Do The Powers That Be Read Foot.ie ?

[ShnaeGuevara715]

Hmm, that rhymes.

Every other day folk post up new ideas on league structure etc on everything from academies, to cup competitions, leagues and so on. Infact it seems its the only purpose some people are here..!

I've only been on foot.ie for about 2 years, but is there any indication that They have ever read the articles/nicked the good ideas? Have to admit this place has a massive ideas turnover, has to be a diamond in the rough somewhere that Abbotstown couldn't resist nabbing in the past?

[niallsparky]

I would assume that they have somebody that would have the odd look around here. In fact I'd be pretty surprised if they didn't.

[pól-dcfc]

I think it would be severe neglect if they didn't have someone having a look around here. It's the one place to find a group of usually very committed fans of a diverse range of clubs in the same place at the same time.

[billybunter]

I can tell you for a fact they do. About 6 years I made a post on a football website about the shop (or lack there of) on the FAI website. And lo and behold, 6 years later its only a few weeks from opening. So keep those idea's coming!!

[holidaysong]

Hopefully they didn't read any of CelticTiger's suggestions..

[pineapple stu]

I was in a few meetings with the FAI a while back (the NLSA thing), and one of the things that came up was asking us to try and stop people posting so many negative things about the FAI on here. They're fairly conscious of the amount of bad press on here, it seems (more so than is sensible really).

[bennocelt]

I was in a few meetings with the FAI a while back (the NLSA thing), and one of the things that came up was asking us to try and stop people posting so many negative things about the FAI on here. They're fairly conscious of the amount of bad press on here, it seems (more so than is sensible really).


wow interesting, thats good to know:p

[Monkfish]

Hopefully they didn't read any of CelticTiger's suggestions..

Hopefully they dont stray into the Off Topic section or we'll all be dismissed as a shower of weirdo loser types. :o

[Dodge]

Hopefully they dont stray into the Off Topic section or we'll all be dismissed as a shower of weirdo loser types. :o

They all support Liverpool or man utd, they already think we're weirdo loser types

[pól-dcfc]

try and stop people posting so many negative things about the FAI on here.

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/6/66/Adolf_Hitler-1933.jpg/225px-Adolf_Hitler-1933.jpg

Pineapple Ztu, ve must make zem comply mit our vishes!

If they want people to stop criticising them they should get their act together.

[Longfordian]

I know from personal experience that they're very aware of what goes up on here and quite likely to try and find out who put it up. A few other members have similar stories I believe.

[John83]

If they want people to stop criticising them they should get their act together.
Yeah, that's part of it.

Thing is, even if they were running things very well, they'd still get heaps of abuse over any tiny thing that went wrong, or was perceived to be wrong.

Also, there's a tendency to become institutionalised in a place like that - even fair, valid ciriticism is seen as an unreasonable attack on you and the people you work with.

Besides, I'm sure at least half the stuff we get aggitated about is just plain wrong (rumours, misinterpretations, spin from some ****ed off manager or chairman), and it must be galling for them to take stick over that.

But yeah, as long as there are clubs being denied a licence over the colour of pen used, and other clubs being given one in spite of not having the resources to last half a season, they'll get hassle here.

[eamo1]

Nick Leeson at a Galway Utd fans forum asked the fans to not post most of what was discussed up on our unoffical site M.B.Didnt the Drogs Chairman(name escapes me) make a similar plea to their fans too a few months ago??My point being that the "they"(FAI Board etc) might not be much aware of fans on the net but Chairmen seem to be.

[pól-dcfc]

Yeah, that's part of it.

Thing is, even if they were running things very well, they'd still get heaps of abuse over any tiny thing that went wrong, or was perceived to be wrong.

Also, there's a tendency to become institutionalised in a place like that - even fair, valid ciriticism is seen as an unreasonable attack on you and the people you work with.

Besides, I'm sure at least half the stuff we get aggitated about is just plain wrong (rumours, misinterpretations, spin from some ****ed off manager or chairman), and it must be galling for them to take stick over that.

But yeah, as long as there are clubs being denied a licence over the colour of pen used, and other clubs being given one in spite of not having the resources to last half a season, they'll get hassle here.

Every organisation in the world has to put up with unwarranted stick. To be perfectly fair, the FAI haven't covered themselves in glory. True, they arranged MNS for us. Yeah, advertising has got slightly better. But the licensing has been a farce, and that's the one thing (ok, it's a series of loads of smaller things) that could actually make the league a bit more popular.

Until they make clubs stick to their commitments, particularly in relation to stadia, they will be criticised. Asking a member to try and stop people outlining their gripes on a forum isn't on.

