PDA

View Full Version : Galway United



Pages : [1] 2 3

nigel-harps1954
30/03/2022, 10:29 PM
Felt like there wasn't really a decent thread to put this into. Their vote went through to give the Comers 85% of the club. Interesting times ahead.

https://galwayunitedfc.ie/galway-united-club-statement/

Olander
31/03/2022, 8:27 AM
A lot of fans from the outside looking in will immediately jump to skepticism over this takeover.

Fan ownership ideally is the way forward, but it does not fit all clubs and it never really took off in Galway for a few different reasons.

Presently I believe there is just over 100 active Co-op members, which should give people a perspective on how poorly supported it is. At its highest, I believe it probably had 200-250 members at most.

The Co-op never really had a huge say in the running of the club and many people ended up not renewing their membership (including myself).

The Comers have displayed their goodwill over their eight year sponsorship of the club, giving roughly €1.5m, which would be at the top end of sponsorship in the country.

The club has not won a trophy since 1997, it's been starved of success and the Comers are promising to develop our own training facilities, along with investing heavily in the squad. Their opening injection of €500,000 is a serious statement of intent.

Fan ownership clearly is not working at the club and what the Comer brothers are offering, off the back of their very generous sponsorship, is very appealing.

They have received very little back in return for their sponsorship, and yet they have continued to bankroll the club more or less.

sbgawa
31/03/2022, 8:36 AM
Agree 100%.
In fairness to them they probably know they need to go deeper into the cash to get Galway up and running properly and you cant blame them for deciding that throwing a few million into the club with no way of getting it back makes sense.
At least they can "hope" to get a return if they own most of it themselves.
Id say leaving 15% with the fans is a show of faith as well as o dont think Galway fans would have voted no if they had asked for 100%.

Longfordian
31/03/2022, 9:09 AM
Yeah at least they have a track record of supporting the club and they aren't in it for the money or a land grab. Not that anyone in their right mind should get involved in LOI for the money.

Jd2793
31/03/2022, 9:30 AM
imagine getting that level of investment and having JC running your transfer dealings. the comers will learn soon enough. seems like a good move for the club from the outside. hopefully they are in a position to take advantage of the money next season from a cork point of view

EatYerGreens
31/03/2022, 9:54 AM
Agree that having proven long-term supporters of the club buying it is infinitely superior to an Arkaga or Peak 6 mode. So long as Comer stay solvent, you would hope and expect that this will be a broadly positive move for Galway United. It should certainly be interesting anyway.

Would be great to see Galway doing well. We need representatives from the main cities outside Dublin - Cork, Limerick, Galway, Waterford (and Derry) - in the top tier.

joey B
31/03/2022, 11:32 AM
On the football side it looks like a great thing for Galway and good luck to them,most clubs would jump at someone promising to pump in another 500k and upgrade their ground.

On the negative side looking through some reaction from locals it seems the people involved are contributing to dereliction and lack of housing in Galway City,you can see why people would have reservations about the move if that is indeed the case…….

pateen
31/03/2022, 1:48 PM
Anyone know any details of deal a few years ago with the Arabs. The Comer bros we're part of that?

Lim till i die
31/03/2022, 1:58 PM
So the lads who insisted nick leeson was a decent skin sold up to the scum of the earth.

I would have done the same, this fan owned mumbo jumbo doesn't fly in Ireland. :ball:

Hopefully those two Limerick tech brother fellas will see a headline somewhere and feel the need to one up :D

Martinho II
31/03/2022, 8:02 PM
If you were listening to OTBam Johnny Ward wasnt giving away who he was voting for in the ballot. I think the Comer bros is a win win situation imo.

JC_GUFC
01/04/2022, 9:29 AM
A lot of fans from the outside looking in will immediately jump to skepticism over this takeover.

Fan ownership ideally is the way forward, but it does not fit all clubs and it never really took off in Galway for a few different reasons.

Presently I believe there is just over 100 active Co-op members, which should give people a perspective on how poorly supported it is. At its highest, I believe it probably had 200-250 members at most.

The Co-op never really had a huge say in the running of the club and many people ended up not renewing their membership (including myself).

