11-a-side Team of the Year

Printable View

22/12/2004, 11:28 AM
Roo69

11-a-side Team of the Year

1. Steve Williams (Shelbourne)
2. Owen Heary (Shelbourne)
3. Sean Dillon (Longford Town)
4. Stephen Grey (Drogheda United)
5. Colin Hawkins (Bohemians)
6. Stuart Byrne (Shelbourne)
7. Alan Moore (Shelbourne)
8. Keith Fahey (St Patrick's Athletic)
9. Jason Byrne (Shelbourne)
10. Daryl Murphy (Waterford United)
11. Liam Kearney (Cork City)

What do we think ? all agreed ? Personally i'd have Danny O'Connor in ahead of Hawkins. Other than that it looks pretty good, Maybe Kevin Doyle in ahead of Stuey Byrne
22/12/2004, 11:32 AM
patsh

What a joke...:rolleyes:

Hawkins? - He made an effort for about the last two months of the season only
Dillon? - Horgan, Frost, Bennett are just three players who were better
Keith Fahy? - Ha Ha Ha Ha....:rolleyes:
S. Byrne - :rolleyes:
22/12/2004, 11:52 AM
Hibs4Ever

Keith Fahey had a GREAT season, and totally deserves it
22/12/2004, 12:03 PM
Slash/ED

Quote:

Originally Posted by patsh

Keith Fahy? - Ha Ha Ha Ha....:rolleyes:
S. Byrne - :rolleyes:

What could you have against these selections? Stuey was possibley the best mid fielder in the league last season and Fahey is absolutley superb.

However, what Alan Moore and Hawkins are doing in there I do not know. Moore was pretty much rubbish in the league and only played half a season and Hawkins was a running joke for most of the season
22/12/2004, 12:15 PM
Cosmo

Cant understand how Trevor Molloy didn't make that team.

Also id agree with the bray fan - danny o connor should have been in that team without any doubt. I'd have him there before Hawkins and Gray.

Danny was better for us this season than Gray - bot many people outside of drogs supporters seem to realsie that :rolleyes:
22/12/2004, 12:16 PM
Slash/ED

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cosmo

Cant understand how Trevor Molloy didn't make that team.

Because he got something like five goals all season.
22/12/2004, 12:52 PM
Cosmo

Goals aren't everything - if you're going by that theory you're automatically saying that theres no point in mentioning forwards in teams of the year as they're automatically given to the 2 top goal scorers - not much thought in that is there? :rolleyes: - performance wise, he's been absolutely brilliant for rovers and has been very impressive. Would've been the perfect signing for us if Myler eventually leaves
22/12/2004, 12:53 PM
Slash/ED

He was good but wasn't nearly as good as Murphy or Byrne, or others you could have picked. I know goals aren't everything but five is a pathetic amount fo a striker really, that does count for something.
22/12/2004, 1:00 PM
patsh

Quote:

Originally Posted by SAINTS4EVER

Keith Fahey had a GREAT season, and totally deserves it

It's easy to look great when you are playing with a less than mediocre team. He played well for SPA but never had to step up to the mark at any stage during the season.I only saw him against us, and on his performance in those games, he wouldn't have even got on the bench with City.
Billy Woods, Kevin Doyle, George O'Callaghan are three players who had far better seasons, and at the business end of the table too, than Fahey.
Alan Kirby had a better season than him and I bet plenty of posters could name more.

Byrne had a good season, but you could say the same about a dozen midfielders this season. Reynolds, O'Callaghan, O'Brien, MacChrystal or Lynch were just as good if not better.
22/12/2004, 1:04 PM
joeSoap

Just read that team three times to be sure....No Kevin Doyle ?? :confused:

Enough said about the tossers that pick that team.Pathetic.
22/12/2004, 1:10 PM
Slash/ED

Quote:

Originally Posted by patsh

Byrne had a good season, but you could say the same about a dozen midfielders this season. Reynolds, O'Callaghan, O'Brien, MacChrystal or Lynch were just as good if not better.

Lynch!? As in Damien? He must have played central mid field less than 10 times all season. Byrne had O'Callaghan in his back pocket in Turners Cross in the 1-0 game that he got a cracker in. None of those were as good as Stuey Byrne who was argubley, along with Heary, our best player in Europe. I'm amazed you single Stuey out and not Alan Moore, Byrne is far more deserving of his place there than Moore.
22/12/2004, 1:12 PM
paudie

Kevin Doyle would have to be in it, even if at the expense of Kearney. Kearney had a good season but not good enough to be in the team of the season IMO.
22/12/2004, 1:13 PM
patsh

Quote:

Originally Posted by Slash/ED

Byrne had O'Callaghan in his back pocket in Turners Cross in the 1-0 game that he got a cracker in.

One good game?
He was almost anonymous in the other three against us.
I didn't complain about Moore because I thought he looked far better than Byrne in the games between us, which I am mostly basing my judgements on.
22/12/2004, 1:15 PM
Slash/ED

Quote:

Originally Posted by patsh

One good game?
He was almost anonymous in the other three against us.
I didn't complain about Moore because I thought he looked far better than Byrne in the games between us, which I am mostly basing my judgements on.

Well Byrne did far more against Cork than O'Callaghan did against Shels. Byrne was our best mid fielder last season, far better than Moore and he had a better season than any of the others mentioned there, he was possibley the best mid fielder in the league last season and was outstanding in Europe.
22/12/2004, 1:30 PM
patsh

Quote:

Originally Posted by Slash/ED

Well Byrne did far more against Cork than O'Callaghan did against Shels. Byrne was our best mid fielder last season, far better than Moore and he had a better season than any of the others mentioned there, he was possibley the best mid fielder in the league last season and was outstanding in Europe.

Well one presumes Byrne was picked for more than the games against Cork, and O'Callaghan was outstanding in so many games this season, possibly the best and most exciting midfielder in the league and Geroge was outstanding in Europe. I totally disagree with the decision on 11-a-side, and whatever you say about Byrne can be said much more so about O'Callaghan. The team that gets second in the league, beat a top Swedish team home and away during a great European run, gets ONE player in the team?

Total f*cking joke....:rolleyes:
22/12/2004, 3:14 PM
De Town

Quote:

Originally Posted by patsh

Hawkins? - He made an effort for about the last two months of the season only
Dillon? - Horgan, Frost, Bennett are just three players who were better
Keith Fahy? - Ha Ha Ha Ha....:rolleyes:
S. Byrne - :rolleyes:

Agree on Hawkins and Fahy to a lesser extent but how can you justify the other 2? Dillo was brilliant this year and while I agree, the other 3 you mentioned played well this season, Dillo totally deserved it.

As for Stuie, he's the best midfielder in the league and possibly the best player.
22/12/2004, 3:39 PM
pete

Alan Moore looked good in europe but nothing too special in the league.

I'd be surprised if any Bohs fans would back Hawkins based on last season alone.

Amazed Kevin Doyle not selected. :eek:
22/12/2004, 7:31 PM
Troy.McClure

Seeing as Kevin Doyle could (should) have got in the team in 2 positions, the fact that he didnt get in at either of them just makes the team a joke, who came up with the team? Usually they have polls.