Shelbourne and Tolka

[Poor Student]

Plus - do you expect things to have not changed at all in 2-3yrs time ?

Of course, they'll be even worse.

[dcfcsteve]

Of course, they'll be even worse.

On what basis ?

[peadar1987]

Of course things will be better. There are Green Shoots. Green Shoots!

[rerun]

Of course things will be better. There are Green Shoots. Green Shoots!

Green Scores!!!

Sorry, couldn't resist :D

[drummerboy]

There are plenty of empty apartments within spitting distance of Tolka as the moment. Can't see anything being built for at least 2 years.

[Higgo]

Isn't that what it's like most Friday nights anyway?




:cool:

Jaysus that's poor:rolleyes:

Shels supporters may be small in number but they are extremely loyal which, to be fair, is more than can be said for your support. I find it quite pathetic that fans of other LOI clubs regularly jeer our crowds considering the fact that attendances are very poor across the board (with one obvious exception).

Back on topic, I think the general concensus amongst Shels supporters is that this move is a step in the wrong direction. It's fair to say that we are now paying dearly for past 'indiscretions'. We will never be able to build anything in Phibsboro'. Worrying times for the club, on and off the pitch.

[thischarmingman]

Jaysus that's poor:rolleyes:

Shels supporters may be small in number but they are extremely loyal which, to be fair, is more than can be said for your support. I find it quite pathetic that fans of other LOI clubs regularly jeer our crowds considering the fact that attendances are very poor across the board (with one obvious exception).


Get a life, it was clearly a joke.

[tallaghtfornia]

Four letters, NAMA. The speculators want Shels out to sell this asset to the state and walk away.

Shels have played a blinder here. Bohs are in such financial meltdown that they have taken the paltry €150k for 5 years and the FAI have allowed this as turnover for this year. Shels sit pretty and wait till the Bohs v Albion/Danninger spat pans out and will be in a position at some point to consider a bid for the Connaught St side or even return to Tolka if NAMA want to generate revenue via its use.

The irony is Bohs turned down a similar deal with noughts on the end of it 5 years ago.

Is this a definate?? I dont want to see Bohs go bust but surely the FAI letting them use it as income for 2009 is just making the hole bigger in D7. Will they let them stick down 120k next season? Surely sticking down 30k in next seasons budget and the four budgets after that while trying to work with some sort of realism is a demand from the FAI to Bohs??

[dcfcsteve]

Is this a definate?? I dont want to see Bohs go bust but surely the FAI letting them use it as income for 2009 is just making the hole bigger in D7. Will they let them stick down 120k next season? Surely sticking down 30k in next seasons budget and the four budgets after that while trying to work with some sort of realism is a demand from the FAI to Bohs??

I'm no Accountant, but normal convention surely dictates that the sum should be amortised/represented equally across the full period of the occupancy it relates to.

Does the FAI stipulate what sort of Accounting conventions can be used in the wage cap calculations, or can it literally be made up to the benefit of each individual club ?

The flip side of Bohs treating it all as income this year is that Shels would therefore have to treat it all as expenditure this year as well. Would that then impact their own 65% situation ? (I suspect not, as it doesn't impact turnover, but still worth asking).

[John83]

The flip side of Bohs treating it all as income this year is that Shels would therefore have to treat it all as expenditure this year as well. Would that then impact their own 65% situation ? (I suspect not, as it doesn't impact turnover, but still worth asking).
You're correct in this: it doesn't affect Shels' compliance with the 65% rule at all.

On the other points you raise, I don't know. Pineapple Stu can answer the first, but the second is probably known only to the FAI, a cabal of club accountants and a telepathic florist who can be found begging at the Abbey Street Luas stop on Tuesdays.

[pineapple stu]

The FAI will make up whatever rules they want, TBH. I - or anyone else - can't predict them.

A nice anomoly I see, though, is Bohs putting 5 years' rent into this year's accounts and Shels, correctly, putting no rent into this year's accounts (cos they don't rent till next year). Voila - E150k profit for the league. Yay FAI!

[KK77]

Very sad to see Tolka go. Have many many fond memories of going to games there over the years.