The Comers have displayed their goodwill over their eight year sponsorship of the club, giving roughly €1.5m, which would be at the top end of sponsorship in the country.

The club has not won a trophy since 1997, it's been starved of success and the Comers are promising to develop our own training facilities, along with investing heavily in the squad. Their opening injection of €500,000 is a serious statement of intent.

Fan ownership clearly is not working at the club and what the Comer brothers are offering, off the back of their very generous sponsorship, is very appealing.

They have received very little back in return for their sponsorship, and yet they have continued to bankroll the club more or less.


I think this sums it up pretty well - also Galway United doesn't really have a history of fan ownership like Bohs, Sligo or Harps so it's not like we're selling out years of history by going private.

Although there is talk of pushing up the first team budget I actually think the main focus behind the project in the development of the Mountain South complex near Athenry which will give a base for the Galway United Academy as well as Connacht hockey amongst other sports.

There definitely is a bit of a concern about the Comer's ownership of property around Galway in a housing crisis and the complete shambles of the Corrib Great Southern Hotel situation and understandably there will be some who are annoyed that they're the ones taking ownership.

Outside of that they have shown support to the club over a number of years so I don't think they'll be looking to screw us over, or even to make money out of this, maybe they feel this is their way of giving back to Galway, similar to JP McManus in Limerick.

Finally just on the question of the Saudi takeover they weren't involved in that at all.

Martinho II
01/04/2022, 7:44 PM
I think this sums it up pretty well - also Galway United doesn't really have a history of fan ownership like Bohs, Sligo or Harps so it's not like we're selling out years of history by going private.

Although there is talk of pushing up the first team budget I actually think the main focus behind the project in the development of the Mountain South complex near Athenry which will give a base for the Galway United Academy as well as Connacht hockey amongst other sports.

There definitely is a bit of a concern about the Comer's ownership of property around Galway in a housing crisis and the complete shambles of the Corrib Great Southern Hotel situation and understandably there will be some who are annoyed that they're the ones taking ownership.

Outside of that they have shown support to the club over a number of years so I don't think they'll be looking to screw us over, or even to make money out of this, maybe they feel this is their way of giving back to Galway, similar to JP McManus in Limerick.

Finally just on the question of the Saudi takeover they weren't involved in that at all.

Before they sponsored Galway Utd Julian did they support Galway Utd?

gufct
02/04/2022, 2:44 PM
A very close friend is a massive gufc fan. We were talking to them as far back as 2010.

ToberonaTornado
03/04/2022, 2:42 AM
Good luck to Galway with the Comers on board is all i'll say to their petrified tenants currently waiting for the hardmen employed by them to evict with no legal argument.

Jd2793
03/04/2022, 6:41 AM
good luck to galway fans.... you'll need it dealing with caulfield ball!

gufct
21/04/2022, 9:05 PM
https://galwayunitedfc.ie/club-update-mountain-south/

Stav
22/04/2022, 8:13 AM
Hopefully the planning permission goes smoothly and the work starts soon. Well done to the Comer brothers who are reinvesting in their home county after being very successful abroad. If this is completed it will be a template for other clubs and organisations. The future is cooperation between different sports in areas such as this.

gufct
10/05/2022, 10:04 AM
New Partnership with gti

https://galwayunitedfc.ie/gufc-gti-launch-elite-football-professional-development-programme/

Great work being done behind the scenes.

Glen Of Aherlow
11/05/2022, 9:17 AM
Have they any plans to do anything with the stadium ?

JC_GUFC
11/05/2022, 1:02 PM
Have they any plans to do anything with the stadium ?

There was talk of stadium improvements in their bid to take over the club but the Galway FA own the ground so there's probably a limited amount that can be done for the moment. There was talk of fixing the scoreboard etc.

At the moment the ground is one of the best in the League although should we get promoted the way crowds currently are and with the larger away support we possibly could do with some additional capacity - I think at the moment it's restricted at 4,200. There's probably potential to put a small covered stand/terrace at the carpark end of the ground - this would probably mean taking a bit of space from the carpark but that shouldn't be too much of an issue but I wouldn't expect anything imminently - that's well down on the priority list.

outspoken
11/05/2022, 1:41 PM
There was talk of stadium improvements in their bid to take over the club but the Galway FA own the ground so there's probably a limited amount that can be done for the moment. There was talk of fixing the scoreboard etc.

