Shocking Refereeing Standard

[gufc2000]

:mad:

Lads, it has come to a stage where something has to be done. I've just arrived in from Terryland, where Mark Gough demonstrated how badly the referees are in Ireland. Is it any wonder people are turned off from going to LoI games.

A few examples of how bad it was:
# I don't mind a few offsides that are offside but when they are not its disgraceful.

# In the second half, down near the corner flag, Jason McGuinnes hooked the ball out over his own touchline from Vinny Faherty yet no corner

# I don't no how many times Pat Fenlon stood outside the manager perimeter and gave out to the officials. Yet the fourth official (who regularly seems to be doing that job at our games) said nothing. Each time Ian Foster complained he was told to get back in the dugout.

# Mark Gough gave out a completely stupid yellow card to Sean Kelly late on, for absolutely nothing. The ref completely ignored Kelly when he was trying to protest something in the first half

Feel free to add more because there is plenty more

[SkStu]

so whats new?

and what will this thread do to sort it out?

[sligoman]

Looks like someone's not happy at not being undefeated anymore:D

[Paddyfield]

He gave a few dodgy decisions against Bohs too.

Also, why was Ndo booked?

[gufc2000]

Looks like someone's not happy at not being undefeated anymore:D
This rant has been coming for a while. Just cos you're jealous that we still ahead of ye :D

[SkStu]

it was timewasting according to extratime.ie, Paddyfield

[gilberto_eire]

In all fairness we were by no means robbed by the ref, which this thread seems to give the impression off

What off-side decisions exactly?... and were you running in line with the ball to call them?, i hate listening to this crap up Terryland every week, we don't seem to remember the offsides we got in our favour or the other decisions, but as soon as the slightest thing goes against us ''The Ref' a ******'' rings out around the stand:rolleyes:

I saw Foster leave his box a few times and nothing was said, unless you were sitting in one of the dugouts then you don't know if Foster was mouthing off or been more of a nuisance then Fenlon?, so you can't give a fair reflection on that situation either!.

Kelly booked?, maybe it was because he was warned about mouthing off in the first half?, sick of hearing this crap about ref's all the time, seem to be the easiest target in the LOI

[Olander]

get over it, we were well beaten tonight and we had many worse reffing performances in terryland than tonights.

[gufc2000]

I accept were awful and deserved to get beat. I'm just highlighting how bad the officials are in our game. Most people in the stand were getting really frustrated at the way Bohs were getting away with repeated time-wasting and what is mentioned above

[Olander]

I accept were awful and deserved to get beat. I'm just highlighting how bad the officials are in our game. Most people in the stand were getting really frustrated at the way Bohs were getting away with repeated time-wasting and what is mentioned above
by goughs standards tonight wasnt even a poor game! every club has to deal with the poor officiating in this league.:o:o absolutely no need for this thread it just looks like sour grapes.

[gufc2000]

Alright if it appears like sour grapes then close this thread please

[Terry]

Ndo got booked for blocking a free kick been taken quickly (not retreating the ten yards)

[celticV3]

If this thread was to remain open then it needs to be covering all referee's in the league. Opening a thread this soon after the game and feeling fcuked over then it is sour grapes.

[brianw82]

There were a few well-dodgy offsides at The Showgrounds tonight, too. Fair enough, a lot were called correctly but a few of them made you wonder if the linesman knew the laws of the game at all.

[RoversHead]

if this thread was to remain open then it needs to be covering all referee's in the league. Opening a thread this soon after the game and feeling fcuked over then it is sour grapes.
never a truer word spoke,i dunno how many times ive cursed refs all the way home only to be proved wrong watching the highlights,its no worse than its ever been there are a few tulips but thats the same in every league in the world.

