a far higher level than Miller or Douglas is playing at. Even Mark Kennedy is playing at a higher standard than them. I think McPhail deserves another look.
I agree, & to be fair everyone was crap that day against Nigeria.Quote:
Originally Posted by Stuttgart88
I also saw him live for Leeds a few times, admittedly when they were in decline. Mcphail had as much presence on the pitch as my 3 yr old daughter would have had. But he looks bigger now and maybe Soper can comment on this, but I don't think Cardiff is the type of club that'd indulge a fancy dan.
He was in a poor team then & from what I recall did notreceive much of a confidence boost - I think O'Leary said something like he would never make a midfielder. When he first broke into the Leeds team he was first class.Quote:
Originally Posted by Stuttgart88
Apparently he was excellent last year (in a tough division) and has already received a few MOM this season. Be great to see him fulfil that early potential.
I think O'Leary said that he wasn't a modern midfielder in the box-to-box Roy Keane/Steven Gerrard/Patrick Vieira mould, and that when he was in the side, he needed players around him to get the best out of him, which made him a luxury player, so he was dropped (IIRC in favor of Dacourt).Quote:
Originally Posted by Paddy Garcia
Mind you, IMO that exact description can be applied to Lampard!
Does that mean your 3 yr old daughter is class or McPhail is muck?Quote:
Originally Posted by Stuttgart88
I said it in another thread but I think the key to getting our CM right is Steven Reid's performance. Look how well the lightweight but skillful Stephen Ireland plays when accompanied by Joey Barton at City. Barton is tough, athletic and covers a lot of ground. If Reid can start to dominate midfield then we have an abundance of players who, in principle, can add creativity & McPhail is probably one of those.
Kavanagh was such a disappontment for me. Even his set piece distribution has been shocking on a number of times for Ireland yet he delivers the ball well at club level. McPhail is a player who takes a mean free kick & corner.
I know it's a bit "clutching at straws" but I'm undwerwhelmed by our central midfield and I can't believe Andy Reid can't get in the squad. I really wish we had another year to get things right as I'm still optimistic but I just haven't derived any sense of strategy from the 3 friendlies so far.
I'd actually like the press to ask tough questions about certain players: why are X and Y in, why are X and Y out? Good communication is essential to stop rumours and speculation festering. The Indo has the bit between its teeth on McCarthy's disciplinerary record for example. But this is only their guess.
Obviously she's class, but not quite ready for first team action just yet.Quote:
Originally Posted by DotTV
Stuttgart - Yeah, he does look, to me anyway, a bit bigger than when he was at Leeds, but he still wouldn't be a Gravesen.His prescence in the midfield is notable though, and he doesn't get knocked off the ball much because he, in line with Cardiff's fast tempo of play, seems to know what he's doing with the ball instantly.He does benfit from having a tough midfield partner in Scimica(sp), so if Steve Reid gets his act together, there could be a similar thing at intl level.
Stuttgart you've summed up my whole impression of McPhail as a player. He looks good even great when he's playing in a game where his team are dominating and getting most of the ball.Quote:
Originally Posted by Stuttgart88
On the flipside in a team that is struggling to get possession he's sh**e. Play him against San Marino and Cyprus (maybe even Wales) but not against Czech Republic, Germany or Slovakia.
I think you're spot on here Stuttgart. Plenty here would call that "hounding" Staunton out of the job, however.Quote:
Originally Posted by Stuttgart88
One reason why I think the press doesn't ask tough questions is because they don't know enough about Staunton's options, who's playing well & who isn't etc..
Against that though, it's completely Staunton's prerogative to pick Jon Douglas if he thinks he's good enough, or Miller if he thinks he's better than McPhail. Both did reasonably well against Holland.
I think it's only saddos like me & many others on here who actually go out of their way to find out how certain Irish players are getting on. I was delighted, as an example, to see Darren Randolph's photo in yesterday Times in the "Player of the Day" caption!
Everyone else is too wrapped up in the WWF, sorry, Premiership. It makes my bloood boil when people like Frank Stapleton, Kevin Moran & Jason McAteer are paid to comment on our future on SKY when they literally only know the tip of the iceberg. I'd bet you anything that Frank the Plank wouldn't cross the road to see Paddy McCarthy or Paul McShane play just to see what he's like, for example.