[John83]

Every organisation in the world has to put up with unwarranted stick. To be perfectly fair, the FAI haven't covered themselves in glory. True, they arranged MNS for us. Yeah, advertising has got slightly better. But the licensing has been a farce, and that's the one thing (ok, it's a series of loads of smaller things) that could actually make the league a bit more popular.

Until they make clubs stick to their commitments, particularly in relation to stadia, they will be criticised.
Yeah, I don't disagree with you on any of that.

I still hold some (possibly naive) hope that licensing will gradually come good, that Bohs are the last club with a rotten financial basis, and that we'll eventually have a league where I would be genuinely surprised to hear that some players weren't paid this month, but every new financial crisis eats away at that. I don't trust them when they say that things are improving. The FAI's attitude has long seemed to be that if no one hears about it, it's not a problem. Which leads us neatly to...

Asking a member to try and stop people outlining their gripes on a forum isn't on.
Yeah. They want us to shut up and trust them, but they rarely give us any reason to trust them.

[passerrby]

I would say its more important to make clubs live up to the financial committments than anything else, espically wages, tranfers and general spending

[John83]

I would say its more important to make clubs live up to the financial committments than anything else, espically wages, tranfers and general spending
Except that they have a habit of making committments they can't keep. But yeah, good financial management is the right thing to emphasise. You can build on that.

[Bald Student]

The FAI banned STIG from being sold in Belfield Park because we published an article implying that Shels were in financial trouble.

[passerrby]

The FAI banned STIG from being sold in Belfield Park because we published an article implying that Shels were in financial trouble.

well there ya go writing such rubbish .shels in trouble whoever heard the like, they must have been scarlet when it didnt come true

[Bald Student]

For the sake of reminiscing, here's the cover of the article.

[Candystripe]

The FAI banned STIG from being sold in Belfield Park because we published an article implying that Shels were in financial trouble.


Should that not of read........"Ollie Byrne told the FAI to ban STIG from being sold in Belfield Park because we published an article implying that Shels were in financial trouble"?

[Longfordian]

Would it not have been that the article dared to question the FAI not doing anything to prevent said trouble?.

[Bald Student]

Would it not have been that the article dared to question the FAI not doing anything to prevent said trouble?.

To be honest, STIG went through a Shels obsessed faze where we had something on them in most issues.

[pineapple stu]

Should that not of read........"Ollie Byrne told the FAI to ban STIG from being sold in Belfield Park because we published an article implying that Shels were in financial trouble"?
Very prescient of you; that's exactly what happened.

Ironically, Ollie never read the fanzine, as far as we can work out, but saw the front cover in the programme, where we used to carry a one page ad for STIG. Needless to say, that was also banned.

And I'm just waiting for Maribor's contribution to this thread...

[pól-dcfc]

To be honest, STIG went through a Shels obsessed faze where we had something on them in most issues.

The whole league went through a Shels obsessed phase for a while, as we watched them rise and rise all the while knowing that they were millimetres from the massive crash.

[thischarmingman]

The whole league went through a Shels obsessed phase for a while, as we watched them rise and rise all the while knowing that they were millimetres from the massive crash.

Thank God we've all learned that lesson.

[pól-dcfc]

Thank God we've all learned that lesson.

:D

I hope to god Derry have anyway.

[Hairy Bowsie]

The whole league went through a Shels obsessed phase for a while

I'll hold this thread up as proof that the "obsessed phase" you mention, isn't over :)

[John83]

The FAI banned STIG from being sold in Belfield Park because we published an article implying that Shels were in financial trouble.
I seem to remember them denying that outright (though I forget when & where). It may be more accurate to say that UCD were leaned push STIG out the gate. Nothing on paper. Asses covered. :)

[Hairy Bowsie]

It may be more accurate to say that UCD were leaned push STIG out the gate. Nothing on paper. Asses covered. :)

Exactly. So i trust you and your UCD cronies to take back your slanderous remarks about Ollir Byrne :D

[Dodge]

Exactly. So i trust you and your UCD cronies to take back your slanderous remarks about Ollir Byrne

You can't slander a deadman

[Hairy Bowsie]

Ha i barely remember posting that but i'm sure i left out a smilie anyway, i'll put it in now.

[Martinho II]

I know from personal experience that longford towns players and management read whats discussed on our forum. our kitman posts on this forum.

[Raheny Red]

The FAI banned STIG from being sold in Belfield Park because we published an article implying that Shels were in financial trouble.

All fanzines are banned from being sold in LoI grounds!

[DmanDmythDledge]

All fanzines are banned from being sold in LoI grounds!
It was because of that.;)

[stann]

Just as a bye-the-bye, is there a current STIG going to be available at the match Friday? And if so where will it be sold?

[pineapple stu]

You want to check with Angus on that, the new editor in chief.