Stunned by U2

[Gerrit]

At very last moment I decided to go to Croke Park. I could not get a day off to travel with Shels to Waterford, so I thought I'd give it a go. Bought a second hand ticket for 120 euro, reasonable if you hear what some others gave for it.

I am not a U2 fan but do like most of their work. So went to the arena with the idea of "we'll see, don't know what to expect, but hopefully it will be a nice one"

It was a nice one... I am deeply impressed. They were absolutely great.

It started off a bit lame, it seemed Bono's voice didn't get through very well, it was mainly Edge's guitars dominating. But the problem was solved rapidly and then Bono proved he is a cracker frontman. Very charismatic, knows how to play the crowd, vocally very well. He surprised me in a very positive way.

The stage seemed very high-tech but was not used at all in the beginning. It proved to be a trick: saving the best for last. With every song the spectacle became bigger and bigger, special effects + displays on a giant screen + light effects... The setlist was very good as well: starting off with Vertigo, then saving most of the classics for last as if they were going towards an apotheose in the end (except for New Year's Day which was played rather early in the evening).

I was a bit afraid Bono's political issues would make it sound a bit mellow, but on the contrary. It gave the gig a unique extra dimension. It was simply a uniquely stunning moment when the whole 80000 fans lit the arena for the Burmese human rights fighter who's imprisoned, it was just as stunning when the whole crowd applauded when the Human Rights Charter was displayed on the giant screen and when Bono speeched on fighting poverty in Africa. There was so much in the small details, for example the word "coexist" with the Islamic moon sign forming the C, the Star of David forming the X, and the cross forming the T ; the three dominant religions' symbols all in such a powerful word. Simply brilliant.
The political issues didn't make it mellow a second. It was unique to see 80000 people make a collective mass statement for peace, the band actually turned a concert into something that goes way beyond a concert. The feeling of connection and brotherhood between everyone in the crowd was unique. United by the wish for a better world, united by love for music.

One of the best gigs I've been to in my life. The atmosphere was stunning, it was a big open air party of people having a good time and praying for a better world. The performance was excellent, the setlist very good as well. The build-up of the show was great, and even the weather gods were going along as the rain stopped pouring by the end of the gig :)
Big big class. I get this feeling when seeing my own idols (Placebo, Bunnymen) but was never so impressed and thrilled by a gig of any other band. I've seen Paul McCartney and the Stones in a recent past, but this was way better.

Stunning concert, and I'm even considering going back on Monday. We'll see if the budget allows it ;)

[Rovers1]

AMAZING wasnt it?
couldnt hear Bono very well for first few songs,(new years day,vertigo,i will follow) couldnt hear edge sing at all, but it was an AMAZING gig!! :eek:

[Gerrit]

During the first songs I could hear mainly The Edge and little of Bono, but they solved the problem later on. I was lucky though to sit on the lower parts of the stands, with a box very near my sit.

I think it was a superb gig, though mainly the atmosphere made it to what it was. Musically I am and remain a Bunnyman, but EATB will never have the finances to set up an impressing show like U2 can... :(

[liam88]

It was simply a uniquely stunning moment when the whole 80000 fans lit the arena for the Burmese human rights fighter who's imprisoned

:D :D
Persuming he played Walk On after/during this? One of my favourite songs ever!! (she's Aung Sung Suu Kyi by the way :) )

Like the sound of the "coexist"
Glad you enjoyed it!!

[redgav]

they had sound problems on friday which were sorted last nite
Went along last nite and tho I'm slightly biased being a aul u2 head but WOW
unbelievable gig-anyone goin on monday will be wiped out by it
Starts off with real old stuff like out of control ,I will follow etc and each track the light an display show gets bigger and better ,by the end the stage is just out of this world
Did a great version of my personal favourite (and a track they've not played live in years ) running to standstill, and some from the latest album including a ecoustic version of yehwah,and they did all the all the clasics like sunday bloody sunday,mysterious ays,the fly,......they really and truly still have it ....feel privilaged to have witnessed 100 thousand people rockin last nite, croker shook last nite ....I've been a fan since the early years and been to all their tours ,but last nite,they showed that they are like fine wine , getting better with age.Nver though the Joshua tree tour would be bettered but they came damn close last nite
Bono had the place rocking ,and it nearly had me in tears when the crowd continued the song ( miricle drug) when the band had stopped playing......