[Tallanted]

# I don't no how many times Pat Fenlon stood outside the manager perimeter and gave out to the officials. Yet the fourth official (who regularly seems to be doing that job at our games) said nothing. Each time Ian Foster complained he was told to get back in the dugout

This has gone on since Fenlon became a manager at every ground in the country, it will never change

[Terry-Lander]

Saying that the standard of refereeing is poor is akin to saying that we were beaten by a far superior team.....get over both and move on

[Jock MIB]

There were a few well-dodgy offsides at The Showgrounds tonight, too. Fair enough, a lot were called correctly but a few of them made you wonder if the linesman knew the laws of the game at all.

just curious what would be your definition of offside?

[The Midget Gem]

There were a few well-dodgy offsides at The Showgrounds tonight, too. Fair enough, a lot were called correctly but a few of them made you wonder if the linesman knew the laws of the game at all.
As Any Gray put it the other day: most of them just don't have a clue. Honestly.

We had a stone wall penalty waved away last night but I'm not complaining we won.

[brianw82]

just curious what would be your definition of offside?

When the forward is closer to the goal than the last defender at the time the ball is played. Oh, and is 'active', can't forget that one.

Same as most fans, tbh.

[pól-dcfc]

It's when any part of the (active) forward that can legally be used to play the ball is ahead of any part of the second last opposition player that can legally be used to play the ball.

[Armando]

When the forward is closer to the goal than the last defender at the time the ball is played. Oh, and is 'active', can't forget that one.

Same as most fans, tbh.


When the forward is closer to the goal than the last two defenders at the time the ball is played.;)

[brianw82]

When the forward is closer to the goal than the last two defenders at the time the ball is played.;)

I meant outfield player, ya scallywag.

[KevB76]

As Any Gray put it the other day.....


That your problem right there. When it comes to refs, dont take Andy Gray as a credible reference. He has his own opinions on the rules, which vary from one situation to the next. But because he's on the telly people accept his version. The man clearly has a dislike for refs (but he's not as bad as Roddy :D )

[KevB76]

In all fairness we were by no means robbed by the ref, which this thread seems to give the impression off

What off-side decisions exactly?... and were you running in line with the ball to call them?, i hate listening to this crap up Terryland every week, we don't seem to remember the offsides we got in our favour or the other decisions, but as soon as the slightest thing goes against us ''The Ref' a ******'' rings out around the stand:rolleyes:

I saw Foster leave his box a few times and nothing was said, unless you were sitting in one of the dugouts then you don't know if Foster was mouthing off or been more of a nuisance then Fenlon?, so you can't give a fair reflection on that situation either!.

Kelly booked?, maybe it was because he was warned about mouthing off in the first half?, sick of hearing this crap about ref's all the time, seem to be the easiest target in the LOI

Well said gilberto.

We've all left matches feeling hard done by with the ref's, some are better than others but they all make the occassional mistake. A lot of the time its our own misinterpretation of rules or poor view of an incident thats at fault.
None of the officials intentionally set out to get things wrong or favour one side or another (except maybe Padraig Sutton :D). The League of Ireland refs are no better or worse than you will find anywhere else.

[bennocelt]

That your problem right there. When it comes to refs, dont take Andy Gray as a credible reference. He has his own opinions on the rules, which vary from one situation to the next. But because he's on the telly people accept his version. The man clearly has a dislike for refs (but he's not as bad as Roddy :D )

Andy gray is the worst - and the funny thing is he only complains AFTER he sees it on the reply, never during the game.

I think the St. Pats - Bray game last week was a referring shocker - dodby peno, and goal wrongly disallowed

[eamo1]

I've seen far worse Ref displays in Terryland too,mostly by Alan Kelly but Tourney(spelling),Buttimer deserve mentions too.I went so far one time to write to the Eircom League office back when they were over the league.The overall standard is shockingly bad but it wouldnt have made ANY difference last night.
The thing i hate is that a ref in this league will never consult his linesman.Also, even though the lineman will have been nearer to the incident he will wait and let the ref make a decision and not flag for anything.Also in this league if a decision is borderline offside the linesman's flag will ALWAYS go up.In most other leagues in Europe benefit of the doubt is given to the attacking team.

