PDA

View Full Version : Has Anyone Won It All


El-Pietro
18/01/2012, 8:55 AM
I was thinking about this recently and have discussed it with a few friends and we can't think of anyone who has one every trophy available to a League of Ireland player currently.

League
FAI Cup
Setanta Cup
League Cup
First Division

There are lots of players with all bar one, players without the first Division or Setanta Cup for example.

I posted this on the City forum and we think we may have an answer in Jason Byrne. Can anyone confirm?

We're thinking if anyone has done it they would have needed to move around a lot. Derry and Sligo haven't won the league recently enough most likely and haven't won a Setanta, Bohs have no first Division, City have no League Cup in recent years, Shamrock have no domestic cups.

Most likely there have been players who have done something similar in previous years pre Setanta though
Dunny
18/01/2012, 8:57 AM
I dont think Jason Byrne won the first division
Sam_Heggy
18/01/2012, 9:18 AM
I dont think Jason Byrne won the first division

Did he not win the 1st Div with Bray?
Dunny
18/01/2012, 9:21 AM
Not sure, this is the list of honours I have for him anyway.

2003, 2004 & 2006 Premier Division (Shelbourne), 2008 & 2009 Premier Division (Bohemians), 1999 FAI Cup (Bray Wanderers), 2008 FAI Cup (Bohemians), 2010 Setanta Sports Cup (Bohemians)
Martinho II
18/01/2012, 8:50 PM
lads Jason Byrne has most definitely won every trophy possible in the league of ireland. in the 99/00 season he was part of the bray wanderers side that won the first division championship ahead of us that season. he only signed for shels in 03 season after being part of bray side that got relegated!
Lim till i die
18/01/2012, 11:57 PM
Fabio O'Brien??
SkStu
19/01/2012, 2:29 AM
I think Roddy Collins has. He reckons he has anyway...
TheBoss
19/01/2012, 2:33 PM
Fabio O'Brien??

He has won 4 out of the 5.


How many games does a player have to play to be considered a league winner ?
GCdfc
19/01/2012, 2:57 PM
He has won 4 out of the 5.


How many games does a player have to play to be considered a league winner ?

Usually it's around 10.
BonnieShels
19/01/2012, 7:06 PM
Not sure, this is the list of honours I have for him anyway.

2003, 2004 & 2006 Premier Division (Shelbourne), 2008 & 2009 Premier Division (Bohemians), 1999 FAI Cup (Bray Wanderers), 2008 FAI Cup (Bohemians), 2010 Setanta Sports Cup (Bohemians)


Has he won the LSC though? :)
Martinho II
19/01/2012, 7:43 PM
Has he won the LSC though? :)

dont think so..just looked up wikipedia..

Jason Byrne first played for bray in 98/99 season winners that year were:wayside celtic. 1999/00 winners were st pats. since then shels won it in 2000 and last yr st pats so no its not the case..

Question I know in 2000/01 we played Kilkenny city that season in LSC how come the final was never played?
BonnieShels
19/01/2012, 7:50 PM
dont think so..just looked up wikipedia..

Jason Byrne first played for bray in 98/99 season winners that year were:wayside celtic. 1999/00 winners were st pats. since then shels won it in 2000 and last yr st pats so no its not the case..

Question I know in 2000/01 we played Kilkenny city that season in LSC how come the final was never played?

I just emailed the LFA. That would bug me not knowing. Though I'd say Dodge or The Boss may have an idea.
dfx-
20/01/2012, 12:52 AM
I think Roddy Collins has. He reckons he has anyway...

He knows it all..
Martinho II
20/01/2012, 7:55 PM
dont think so..just looked up wikipedia..

Jason Byrne first played for bray in 98/99 season winners that year were:wayside celtic. 1999/00 winners were st pats. since then shels won it in 2000 and last yr st pats so no its not the case..

Question I know in 2000/01 we played Kilkenny city that season in LSC how come the final was never played?

let me know how you get on bonnieshels with them.. I compile stats for LTFC and have that marked down as a game.. if that game is declared null and void I will have to change my records for that season and for player appearances!
BonnieShels
20/01/2012, 9:28 PM
let me know how you get on bonnieshels with them.. I compile stats for LTFC and have that marked down as a game.. if that game is declared null and void I will have to change my records for that season and for player appearances!


Maybe the winner of that game was declared the LSC winner? Curiouser and curiouser. :)
TheBoss
21/01/2012, 1:17 AM
let me know how you get on bonnieshels with them.. I compile stats for LTFC and have that marked down as a game.. if that game is declared null and void I will have to change my records for that season and for player appearances!

A thread yourself started about the topic seems to have some answers: http://foot.ie/threads/139336-leinster-senior-cup-2000-01
nigel-harps1954
21/01/2012, 1:50 AM
What about Dessie Baker? Can't be far off it? Anyone?
BonnieShels
21/01/2012, 11:08 PM
A thread yourself started about the topic seems to have some answers: http://foot.ie/threads/139336-leinster-senior-cup-2000-01


I'm guessing that's why the heads in the LFA haven't gotten back to me... :rolleyes:
Martinho II
22/01/2012, 8:34 PM
What about Dessie Baker? Can't be far off it? Anyone?


Dessie Baker League championship 99/00 2011
FAI Cup 1999/00,2004,
league cup 2004
Setanta Cup never
First Division Championship Dundalk 2008
A face
25/01/2012, 8:06 AM
Setanta Cup never

Where is he now?
nigel-harps1954
25/01/2012, 10:45 AM
Did Ollie Cahill ever play first division?
Martinho II
25/01/2012, 8:02 PM
Did Ollie Cahill ever play first division?

never he always was in the top flight...