It wasn't at all political although the little speech to shame that fool bertie was class .100,000 people booing the little podgy f*cker was class

"Sometimes you can't make it on your own" blew me away , and when he did "one " with all the lights in the stadium out ,and only mobile fone lights on , that was just genius,felt like the sky had fallen

Cannot wait till monday's gig

[Drumcondra Red]

I went on Friday and I was very dissapointed, sound was shít, couldn't here a word Bono said either, I'm glad it was sorted out but it was VERY dissapointing to ruin a great show with crap sound!

[Anto McC]

All that Political bullsh*t in the middle wrecked my head,I went to the concert to see U2 play music,not to be told what to do with my money and who i should and should not vote for.

[EnDai]

Will we be able to hear them playing in Tolka? ;) If so, I'm bringing headphones!! :mad:

[4tothefloor]

:D :D
Persuming he played Walk On after/during this? One of my favourite songs ever!!
Modern pop rip-off of You'll Never Walk Alone......I like U2's music, but I can't stand Bono. The man's a tool, I'd puke if I had to listen to him or watch him girate for more than 10 minutes. I'd say the stage and effects were impressive though, U2 always pull out all the stops.

[Slash/ED]

All that Political bullsh*t in the middle wrecked my head,I went to the concert to see U2 play music,not to be told what to do with my money and who i should and should not vote for.


That's the kind of crap I expected from Bono and why I made no effort at all to get tickets despite likeing their music, espically their old stuff which is absolutley superb.

[Plastic Paddy]

I am not a U2 fan but do like most of their work. So went to the arena with the idea of "we'll see, don't know what to expect, but hopefully it will be a nice one"

It was a nice one... I am deeply impressed. They were absolutely great.

Good for you Gerrit. I had not a clue what "f**k the revolution" meant in 1984 and, although it took me many years to work through the issues, finally now I see where Hewson et al. were coming from. Despite coming from positions largely contrary to my own, this band and their music have helped me define and sharpen my beliefs and understand the humanity that underpins all those points of view that are not my own. Despite being the finest bombasts of me generation, I owe U2. Legends.

And - more importantly - they can still do it. What a show. U2 go bragh! :D

:ball: PP

[Gerrit]

:D :D
Persuming he played Walk On after/during this? One of my favourite songs ever!! (she's Aung Sung Suu Kyi by the way :) )

Like the sound of the "coexist"
Glad you enjoyed it!!

The 'coexist' thing was very simple yet stunning. Brilliant idea to mix the three main religions' symbols in that very word. The simple things are sometimes the greatest.

After the birthday song dedicated to Aung Sung Suu Kyi (I remembered the name but was afraid to make spelling mistakes in my previous post) he played "Running to stand still" I think, if I remember it well. I am not sure because it was a gig of over 2 hours and I can't exactly remember the order of the songs.

The setlist was brilliantly constructed, starting off with new and less known work, then when it moved on they fired all classics off to the audience and the stage was used in a better and better way.




Now don't get me wrong: I am and remain a fan of Echo & The Bunnymen more than of any other band. Musically they cannot be beaten by anyone IMO, and that includes U2.

But that doesn't mean I cannot enjoy U2 music or enjoy U2 gigs. It's different in the way that a U2 concert is more than just a concert, the Bunnymen simply could not afford to bring a show like that (which as other side of the medal means that they prove they don't need any high-tech trics to make their concerts impressing). I'd say a U2 concert in a unique experience because it's so much more than a concert: it's a grand spectacle and a massive prayer for peace and brotherhood, which is impressing. A Bunnymen concert is more like simply a concert.

I'm very glad I experienced this U2 gig and it was worth every euro. I won't suddenly be a U2 fan as in terms of finding them the best band ever, but my respect for them (which was already rather big) did grow a lot.

[Gerrit]

That's the kind of crap I expected from Bono and why I made no effort at all to get tickets despite likeing their music, espically their old stuff which is absolutley superb.

Well, you can expect that, can't you ? We all know Bono, so it was a bit predictable that he'd bring up African issues ;)

I feared for too many political references and that it would break the gig, but on the contrary, they did it in such a good way that it brought an atmosphere amongst the audience of all being united by the wish for a better place and by the love for music.

