All over for top of the flops?

[BohDiddley]

Now that UCD have, with some style, dumped Shels out of the league cup, farcically re-engineered in a futile effort to give them another route to the Setanta, that should be it for the season. Barring a Cork and Derry blow-up in the league and a collapse in form from other clubs in the distant chasing pack, they'll win nowt (as tunefully predicted in Tolka last week :D ).
But do you think the powers that be are done doing Ollie & Co. favours?
Will the FAI be too embarrassed to open yet another back door for the most expensive flops in Irish football? I don't think so, but I'd like to think that talking about it might just make it less likely ...

[sullanefc]

Cork and Derry to be fined 20 points each.

"The FAI have slammed Cork City FC and Derry City FC for being too far ahead of Shelbourne FC in the Eircom League. As this is against Rule 57 paragraph 2 in the leagues handbook that states Shelbourne FC should always win the league, the FAI are left with no other option than to fine Cork City FC and Derry City FC by 20 points each."

You could see it happen couldn't you??? :D

[Slash/ED]

They'll declare us champions as despite a superb title race we're all anyone wants to talk about anyway :)

[Peadar]

Will the FAI be too embarrassed to open yet another back door for the most expensive flops in Irish football?

Shels will finish third and the FAI will announce tha they didn't mean to introduce the 12 team league until next season and therefore think that the only fair thing to do is to remove the top two teams and place them on top of the First Division. :D

[Poor Student]

If Derry win the League Cup they'll have a chance through third place in the league if they can secure that. Even then Cork or Derry could also win the FAI Cup extending that to 4th place. It's not entirely over for Shels yet but they'll have to be praying for their enemies to win the cups.

[pineapple stu]

Shels will finish third and the FAI will announce tha they didn't mean to introduce the 12 team league until next season and therefore think that the only fair thing to do is to remove the top two teams and place them on top of the First Division. :D
Is this after colluding with Aertel? :D

[Réiteoir]

They'll declare us champions as despite a superb title race we're all anyone wants to talk about anyway :)

Ah yes, I can hear them down at Merrion Square...

Untrained FAI Monkey in a Suit: "Morning Ollie, what's the problem, you look even redder in the face than usual?"

Ollie: "CHOKE CHOKE"

Untrained FAI Monkey in a Suit: "Must be a result of all those cigarettes, ah well - as a get well soon present let's give them the League title - sure it's the only way they'll get anything this season"

[Krstic]

If Cork Win the League and Derry come second or Vice-Versa and one of them wins either the League or FAI Cup, should the Setanta place not go to the beaten finalists of the cup???

I remember back in the late 80's when Dundalk beat us in the FAI cup final to complete the double, the cup winners cup place was given to Derry.

Would the same thing for the Setanta not be the fairest way to do it??

[pete]

IMO the Setanta Cup should go to CL & Uefa Cup qualifiers (this includes FAI Cup runner up if required). I think only LC winners should qualify, if they've already qualified through other means then should go to next best league placing.

[Philo]

Personally I'd go for the top 4 in the league only to qualify for Setanta with cup losers only qualifying for Europe in the event of the cup winners getting CL or UEFA Cup spots.

The eircom League is too small and weak give consideration for the League Cup winners in my opinion. It's a bit of a nuisance competition that used to serve the purpose of getting player suspensions out of the way but now is just a day out for fans of teams in the final.

[Krstic]

But surely the added bonus of a Setanta place, even though it's come too late for most, is something that gives the league Cup more meaning and worth.

[Macy]

But do you think the powers that be are done doing Ollie & Co. favours?
Will the FAI be too embarrassed to open yet another back door for the most expensive flops in Irish football? I don't think so, but I'd like to think that talking about it might just make it less likely ...
Wouldn't be particularly shocked, afterall they won one league title in the corridors of Merrion Square rather than on the field of play....

[Philo]

But surely the added bonus of a Setanta place, even though it's come too late for most, is something that gives the league Cup more meaning and worth.