[KevB76]

The thing i hate is that a ref in this league will never consult his linesman.Also, even though the lineman will have been nearer to the incident he will wait and let the ref make a decision and not flag for anything.

Wrong. Exhibit 1 - go to 2 min 30 on the youtube video here, watch the lino in the background.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xRDeleEjeOs&feature=channel_page

This was one incident where a lot of us in the shed, from our view point, thought the sending off of the keeper was harsh. But the video is perfectly positioned and clearly shows that the keeper was last man.



Also in this league if a decision is borderline offside the linesman's flag will ALWAYS go up.In most other leagues in Europe benefit of the doubt is given to the attacking team.

Borderline offside is offside.
And I dont agree about other leageues giving the beneft - surely you've seen enough replays of tight offside decisions on EPL games and internationals for example?

[Réiteoir]

They do consult their Assistants - only it's not that noticeable nowadays thanks to the Headsets they wear.

Think it does speak volumes and an improvement that the first "major" thread about someone (on this occasion, wrongly) cribbing and moaning about Match Officials comes just under a whole month into the new season - in previous years it's been on the first night or so...

Officials are bound to make the odd mistake - just the same as players and managers do

[pineapple stu]

Also in this league if a decision is borderline offside the linesman's flag will ALWAYS go up.In most other leagues in Europe benefit of the doubt is given to the attacking team.
Advantage goes to the attacking team in cases of doubt. Doubt and borderline aren't the same thing.

[WoodquayBoy]

I thought Gough did little wrong last night to be honest. Derek O'Brien was booked for mouthing, Ndo was booked for preventing a quick free, and lets be honest, Davoren's booking was a no-brainer. Yes, Fenlon gave Paul Deering (4th official) fierce gip - it ewas fiunny watching a manager tell an official to relax, rather than the other way aorund - and he spent more time outside technical area than inside it, but as someone else posted, Foster did plenty of wandering around as well. The reason so many offside decisions are given against us is because our front men are far too slow to get back onside, or are unable to look across the line to time their run off the last defender. If Faherty had scored the 'goal' Byrne did just after half time, only for it to be ruled out for offside, we would be going ape. Not a word though because it was an opposition player.
And as someone else said, the officials don't intentionally go out to make wrong decisions, just the same as the players don't go out to play poorly

[GuisaSaigon]

Mark Gough is a shockingly inept referee. That obese linesman that we always seem to get is without doubt the worst linesman in the league. He can't even keep up with the play. I think he actually gets a buzz from making crap decisions and getting the crowd on his back.

[celticV3]

just curious what would be your definition of offside?
Someone get the salt and pepper out

[Jock MIB]

When the forward is closer to the goal than the last defender at the time the ball is played. Oh, and is 'active', can't forget that one.

Same as most fans, tbh.

here i was just being curious as to know if you knew the rule, which you have shown to not know fully ... as its the second last defender and also its not when the ball is played its when the ball is touched by your fellow player .. here but let you off being vague but here its fifa who got rid of the if you were offside you were offside and brought in this grey aera of being active or not and left it to the referees to make the decision as the sit back and make up the rules. Come on give them a break if you think you the fan can do better try it but as most i guess you will say NAH i prefer to give abuse

[Jock MIB]

Someone get the salt and pepper out

why you taking up cooking?

[Schumi]

its fifa who got rid of the if you were offside you were offside and brought in this grey aera of being active or notReally? You always had to be interfering with play (which I assume is the same being 'active') to be called offside I thought. Otherwise a guy at the corner flag could be called offside for a through-ball in the middle of the pitch.

[holidaysong]

I meant outfield player, ya scallywag.

The two players don't have to include the goalkeeper though. It's rare alright but I have seen it where the goalkeeper isn't one of the two players playing the attacker offside.

