oldkeeper?

[the dazzler]

what a joke he is says on the paper and radio they have signed keith hartnett but the player has not even signed a form yet what is happening here mr,finnin? who are doin great work so far but if the player does not sign we will be a laughing stock are are we just trying to put pressure on the player to sign?

[the hoops]

its true ok he has not signed for lim37 he is still not sure interested in the irish junior team bit strange to announce it on the radio +papers

[gael353]

I think he did sign lads last night or the night before

[4tothefloor]

Not having a go at Ger Finnin or anyone at L37 but as of Friday night Keith had not signed anything and not only that, he had heard nothing at all from L37 at all. So basically our guess was as good as his. Thus the thread that one of the lads started regarding this. I was surprised then to hear the announcement that he was signed a few days later.........bit strange :confused:

[gaidin]

Not having a go at Ger Finnin or anyone at L37 but as of Friday night Keith had not signed anything and not only that, he had heard nothing at all from L37 at all. So basically our guess was as good as his. Thus the thread that one of the lads started regarding this. I was surprised then to hear the announcement that he was signed a few days later.........bit strange :confused:

If this is true and he doesnt sign then the club will have rightly f**ked up by announcing his 'signing'.

Still hopefully they will learn from their mistakes.

[joeSoap]

So What !!!

I'm getting a little fed up and tired of all this Keith Hartnett business as if he is THE ONE....

I know Keith. I have done for a while. He is a good lad, and a decent player, quite a good junior player, but will be only an average EL player. He is not going to be the be all and end all of our season, and to be honest I don't think its going to make much of a difference either way if he signs or not.

[gaidin]

So What !!!

I'm getting a little fed up and tired of all this Keith Hartnett business as if he is THE ONE....

I know Keith. I have done for a while. He is a good lad, and a decent player, quite a good junior player, but will be only an average EL player. He is not going to be the be all and end all of our season, and to be honest I don't think its going to make much of a difference either way if he signs or not.

I think what most people are getting at is that the club announced a signing, but at the time of the annoncement he is/was not actually signed. For me anyway its not about who the signing is its about doing things properly. And you dont announce a signing if the player isnt actually signed.

[joeSoap]

Fair point.

Did it occur to you that Keith might have given a verbal commitment to join the club, which the club took in good faith?

The main mistake the club made in that instance was taking somebodys word.

[the only 1]

like fathers joe?:D

[Monkfish]

like fathers joe?:D

.......or yours when it comes to breaking a 'big' story.

[gaidin]

Fair point.

Did it occur to you that Keith might have given a verbal commitment to join the club, which the club took in good faith?

The main mistake the club made in that instance was taking somebodys word.

Ya I did think of that. Like you said if thats what happened, their mistake was taking someones word.

Hopefully they will learn from these mistakes. (Then again he could have signed something already and all this will be pointless :D).

[Lim till i die]

Fair point.

Did it occur to you that Keith might have given a verbal commitment to join the club, which the club took in good faith?

The main mistake the club made in that instance was taking somebodys word.

If the club said someone has signed and he hasn't signed it's pretty fcukin amateur in fairness

[4tothefloor]

So What !!!

I'm getting a little fed up and tired of all this Keith Hartnett business as if he is THE ONE....

I know Keith. I have done for a while. He is a good lad, and a decent player, quite a good junior player, but will be only an average EL player. He is not going to be the be all and end all of our season, and to be honest I don't think its going to make much of a difference either way if he signs or not.
That has nothing to do with what this thread is about, at all! Storm in a tea cup anyway....

[joeSoap]

Original thread...

what a joke he is says on the paper and radio they have signed keith hartnett but the player has not even signed a form yet what is happening here mr,finnin? who are doin great work so far but if the player does not sign we will be a laughing stock are are we just trying to put pressure on the player to sign?

My post:

I'm getting a little fed up and tired of all this Keith Hartnett business as if he is THE ONE....

I know Keith. I have done for a while. He is a good lad, and a decent player, quite a good junior player, but will be only an average EL player. He is not going to be the be all and end all of our season, and to be honest I don't think its going to make much of a difference either way if he signs or not.


That has nothing to do with what this thread is about, at all!.

I thought it was relevant.......

[Needtoknow]

Keith wants to play for pick rivers in the little boys league then let him off. He is obviously afraid to test himself playing at a way higher level. He must doubt his own ability to make the grade, so we are better off without him!