I just wonder what The Edge, Larry and Adam thought of it. It seems that The Edge is not very wild about Bono's political issues, i remember that a few years ago there were issues between the both of them because Edge thought Bono was not spending too much attention and time to the music anymore because of his political involvements. So I wonder if Edge, Larry and Adam were that glad with Bono spending 6 or 7 songs dedicated to his political ideals.
Then on the other hand, they seemed to enjoy the gig. The Edge seemed very emotional by the massive response from the audience...



Also I was surprised with the papers posting pics of Bono the day before the gig. He went to a few pubs in Dublin together with Gavin Friday and Gucci from the Virgin Prunes. I know the two bands formed a sort of underground society back in their early days (The Lypton Village) but I didn't know they were still in touch.
I kinda like the ideas of the Virgin Prunes, in a way I have more respect for their anti-commercial approach than for the steps towards commerce that U2 made after Achtung Baby.

[liam88]

Modern pop rip-off of You'll Never Walk Alone......

What?!?! Biggest load of rubbish I ever heard! The scum raping Burma banned that song because it got Aung Sung Suu Kyi to much support! Nout like YNWA!

Walk on
Walk on
What you got, they can't steal it
No they can't even feel it


Up the NLD

[Plastic Paddy]

I just wonder what The Edge, Larry and Adam thought of it. It seems that The Edge is not very wild about Bono's political issues, i remember that a few years ago there were issues between the both of them because Edge thought Bono was not spending too much attention and time to the music anymore because of his political involvements

I should think that several million Euro each over the years and across the piece might well have mollified any angst that Evans, Clayton and Mullen were/are feeling over Bono's "issues". (I know it would me.) But then, I'm just an old and shrivelling cynic. :eek:

:ball: PP

[Troy.McClure]

Great concert alright (although I prefered Slane when we beat the Dutch). There wasnt too much political stuff to be fair, Mirical Drug was dedicated to helth care professionals more because of recient personal experiences of the band and every one likes a good boo at Bertie, after all Bono was just pointing out that Bertie was continuing to break another of his promises. Dont think that the ASSK video would have shown if it wasnt her birthday but I found it very moving and what can you say about all the mobile phones 'lighting up like a Xmas tree'... one of the most increadable sights Ive ever seen :o

They had the sound sorted fairly quickly, although I could hear him sing anyway coz I was in the pit :cool:. Thought the start of Vertigo was great + the version Elevation was mad too. The stage set was incredable too. How poxy was that that Canadian guy Mat though :mad: That b@stard lived my dream :mad: (he got pulled out of the crowd and played guitar for one of the songs)

[Rovers1]

i dont see how anyone could have been dissapionted with that show,i payed 60 euro and would have gladly paid more,what a show!!! the only problems i found was that blinding lights should have been played later for full effect of lights, couldnt hear Bono for a while,and edges guitar on SBS was almost too loud, but i really cannot complain, U2-ABSOULUTE LEGENDS :cool:

[Macy]

Turned out I was in block 332 not 333, so even closer... :)

Didn't think the sound was great tbh, but great to hear Out of Control, Electric Co live. And actually Party Girl with Canadian bloke guesting/picked from the crowd. Good visually once it was dark, fookin residents making it an early start.....

[monutdfc]

I'm with Drumcondra Red on this - the sound quality was very poor, and for €70 you expect better than that. In fairness to U2 they always put on a great show and try to give value for money, but they were badly let down by their sound engineers. I mean how hard is it to do some soundchecks?
Snow Patrol were meant to be on at 7.30 but they were gone when I arrived at 8, but u2 weren't on until about 9.15. Could have filled that gap.
And finally, Bono was completely out of key for With or Without You, either that or his voice went completely.

I enjoyed the show, don't get me wrong, but it wasn't up to their usual high standard.
Edge's guitar playing was awesome.

[Macy]

And finally, Bono was completely out of key for With or Without You, either that or his voice went completely.
I've noticed an increasing trend of Bono's to get the crowd to sing the high notes... Actually slips under the radar until you notice it...

[Baker]

Went Friday night, one of the best gigs I've ever been to!

