Log in

View Full Version : MNS



ramblers
28/07/2008, 7:45 PM
Well all agreed that the goal that was disallowed should have stood!!:mad:

The penalty was not a penalty Kavs fell over the bray player and the lads said the ref should have stuck with the original desicion if he thought it was a peno.:(

More emails got on this match then any other game. They all agreed the Ref was inconsistent to say the least:mad:

pcplod
28/07/2008, 9:52 PM
the peno may have been questionable but it is not rugby they were playing so he should of had the b***s to stick with his original decision i think that is what is so frustrating. it showed complete incompetance.

Great to mns actually agreeing with us though for a change its whether fai will follow suit and actually do something about it will realy tell if we were listened to

minty
29/07/2008, 2:41 PM
Kavanaghs goal should definitely have stood...the timing of his jump was outstanding

Pablo Escobar
01/08/2008, 4:09 PM
the peno may have been questionable but it is not rugby they were playing so he should of had the b***s to stick with his original decision i think that is what is so frustrating. it showed complete incompetance.

Great to mns actually agreeing with us though for a change its whether fai will follow suit and actually do something about it will realy tell if we were listened to


It's all about precedent. Different Sports have different practices, but agreed, peno decision should have stood, as should the goal!