At the moment the ground is one of the best in the League although should we get promoted the way crowds currently are and with the larger away support we possibly could do with some additional capacity - I think at the moment it's restricted at 4,200. There's probably potential to put a small covered stand/terrace at the carpark end of the ground - this would probably mean taking a bit of space from the carpark but that shouldn't be too much of an issue but I wouldn't expect anything imminently - that's well down on the priority list.

Is the carpark not already very small? Parking must be a nightmare for bigger games.

JC_GUFC
12/05/2022, 8:55 AM
Is the carpark not already very small? Parking must be a nightmare for bigger games.

Not really - there would be space to take another 3 to 4 metres I would say, in saying that maybe when the carpark is full I would think differently! I think there are about 200 spaces but it fills very quickly and generally is booked for players/sponsors etc.

There was an issue last season where a local councillor objected to people parking on the Dyke Road on match night. There is free parking at the Black Box Theatre on match day which is a 10 minute walk to the ground and probably has in the region of 500 spaces so generally it's ok - there are certainly worse grounds to try and park near.

outspoken
12/05/2022, 5:27 PM
Not really - there would be space to take another 3 to 4 metres I would say, in saying that maybe when the carpark is full I would think differently! I think there are about 200 spaces but it fills very quickly and generally is booked for players/sponsors etc.

There was an issue last season where a local councillor objected to people parking on the Dyke Road on match night. There is free parking at the Black Box Theatre on match day which is a 10 minute walk to the ground and probably has in the region of 500 spaces so generally it's ok - there are certainly worse grounds to try and park near.
Noticed all the traffic cones outside the ground the last day and was wondering where people were parking. Parking is a nightmare at the likes of Oriel, Richmond, Dalymount etc. Obviously most people find their own spots they become familiar with but you'd like to think it would be factored in to more modern stadiums.

EatYerGreens
16/05/2022, 10:55 AM
Not really - there would be space to take another 3 to 4 metres I would say, in saying that maybe when the carpark is full I would think differently! I think there are about 200 spaces but it fills very quickly and generally is booked for players/sponsors etc.

There was an issue last season where a local councillor objected to people parking on the Dyke Road on match night. There is free parking at the Black Box Theatre on match day which is a 10 minute walk to the ground and probably has in the region of 500 spaces so generally it's ok - there are certainly worse grounds to try and park near.

Ireland is going to have to move away from the idea that everyone is enabled to drive to and park near sports stadia though. There's some serious behavioural change required to meet the government's climate chnage targets, and not long to do it. So public transport is getting improved, and there is supposed to be a lot more cycling and walking infrastructure put in. Trip generators like ED Park should have cycle lanes and decent bicycle parking. Galway is a compact city, so no genuine reason why people shouldn't cycle more there.

JC_GUFC
16/05/2022, 11:07 AM
Ireland is going to have to move away from the idea that everyone is enabled to drive to and park near sports stadia though. There's some serious behavioural change required to meet the government's climate chnage targets, and not long to do it. So public transport is getting improved, and there is supposed to be a lot more cycling and walking infrastructure put in. Trip generators like ED Park should have cycle lanes and decent bicycle parking. Galway is a compact city, so no genuine reason why people shouldn't cycle more there.

I have actually asked the club about this earlier in the season - it was actually on the back of cycling to Dalymount Park and despite Bohs promoting a few of their women's matches as 'Cycle-to' events I have struggled to find any securing bicycle parking around the ground itself.

CorribsideSteve
16/05/2022, 11:29 AM
We have to figure out a way of banning vehicles from the city centre alltogether, something like a ring road would work, but Finn Harps ground will be built before that happens. The Dyke road is usually jammed solid of a Friday night with an attendance of about 1,500 and its little more than a bothrin. Galway was a town built in Mideival times with roads wide enough for a donkey and cart and it hasn't changed since the day the 1st house was built. If any city needs to be pedestrianized and made more accessible for cycling etc its Galway.