We were on the pitch and got a spot near enough to the front so didnt notice any problems with the sound that seem to have affected a lot of the stadium.

I didnt like the political bit around the middle and the version of Walk On was disappointing despite the fact its one of my favourite U2 tunes. The two encores were breathtaking, the whole place went nuts!

Whatever anyone says about U2 you'll be looking a long time before you find another band that puts on such a good show.

Just sorry its all over now!

[Lionel Ritchie]

anyone got a setlist? -I'm not a u2 fan or anything.

-just that I've heard that the setlists shoot through the head Paul McGuinness' assertion that the band aren't whoring it round the cabaret circuit.

He claimed that approx a dozen songs in the set were from the last two LPs which I heard someone claim last night was a barefaced lie.

[Drumcondra Red]

Friday's was:

Vertigo
I Will Follow
Electric Co.
Elevation
New Year's Day
Beautiful Day
Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For
Wild Horses
City of Blinding Lights
Miracle Drug
Sometimes You Can't Make It On Your Own
Love and Peace
Sunday Bloody Sunday
Bullet The Blue Sky
Running To Stand Still
Pride In The Name of Love
Where The Streets Have No Name
One

Zoo Station
The Fly
With or Without You

All Because of You
Yahweh
Vertigo

[Macy]

Saturday's...

Vertigo
Out of Control
Electric Co.
Elevation
New Year's Day
Beautiful Day
Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For
All I Want is You
City of Blinding Lights
Miracle Drug
Sometimes You Can't Make It On Your Own
Love and Peace
Sunday Bloody Sunday
Bullet The Blue Sky
Running To Stand Still
Pride In The Name of Love
Where The Streets Have No Name
One

Zoo Station
The Fly
Mysterious Ways
Party Girl
All Because of You
Yahweh
Vertigo

Not sure I get you're point - plenty of recent stuff, and several of the older one's wouldn't be that widely known, unless you were a fan.

[Lionel Ritchie]

Certainly on the saturday set theres 10 possibly 11 songs I either know to be from the last two or haven't heard of and so am presuming them to be from recent LPs so it does appear McGuinness is on solid enough ground

Vertigo
Electric Co. (?)
Elevation
Beautiful Day
City of Blinding Lights
Miracle Drug (?)
Sometimes You Can't Make It On Your Own
Love and Peace (?)
Party Girl (?)
All Because of You
Yahweh (?)

...and they started and finished with Vertigo? -jaysis I'd find that annoying. An act with a 20-odd year canon of work repeating songs. Morrissey did the same with 'There Is A Light...' before christmas and I was not amused.

[fosterdollar]

Morrissey did the same with 'There Is A Light...' before christmas and I was not amused.
Tough crowd... ;)

[Macy]

Electric Co is on Boy and the Under a Blood Red Sky live album
Party Girl is an early B side (October era I think) and also on Under a Blood Red Sky.

The others you question are on the new album. So maybe not the 12, but hardly caberet circuit stuff either. He also did a few bits of Walk not then there was also a few bits of the Hands That Built America (during Bullet the Blue Sky) and Walk On (during Running to Stand Still) iirc.

Think it's a cop out too to repeat the same song twice, although not really the same version, given the Boys are Back in Town/ Jailbreak additions. Also big screen wasn't on for the opening....

[Lionel Ritchie]

Tough crowd... ;)

Ah it's just these gigs are never more than 2 hours and the amount of stuff that wasn't played to make way for two runs through There is a Light was frustrating -had it been an impromptu reprise you wouldn't have been bothered -but he knew the first time he was doing it that they'd be finishing with it as well which I considered a cop out as there was no room for Ouija Board, Boxers, Interesting Drug.... Likewise I'm sure there's U2 fans who wouldn't have minded hearing something else -though i take the point about the screen.

