ireland players ranked 1 to 11

[livehead1]

rite imagine there are these 11 players in a starting line up:
shay given
stephen carr
richard dunne
kenny cunningham
john o'shea
roy keane
andy reid
kevin kilbane
aiden mcgeady
damien duff
robbie keane

now rank them 1 to 11. 11 being the best ability wise/most important to ireland and 11 being the least
mine would be
roy keane
damien duff
shay given
robbie keane
kenny cunningham
andy reid
kevin kilbane
stephen carr
aiden mcgeady
stephen carr
john o'shea

[cullenswood]

rite imagine there are these 11 players in a starting line up:
shay given
stephen carr
richard dunne
kenny cunningham
john o'shea
roy keane
andy reid
kevin kilbane
aiden mcgeady
damien duff
robbie keane

now rank them 1 to 11. 11 being the best ability wise/most important to ireland and 11 being the least
mine would be
roy keane
damien duff
shay given
robbie keane
kenny cunningham
andy reid
kevin kilbane
stephen carr
aiden mcgeady
stephen carr
john o'shea
Another Bored foot.ie user!!

Given
Keane
Duff
Cunningham
Keane
Dunne
Kilbane
Reid
Carr
OShea
McGeady
McGeady

[eirebhoy]

Shay Given is our most important player by a country mile.

[noby]

11 being the best ability wise/most important to ireland and 11 being the least


So, which 11 is a typo?

[eirebhoy]

Importance wise (not ability wise):

Given
Cunningham
Duff
Roy Keane
Robbie Keane
Carr
Dunne
Kilbane
O'Shea
Reid
McGeady

[livehead1]

So, which 11 is a typo?
wups 1 been most impt etc...

[Closed Account 2]

...
now rank them 1 to 11. 11 being the best ability wise/most important to ireland and 11 being the least
mine would be
roy keane
damien duff
shay given
robbie keane
kenny cunningham
andy reid
kevin kilbane
stephen carr
aiden mcgeady
stephen carr
john o'shea

Is it me or have you Stephen Carr twice in that list ?

[loscherland]

1. damien duff
2. shay given
3. robbie keane
4. roy keane
5. kevin kilbane
6. kenny cunningham
7. stephen carr
8. andy reid
9. richard dunne
10. john o'shea
11. aiden mcgeady