EatYerGreens
17/05/2022, 10:26 AM
We have to figure out a way of banning vehicles from the city centre alltogether, something like a ring road would work, but Finn Harps ground will be built before that happens. The Dyke road is usually jammed solid of a Friday night with an attendance of about 1,500 and its little more than a bothrin. Galway was a town built in Mideival times with roads wide enough for a donkey and cart and it hasn't changed since the day the 1st house was built. If any city needs to be pedestrianized and made more accessible for cycling etc its Galway.

The problem with the Galway Ring Road is that it will only attract and generate more traffic, not less. And the idea that it will enable more space for cycling, public transprot etc will most likely prove to be mythical, as gombeen local councillors will fight tooth and claw against any changes that disadvantage drivers.

People in Ireland have no concept of the extent of behavioural change that will be required in the very near future. Transport is Ireland's second largest generator of greenhouse gas emissions. During Covid - despite everything being locked down, people stuck at home or unable to go more than 5kn, not going to work, shops closed etc - Ireland's emissions from transport fell by only 16% (2020 vs 2019). The government is committed to a 51% fall in all emissions by 2030 - that's in 8yrs time. So when you compare what happened during Covid, you see how big the challenge is. And we've only 8yrs to get there. And then after that emissions need to be driven down to zero by 2050.

Stav
17/05/2022, 11:26 AM
So your team is playing Galway and you get the train from Dublin. You will not get one back after the match. Same applies to a bus. Public transport may be improving in Dublin and there were more buses on some routes 50 years ago than there are now but we have a long way to travel to make public transport a first option. Yes it would be easier and more enjoyable to get the train but the additional cost of a nights stay is not that appealing.

pineapple stu
17/05/2022, 11:48 AM
The problem is that excusing actions like that won't actually address the climate change issues EYG is talking about.

I don't think we've any real intention of addressing the issues tbh. Not until it's far too late anyway. It's far too inconvenient for the present

sbgawa
17/05/2022, 11:55 AM
The problem is that excusing actions like that won't actually address the climate change issues EYG is talking about.

I don't think we've any real intention of addressing the issues tbh. Not until it's far too late anyway. It's far too inconvenient for the present

Someone either comes up with an economical new technology way to reduce the hole in the Ozone or we are all Donald Ducked in the long long long long run, we arent going to make the changes off our own bat. Its like trying to get an 18 year old to drink a few pints less and start a pension scheme.
Hopefully someone does and we can go back to economical Diesel engines :)

pineapple stu
17/05/2022, 12:06 PM
Ozone hole isn't the issue any more - which goes to show we can address things if we want to. (From wiki - "In 2019, NASA reported that the ozone hole was the smallest ever since it was first discovered in 1982")

But carbon emissions are a far bigger thing, and even if we solve the problems on time, we're dependent on the US, China, the Middle East, etc, following suit. Which they almost certainly won't

sbgawa
17/05/2022, 12:12 PM
Ozone hole isn't the issue any more - which goes to show we can address things if we want to. (From wiki - "In 2019, NASA reported that the ozone hole was the smallest ever since it was first discovered in 1982")

But carbon emissions are a far bigger thing, and even if we solve the problems on time, we're dependent on the US, China, the Middle East, etc, following suit. Which they almost certainly won't

Exactly true, i still sort my rubbish etc but i do it with an acceptance that its about as useful as a chocolate fire guard, makes Eamon Ryan feel like he has a purpose in life i suppose

EalingGreen
17/05/2022, 1:04 PM
So your team is playing Galway and you get the train from Dublin. You will not get one back after the match. Same applies to a bus. Public transport may be improving in Dublin and there were more buses on some routes 50 years ago than there are now but we have a long way to travel to make public transport a first option. Yes it would be easier and more enjoyable to get the train but the additional cost of a nights stay is not that appealing.
If you were to take the enviromental argument to its logical conclusion (and I'm NOT advocating that!) then even convenient and frequent trains both ways on the day etc would not be acceptable, since even that uses up carbon emissions unnecessarily.