Fuk that. Why should the League Cup attain more meaning or worth? Like I said, Irish football is weak enough as it is without having it spread even thinner by promoting another competition to importance.

[Krstic]

Fuk that. Why should the League Cup attain more meaning or worth? Like I said, Irish football is weak enough as it is without having it spread even thinner by promoting another competition to importance.

Then why have the League Cup at all???

Something tells me that if your team were still in the league Cup, it'd be a different story!!!!

[Philo]

Then why have the League Cup at all???

Beats me. I say scrap it.


Something tells me that if your team were still in the league Cup, it'd be a different story!!!!

Wrong.

[bigmac]

Have to agree that the LC is a bit of a lame duck. top 3 in the league plus cup winners would be a better system, but at least having 3 ways of qualifying gives the smaller teams a chance - the question then is should we be helping smaller teams to qualify or ensuring that the big teams only go forward. IMO having the LC and FAI Cup spot could help clubs like UCD or Longford take a big step forward by providing a decent cash injection.

[Schumi]

I think the Setanta Cup place for the FAI Cup goes to the league if the winners have already qualified (the UEFA Cup place doesn't though). The same will presumably be the case for the League Cup place.

[Supersaint3]

Wouldn't be particularly shocked, afterall they won one league title in the corridors of Merrion Square rather than on the field of play....

OH! And it wasn't even a Pat's fan..

[Slash/ED]

Then why not scrap the Santy cup ?? The league cup was there first in all fairness. U21 players won't get a decent chance in any competition if you scrap the League Cup.

If thats the significance of the league cup then it should remain but not have a significant prize for the winners.

[Philo]

Then why not scrap the Santy cup ?? The league cup was there first in all fairness. U21 players won't get a decent chance in any competition if you scrap the League Cup.

Bohs U21s are getting a great run out every week thanks to the injury crisis... who needs the league cup!

[Peadar]

Then why not scrap the Santy cup ??

Wonder what you'll be calling it if you qualify again???
More money for being involved than your club had seen for all your cups that it took you over 70 years to win. :rolleyes:

[Poor Student]

Come to think of it, why did the League Cup come into being? I know in England it was the Football League's way of creating a rival to the FA Cup with a cup of their own but why do we have it? Was it copying the English? :confused: I can only think of France outside these islands that have a proper league cup.

[Breifne]

Come to think of it, why did the League Cup come into being? I know in England it was the Football League's way of creating a rival to the FA Cup with a cup of their own but why do we have it? Was it copying the English? :confused: I can only think of France outside these islands that have a proper league cup.

Don't know the history, but i like the league cup, there is something about cup competitions that attract attention, and i realise that the FAI cup is the top dog, but the league cup has now got the chance to regain a little integrity. with a nice five figure prize fund, and the setanta cup spot also in the frame, along with possible three home games in the high profile setanta cup. It allows first division sides, and weaker premier sides to win something, and bring in a bit of cash from a football source.

An all too rare occurance in this league. 2 competitions over a twelve month period is too few. Three (four with setanta Cup) is just about enough difference in footballing competitions

[Schumi]

Come to think of it, why did the League Cup come into being?
It was felt that the Leinster Senior Cup was being overshadowed by the other competitions and so they had to start a competition that people cared even less about. ;)

[Poor Student]

Don't know the history, but i like the league cup, there is something about cup competitions that attract attention, and i realise that the FAI cup is the top dog, but the league cup has now got the chance to regain a little integrity. with a nice five figure prize fund, and the setanta cup spot also in the frame, along with possible three home games in the high profile setanta cup. It allows first division sides, and weaker premier sides to win something, and bring in a bit of cash from a football source.

An all too rare occurance in this league. 2 competitions over a twelve month period is too few. Three (four with setanta Cup) is just about enough difference in footballing competitions

Don't get me wrong. I like it too and they're valid reasons about its worth however they are applied to it now we have it but when they decided to form the competition I am wondering what they were thinking.