Editing

[jmurphyc]

I'm not sure whether this is possible, but when other people edit their posts it doesn't come up as a new post afterwards. Sometimes this causes me - and possibly others - to miss an essential point so I was wondering whether the system could be modified so that it comes up as a new post causing people not to miss it. I've seen it on other message boards but I'm not sure whether it could be done on this one. I know it's a bit of an odd request but I think it would be a useful change to the message board.

Thanks.

[Rovers fan]

I'm not sure whether this is possible, but when other people edit their posts it doesn't come up as a new post afterwards. Sometimes this causes me - and possibly others - to miss an essential point so I was wondering whether the system could be modified so that it comes up as a new post causing people not to miss it. I've seen it on other message boards but I'm not sure whether it could be done on this one. I know it's a bit of an odd request but I think it would be a useful change to the message board.

Thanks.

Did you edit this post for the craic?!

[A face]

I'm not sure whether this is possible, but when other people edit their posts it doesn't come up as a new post afterwards. Sometimes this causes me - and possibly others - to miss an essential point so I was wondering whether the system could be modified so that it comes up as a new post causing people not to miss it. I've seen it on other message boards but I'm not sure whether it could be done on this one. I know it's a bit of an odd request but I think it would be a useful change to the message board.

Thanks.

Are you saying ....

- Someone posts something
- They go to edit it and you read/reply at the same time
- Then you realise their post has changed somewhat

and you are suggesting that ...

- When they edit it removes their initial post
- And their 'new' post appears below your reply

Dont think that would help the situation/issue you are highlighting, it could possibly make it worse

[jmurphyc]

Are you saying ....

- Someone posts something
- They go to edit it and you read/reply at the same time
- Then you realise their post has changed somewhat

and you are suggesting that ...

- When they edit it removes their initial post
- And their 'new' post appears below your reply

Dont think that would help the situation/issue you are highlighting, it could possibly make it worse

I understand that my post wasn't put in the most coherent way possible but it's a difficult thing to explain. I'll put it in bullet points as you have done as it's the best way of explaining it (btw I'm pretty much agreeing with the first part):

- You read said post.
Then you either
- Respond to it only to realise that their point has changed.
or
- You move on to another part of the forum or log out and when you come back you read later posts in the thread but completely miss out on the bit that they added to their post.

As for the second suggestion, I agree that that would make things far more complicated and could lead to confusion/arguments. I'm not sure whether this can be changed (and perhaps most people don't really care) but I personally think it would be a good thing.

Again, thanks.

Oh and I didn't edit the initial post for the laugh! :D

[dahamsta]

We can't really bump threads because a post was edited in them, it would result in half the current threads on the site being bumped thoughout the day. Sorry.

[jmurphyc]

We can't really bump threads because a post was edited in them, it would result in half the current threads on the site being bumped thoughout the day. Sorry.

That's no problem. I just noticed it on another forum and I thought it could be useful, but then again I guess it could lead to chaos. Thanks for getting back to me anyway.

[stann]

And (speaking for myself here) I only edit posts to add or change a point a small percentage of the time. Mainly, in fact overwhelmingly, it's to correct spelling, or in a long post to change sentance structure around to make it read easier. This would really cause chaos if these changes were to appear below any replies, long threads would quickly become totally unreadable.
Very poor idea. Which board did you see this on so we can avoid it? :D

[L37Ultra]

Blah edit Blah edit Blah edit Blah edit Blah edit.

Do you mean like this?