It's a bit like holidaying at home, instead of flying abroad for two weeks etc in that away fans could just watch the game live on a stream, while only home/local fans would actually go to the stadium. That way, it would just be like La Liga, where eg fans of Atletico don't travel en masse to the Bernabeu, or Espanol to the Camp Nou, but prefer instead to watch the game in supporters clubs and bars in their own neighbourhood. And you certainly don't get big numbers even from well-supported clubs like eg Sevilla travelling the length of Spain to attend matches in Santander etc.

But I repeat, I'm not advocating banning away fans from football, merely emphasising some of the hard choices which will have to be made in combatting climate change, including by football.

JC_GUFC
17/05/2022, 1:27 PM
So your team is playing Galway and you get the train from Dublin. You will not get one back after the match. Same applies to a bus. Public transport may be improving in Dublin and there were more buses on some routes 50 years ago than there are now but we have a long way to travel to make public transport a first option. Yes it would be easier and more enjoyable to get the train but the additional cost of a nights stay is not that appealing.

I know it's not really the point but there are late night buses that will take you to Dublin Airport if you're really against staying over in Galway! Obviously depending where you're from in Dublin it may be a 50 quid taxi fare from the airport so may not suit to end up there!

EalingGreen
17/05/2022, 1:37 PM
I know it's not really the point but there are late night buses that will take you to Dublin Airport if you're really against staying over in Galway! Obviously depending where you're from in Dublin it may be a 50 quid taxi fare from the airport so may not suit to end up there!
Surely it would be worth the train operator's while simply to delay the last train back to Dublin or Cork etc by an hour or two, if it meant they could transport an extra couple of hundred fans?

Though presumably that would require them to be arsed about doing a proper job...

pineapple stu
17/05/2022, 1:44 PM
I think your conclusion overlooks the probability that it's actually not worth their while doing that. Delaying a train an hour or two will annoy people who actually use it (compared to people who might use it), and running an additional train from Sligo (taking a PD team who actually have games in Dublin) once a month for those who don't mind getting back into Connolly at 2am mayn't be a big seller either.

A supporters' club bus is another public transport option of course.

EatYerGreens
17/05/2022, 2:18 PM
Exactly true, i still sort my rubbish etc but i do it with an acceptance that its about as useful as a chocolate fire guard, makes Eamon Ryan feel like he has a purpose in life i suppose

Except you're wrong really. You recycling reduces the amount of space required in Ireland for landfill, and the fines form the EU which that entails. It also means waste is turned into useful resource on an island that has very few natural resources. On related issues - You using less energy, and especially wasting less energy, would also directly benefit you financially. It has a higher net financial benefit to you than it does net benefit to the environment (although everything obviously helps). And switching Ireland to renewable energy sources, electric vehicles etc helps Ireland. Ireland has no fossiil fuels worth talking about, so we are currently a net energy importer. That is bad for both our energy security and our balance of trade. And a lot of the energy we import is via hateful regimes like the Saudis, the Qataris and the Russians. We have enough coastline, waterways etc to be a genuinely self-sufficient country in renewable energy. And even to generate a consistent surplus which we can sell to the rest of Europe - thereby making us all better off financially, creating jobs, extra tax revenues etc. Instead of just giivng all of that over to dodgy Arab regimes.

So it's not just about minor intangible impacts for the environment. It's about saving yourself money, making your country more secure, not funding sh!heads like the Saudis and the Russians, creating domestic jobs and improving living standards for everyone in Ireland. Reject all that if you really want to.

EatYerGreens
17/05/2022, 2:27 PM
If you were to take the enviromental argument to its logical conclusion (and I'm NOT advocating that!) then even convenient and frequent trains both ways on the day etc would not be acceptable, since even that uses up carbon emissions unnecessarily.

There is nothing that humanity does which doesn't have some sort of energy requirement. The issue is where that energy comes from, and how sustainable it is.

The Republic will be electrifying its rail in the coming decade or so. In the meantime, rail emits less emissions per average occupancy/passenger than cars do, so it's still significantly better than driving.

As everything humans do has some sort of impact, no-one is suggestig that everyone just sit at home and do nothing. It's about transitioning to less harmful and zero-harm alternatives.