[Macy]

Ah it's just these gigs are never more than 2 hours and the amount of stuff that wasn't played to make way for two runs through There is a Light was frustrating -had it been an impromptu reprise you wouldn't have been bothered -but he knew the first time he was doing it that they'd be finishing with it as well which I considered a cop out as there was no room for Ouija Board, Boxers, Interesting Drug.... Likewise I'm sure there's U2 fans who wouldn't have minded hearing something else -though i take the point about the screen.
If it was a straight re-run then I would've been more píssed off but it wasn't so doesn't matter that much. Everytime I've seen Primal Scream they've repeated their first song as the encore.... :rolleyes:

[Gerrit]

I only saw Friday, but I think the first encore and the texts posted on the screen were an absolute highlight, they sounded more new-wave like than ever then. Also I was very pleasantly surprised by Sometimes You Can't Make It... I saw a live recording on the internet where Bono had problems with his voice during this song, didn't sound good at all. Friday it sounded stunning.

Too bad they didn't play Electrical Storm, my favourite post-eighties U2 song.

[Countyman]

Saw them again last night and they blew me out of the water. Was there friday as well but didnt have the same impact for me. Maybe because of the sound and the bad seats i had in the canal end.


But last night they rocked. There was a real edge (no pun intended) to some of the harder songs like An Cat Dhubh , Bloody Sunday, Love and Peace, Bullet etc.

40 was another highlight as was Gloria. The old stuff is by far the best for me.

Didnt mind the 2 Vertigos - There was a lot of improvisation in them anyway and the place was bouncing for the encore version.

I thought bonos voice was on the verge of collapse at one stage but he held it together. Even Larry got to sing centre stage a few times.

Definately one of the best U2 gigs I've ever been too last night. Thank you God for the ticket!

[Countyman]

How did I forget BAD . bloody hell that was class.

Here's the setlist

Vertigo
All Because of You
Gloria
Elevation
An Cat Dubh / Into the Heart
Beautiful Day
Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For
Original of the Species
Bad
City of Blinding Lights
Miracle Drug
Sometimes You Can't Make It On Your Own
Love and Peace
Sunday Bloody Sunday
Bullet The Blue Sky
Running To Stand Still
Pride In The Name of Love
Where The Streets Have No Name
One

Zoo Station
The Fly
With or Without You
Vertigo

Yahweh
'40'

[tetsujin1979]

Was in the Canal End Upper Tier last night, absolutly amazing. Perfect view, sound. Blew me away.
Edge strumming the intro to Elevation with the crowd going "wooo-ooooo"
"My name is Paul, but my friends call me Bono"
Sunday, Bloody Sunday
Elevation twice
The one-armed bandit effect on the screen
Tony Blair getting booed

Special mention to Ash playing Kung Fu!

[Gerrit]

Saw them again last night and they blew me out of the water. Was there friday as well but didnt have the same impact for me. Maybe because of the sound and the bad seats i had in the canal end.


But last night they rocked. There was a real edge (no pun intended) to some of the harder songs like An Cat Dhubh , Bloody Sunday, Love and Peace, Bullet etc.

40 was another highlight as was Gloria. The old stuff is by far the best for me.

Didnt mind the 2 Vertigos - There was a lot of improvisation in them anyway and the place was bouncing for the encore version.

I thought bonos voice was on the verge of collapse at one stage but he held it together. Even Larry got to sing centre stage a few times.

Definately one of the best U2 gigs I've ever been too last night. Thank you God for the ticket!

I went to the Friday show, they didn't play 40" and Gloria then, and I'm not sure anymore but think An Cat Dubh was also not there the first two Croker gigs. Did the special effects and films projected on the screens vary as well from what they did the first night ?

[Countyman]

I went to the Friday show, they didn't play 40" and Gloria then, and I'm not sure anymore but think An Cat Dubh was also not there the first two Croker gigs. Did the special effects and films projected on the screens vary as well from what they did the first night ?

to be honest I had to keep ducking down to see the big screen on friday night as I was right at the back of the lower levels. Throw about 9 5 euro pints of Budwater into the mix and the memory is a bit fuzzy.

Last night The big screen only kicked in from City of blinding lights and gradually built to a crescendo with major highlights being Love and Peace / Bloody sunday / Bullet the blue sky / Streets / Zoo station and especially The Fly.

For me the best effect was seeing croker lit up and gazing around 3 stands.
Incredible!

[Peadar]

For me the best effect was seeing croker lit up and gazing around 3 stands.
Incredible!

Same for me.
Tried to capture it in my pictures (http://foot.ie/showthread.php?t=26700) but didn't do it justice.
For a moment, I believed that all present in the stadium could Make Poverty History and could end world hunger. :o

[Eire06]

For me the best effect was seeing croker lit up and gazing around 3 stands.
Incredible!