(The goalkeeper had gone up to take a penalty and missed). :D

[Jock MIB]

Really? You always had to be interfering with play (which I assume is the same being 'active') to be called offside I thought. Otherwise a guy at the corner flag could be called offside for a through-ball in the middle of the pitch.

:rolleyes: all i was saying was many years ago there was no such thing as being active or not ... it was deemed an offside offence for anyone to be in a offside position then fifa brought in active or not and then the offside rule changed in its interpretation and how it was implemented. Hence the grey area because for every 1 you think is offside another will say its not different interpretations

[Schumi]

:rolleyes: all i was saying was many years ago there was no such thing as being active or not ... it was deemed an offside offence for anyone to be in a offside position then fifa brought in active or not and then the offside rule changed in its interpretation and how it was implemented. Hence the grey area because for every 1 you think is offside another will say its not different interpretations

Not sure why the rolling eyes are necessary. What's the difference in the two interpretations? Players not interfering with play were never to be called offside that I remember, how is that different to being inactive?

[Jock MIB]

Not sure why the rolling eyes are necessary. What's the difference in the two interpretations? Players not interfering with play were never to be called offside that I remember, how is that different to being inactive?

come on you know thats not true, offside was offside ask anyone in soccer thats what all the players and managers want it to go back to... a plain if a player is offside (inactive or not) then flag offside . no grey aera or anything.

here but thats my interpretation of it, and i am going with experience in the middle get asked(as well as abuse) by players and managers why that was offside and another isn't.

i know it like talking to a brick wall with most fans because you look for an easy target and 80% of time its the ref so enjoy the rest of your season and best of luck

[JC_GUFC]

You'd know it was school holidays around here!

[Weatherman]

That young linesman. his name escapes me, who lookes like torres and is almost a regular fixture down the carisle grounds is absolutly shocking! he ruled out quigley's goal for nothing almost and imo is always calling for fouls and giving offsides wrongly all the time.

[brianw82]

here i was just being curious as to know if you knew the rule, which you have shown to not know fully ... as its the second last defender and also its not when the ball is played its when the ball is touched by your fellow player .. here but let you off being vague but here its fifa who got rid of the if you were offside you were offside and brought in this grey aera of being active or not and left it to the referees to make the decision as the sit back and make up the rules. Come on give them a break if you think you the fan can do better try it but as most i guess you will say NAH i prefer to give abuse

I know the rule. Perhaps I didn't explain it properly, but I do know it.

Anyway, on with the thread.

[BobtheDrog]

i was amazed at how bad a certain female official was when she was running the line at the Drogs-Rovers game. She was permanently out of position and seemed to be randomly guessing whether people were offside or not

[Réiteoir]

come on you know thats not true, offside was offside ask anyone in soccer thats what all the players and managers want it to go back to... a plain if a player is offside (inactive or not) then flag offside . no grey aera or anything.

here but thats my interpretation of it, and i am going with experience in the middle get asked(as well as abuse) by players and managers why that was offside and another isn't.

i know it like talking to a brick wall with most fans because you look for an easy target and 80% of time its the ref so enjoy the rest of your season and best of luck


1920: The following is introduced onto the Off-side Law 6.

Play should not be stopped and a player given off-side under Law 6 because the player is in an off-side position. A breach of the Law is only committed when a player who is in an offside position interferes with an opponent or with the play. ".
(Council of the Football Association 8th March).

So lads - who fancies reverting to the Law as applied in 1919?

[Jock MIB]

So lads - who fancies reverting to the Law as applied in 1919?

would love it , so i dont have to listen to so much crap that comes out of fans mouths about offsides and back then it was the last three defenders which was even better or will we go back to the experimental GM Vauxhall conference of you couldnt be offside for a free kick that would be a great one to bring back

[thischarmingman]

i was amazed at how bad a certain female official was when she was running the line at the Drogs-Rovers game. She was permanently out of position

Too right, the kitchen was on the other side of the ground.