Anyone who's genuinely interested in this, and the significant changes coming down the line for Ireland, should have a look at the National development Plan Project Ireland 2040 : gov.ie - Project Ireland 2040 ( (https://www.gov.ie/en/campaigns/09022006-project-ireland-2040/)www.gov.ie (http://www.gov.ie))

BTW - part of the reason why Spain doesn't have a large travelling club fan tradition is because fixtures in Spain often get changed at extremely short notice to facilitate live broadcast. As I found when I was in Cordoba on my way to see a game in Granada the following day, onyl to turn on the TV that night and discover the Granada game was being played 24hrs early.

EatYerGreens
17/05/2022, 2:32 PM
I know it's not really the point but there are late night buses that will take you to Dublin Airport if you're really against staying over in Galway! Obviously depending where you're from in Dublin it may be a 50 quid taxi fare from the airport so may not suit to end up there!

Have a look at strategies like 'Connecting Ireland' (for rural areas) and Bus Connects (for the 5 cities). It's all about acknowledging that buses are crap in Ireland, and coming up with significantly better future connnectivity via them.

All part of the bigger picture of climate-focused changes that are already happening, but which most people are oblivious to.

What is Connecting Ireland? - National Transport (https://www.nationaltransport.ie/connecting-ireland/what-is-connecting-ireland/)
Sustainable transport for a better city | Busconnects (https://busconnects.ie/)

Rail will have something similar once the All-Island Rail Review Strategy reports its findings at the end of this year.

Change is coming, people !

EalingGreen
17/05/2022, 3:48 PM
I think your conclusion overlooks the probability that it's actually not worth their while doing that.
Im not so sure. An extra couple of hundred fans attracted by the ease of travelling would surely pay for the overtime needed to delay a train which would have been travelling the route earlier anyhow? Especially if the drinks trolly was well stocked!


Delaying a train an hour or two will annoy people who actually use it (compared to people who might use it),.
Maybe, but what choice would they have? And besides, you're only talking a handful of occasions a year i.e. the vast majority of the timetable would be unaffected by "football specials".


... and running an additional train from Sligo (taking a PD team who actually have games in Dublin) once a month for those who don't mind getting back into Connolly at 2am mayn't be a big seller either.

Maybe, maybe not. Worth a trial for a season or two, I'd have thought.




A supporters' club bus is another public transport option of course.
It's not actually, since ordinary members of the "public" couldn't/wouldn't use it; also it is in addition to other bus and train services which already exist, rather than instead of them; as well as being higher carbon-footprint than a train.

pineapple stu
17/05/2022, 3:57 PM
Well you're assuming you're going to have a couple of hundred on it. Is that reasonable? And a stocked drinks trolley brings other issues (as IÉ have shown by taking drink away from some trains), so potentially more cost in terms of cleaning.

And I don't think "What choice would they have" is really great public service. Plus you're delaying the train a lot longer than you think. The last service from Sligo to Dublin on a Saturday leaves at 7:05pm, for example. You want to delay that to what - 10:15pm? That'd then get in at 1:15am. You're going to lose as many passengers as you gain doing that I'd say.

Yes, a supporters' bus is higher carbon footprint than the train, but it's still mass transit and therefore worth flagging in the context of Stav's "the only way is to drive" option. And yes, football special trains are worth considering and would be nice to have, but I don't think your comment "that would require them to be arsed about doing a proper job" is at all fair. I don't think you've thought it through enough, and I don't think you've shown IÉ haven't thought it through and decided that actually it's not worth it.

(Back in the LSL in the day, Longford and Sligo used to charter trains for games in Dublin, and possibly vice versa too, and that may still be an option)

EalingGreen
17/05/2022, 4:05 PM
There is nothing that humanity does which doesn't have some sort of energy requirement. The issue is where that energy comes from, and how sustainable it is.

As everything humans do has some sort of impact, no-one is suggestig that everyone just sit at home and do nothing. It's about transitioning to less harmful and zero-harm alternatives.

Having more energy efficient and sustainable power is obviously a huge contributor to where the planet needs to be.

But simply consuming less makes an even greater contribution, regardless of how the energy is generated. So that a football fan watching at home online is still "better" than travelling to an away game, even if it is on an electric train.