It would have been much better if they had turned off the lights in the corporate boxes.. that kinda took away from the effect :(

[Peadar]

that kinda took away from the effect :(

On the contarary, in my opinion, it added to the affect.
It gave a greater sense of scale to the venue.
Perhaps it just looked different from where you were sitting.

[Eire06]

On the contarary, in my opinion, it added to the affect.
It gave a greater sense of scale to the venue.
Perhaps it just looked different from where you were sitting.
I was standing right in front of the stage so could see all around and it did take away from the effect IMO...

The stage lighting was great though.. the old man walking (Bono's Dad) for 'Sometimes You Can't Make It On Your Own' looked class.. as did the lighting for City of Blinding lights

[fosterdollar]

For a moment, I believed that all present in the stadium could Make Poverty History and could end world hunger. :o
I heard Bono talked about the horrors of poverty, and that was followed by George Best talking about the wonders of a sober lifestyle.

[Countyman]

It would have been much better if they had turned off the lights in the corporate boxes.. that kinda took away from the effect :(

it wasnt just the corporate boxes. It was the back of the lower and middle tiers as well. I thinks its a safety thing. Bugged the hell out of me friday night as I was at the back of the lower canal.

Still though when the whole stadium was lit up it was incredible. The safety lights definately didnt detract from that effect.

You must be all google eyed being that close to the big screen. I know I am and I was half way back. :) Then again maybe it was the pot smoking teenagers beside me that caused it.

[Eire06]

it wasnt just the corporate boxes. It was the back of the lower and middle tiers as well. I thinks its a safety thing. Bugged the hell out of me friday night as I was at the back of the lower canal.

Still though when the whole stadium was lit up it was incredible. The safety lights definately didnt detract from that effect.

You must be all google eyed being that close to the big screen. I know I am and I was half way back. :) Then again maybe it was the pot smoking teenagers beside me that caused it.
I was wondering what that smell was :rolleyes:

Didn't have to look at the screen cause could see everything on stage from where I was standing :D

[Peadar]

the old man walking (Bono's Dad) for 'Sometimes You Can't Make It On Your Own' looked class..


Didn't have to look at the screen cause could see everything on stage from where I was standing :D

So you saw Bono's Dad on stage?
Make up your mind, girl.
There was stuff on the screen which wasn't what was happening on stage.

[Eire06]

So you saw Bono's Dad on stage?
Make up your mind, girl.
There was stuff on the screen which wasn't what was happening on stage.
Don't be such a smart ass
The old man was not on what I would call the screen it was part of the lighting show..
the screens were above thats at the side of the lighting display showing the band members on stage.. and two screens at the sides of the stage showing the band too..

[paul_oshea]

bonos father is dead, so how was the old man bonos dad??? :confused: :confused:

[Eire06]

bonos father is dead, so how was the old man bonos dad??? :confused: :confused:
Your a bit slow aren't you :rolleyes:

[paul_oshea]

ye mean to tell me you only figured that out now???

[Troy.McClure]

ye mean to tell me you only figured that out now???

I've been waiting for the right time to use this to get this grudge off me back :) ;) :p (http://foot.ie/showpost.php?p=298096&postcount=19)

Only kidding :D

[4tothefloor]

What?!?! Biggest load of rubbish I ever heard! The scum raping Burma banned that song because it got Aung Sung Suu Kyi to much support! Nout like YNWA!

Walk on
Walk on
What you got, they can't steal it
No they can't even feel it


Up the NLD

What? I coudn't care less what political achievements the song has enjoyed, I listen to music for the entertainment value, not to be lectured by some tool like Bono. You see that's why I feel like puking everytime I hear\see Bono, the political BS that he goes on with. If he's so worried about poverty etc, why doesn't he start up some schemes in these countries with the vast wealth that he has earned? Why doesn't he do a Bob Geldof, and instead of talking $hit all the time, actually go out and organise big concerts\fundraising events? I'd pay good money to give him a good kick in the balls to be honest...

Regarding the song, IMO it sounds like a modern pop version of YNWA, emotionally it sounds the same, and that's all i'm interested in.