Printable View
Last quarters of the tournament, made all the harder by having 7 choices instead of 6 due to an adding up error on my part, sorry fellas but thems the breaks :)
Nirvana - Heart Shaped Box - In Utero - 1993
Arcade Fire - Wake Up - Funeral - 2004
QOTSA - No One Knows - Songs For The Deaf - 2002
Oasis - Slide Away - Definitely Maybe - 1994
Manic Street Preachers - Everything Must Go - Everything Must Go - 1996
Arctic Monkeys - Fake Tales Of San Francisco - Whatever People Say I Am - 2006
Happy Mondays - Step On - Pills, Thrills and Bellyaches - 1989
May vote for what I like here, won't make a difference with Oasis and Arcade Fire in the list. :p :D
This is true. To be honest this whole process has been building up to a battle between Stone Roses and Oasis in the final, the rest are just decorationsQuote:
Originally Posted by stann
Currently it's on the shelf with a thick layer of dust on it, but I did listen to it a lot on release, so I'll go for Oasis.
(or, now that we're in the knockout stages I'm backing the winners)
as with all things Manc pub band polluted, I'm voting for any reasonably placed contender ...so I'm backing the Manc Club band instead.
just an observation from Q/F3 ...no votes at all for Nevermind yet. I voted for Pumpkins anyway ...though I'd have preferred if it were MC&TIS that were in the battle.
Well, I voted for the album I still play most regualrly of this bunch, so Manics for me. Fingers crossed for the Mondays though. Perhaps the semis shouldbe played where the Oasis fans do not venture - move it to the Current affairs sub-forum perhaps? Tech Support? Though to be honest, I thought that you'd find few im Music...
Argubly the toughest of the quarterfinals here, cases to be made for most. Manics get the vote though, of the Mancs i'd probably have gone with Pills, Thrills & Bellyaches.
Arcade Fire for me.
Gone for Everything Must Go, an album of its time. Bloody tough battle for second, Funeral just over Songs for the Deaf. I really didnt want to choose though. But I did.
well done on lazy generalizations :rolleyes:Quote:
Originally Posted by Bluebeard
Can't believe Oasis beat the Arctic Monkeys on this one.
Just happened on this now.....
In Utero is tripe!!! :eek: :eek: :eek:
Well done you.
Oh please noby, really there's no need.
:rolleyes:
Well, I will admit that of all the Oasis albums, Definitely Maybe is quite good, and is more worthy of a place in the quarters than any other.Quote:
Originally Posted by gustavo
Not a single vote for QOTSA! :eek:
Then why didn't you vote for it if you're that arsed!Quote:
Originally Posted by Pauro 76
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pauro 76
It was an impulse vote my one....Quote:
Originally Posted by Macy