It might be after my time, but I can see the day when a number of activities we currently take for granted will be priced out of our reach (eg road-pricing, fuel duty, carbon taxes etc), or even curtailed completely (eg traffic free cities).



BTW - part of the reason why Spain doesn't have a large travelling club fan tradition is because fixtures in Spain often get changed at extremely short notice to facilitate live broadcast. As I found when I was in Cordoba on my way to see a game in Granada the following day, onyl to turn on the TV that night and discover the Granada game was being played 24hrs early.
Screwed-up TV scheduling has only exacerbated a problem which existed long before the regular televising of games, indeed before most homes even had a TV, never mind a mobile or a PC.

I've always assumed it was originally down to socio-economic factors (i.e. fans could just about afford to attend home games in what was long a very poor country); low car ownership; poor train services; large distances involved; and local/state rivalries and prejudices (i.e. Catalans or Basques not wanting to visit Castille or Andalucia and v.v.).

Meaning that Spanish fans never got into the habit of travelling away in numbers in the first place. And as with football everywhere, habit and tradition are huge factors in determining how fans behave.

EalingGreen
17/05/2022, 4:13 PM
Well you're assuming you're going to have a couple of hundred on it. Is that reasonable? And a stocked drinks trolley brings other issues (as IÉ have shown by taking drink away from some trains), so potentially more cost in terms of cleaning.

And I don't think "What choice would they have" is really great public service. Plus you're delaying the train a lot longer than you think. The last service from Sligo to Dublin on a Saturday leaves at 7:05pm, for example. You want to delay that to what - 10:15pm? That'd then get in at 1:15am. You're going to lose as many passengers as you gain doing that I'd say.

Yes, a supporters' bus is higher carbon footprint than the train, but it's still mass transit and therefore worth flagging in the context of Stav's "the only way is to drive" option. And yes, football special trains are worth considering and would be nice to have, but I don't think your comment "that would require them to be arsed about doing a proper job" is at all fair. I don't think you've thought it through enough, and I don't think you've shown IÉ haven't thought it through and decided that actually it's not worth it.
With LOI attendances currently increasing at an impressive rate, shouldn't people be thinking about capitalising on that in any way possible, esp if in a more sustainable, environmentally-friendly manner?

Meaning that a proper trial for a season or two could surely be worth it. After all, if it turned out to be a non-runner, how much would you have lost?

But maybe you're right, those where just the speculative musings of a non-expert, so that if you have superior expertise in the field, I'll happily bow to that.

pineapple stu
17/05/2022, 7:26 PM
I don't think a trial for a season or two makes sense; that's a very long trial. You could learn a lot trialing it for one match. They have trains to big matches in the GAA as far as I know, but I'd say evening kick-offs in the football means you're also having to work around night-time track maintenance (https://www.irishrail.ie/en-ie/news/iarnrod-eireann-night-time-track-works).

So as you say, they're "speculative musings of a non-expert", which is why I think the "that would require them to be arsed about doing a proper job" comment is very unfair.

Martinho II
17/05/2022, 7:39 PM
I know it's not really the point but there are late night buses that will take you to Dublin Airport if you're really against staying over in Galway! Obviously depending where you're from in Dublin it may be a 50 quid taxi fare from the airport so may not suit to end up there!

I got the Go Coach service a few weeks ago from Galway to Dublin and it doest stop at OConnell St at Eden Quay

Martinho II
17/05/2022, 7:43 PM
I dont mean to be awkward but what has this debate anything to do with Galway Utd?

sbgawa
17/05/2022, 9:35 PM
I dont mean to be awkward but what has this debate anything to do with Galway Utd?

We are debating how to get back from galway after they are promoted :)

joey B
18/05/2022, 1:15 AM
We are debating how to get back from galway after they are promoted :)

*in 2024
They have to lose to Harps in a play off first!!

Glen Of Aherlow
18/05/2022, 7:27 AM
It's all gone a bit Daniel Lambert here

sbgawa
18/05/2022, 8:33 AM
It's all gone a bit Daniel Lambert here

Ah jaysus dont say that the Galway lads still have hope of winning something