Duffer First?

[fergalr]

I might be forgetting somebody obvious ... but:

Is Damien Duff the first Dub to play (and score) in the Champions League?

[Dodge]

Alan Maybury played for leeds. Don't know if he scored

[finlma]

You'd think there would have been one before now. Ian Harte is the closest to Dublin player to score a Champions League goal before now.
There's been more goals scored by Cork men.

[John83]

Don't know about the Champion League in the modern sense, but surely Brady played in the European Cup. And didn't Robbie get a CL qualifier or two for Inter? Didn't score anyway.

[finlma]

Plenty of Dubs have played in the European Cup: Moran, McGrath. Even the League of Ireland players have played European Cup. Not too many have played Champions League though.

[fergalr]

I was just thinking of the modern champions league.

So - nice one Dodge for Alan Maybury - would never have thought of that one. Not so sure about Robbie however.

[Dodge]

Originally posted by fergalr
I was just thinking of the modern champions league.

So - nice one Dodge for Alan Maybury - would never have thought of that one. Not so sure about Robbie however.
Didn't Keane miss out on Leeds run that year as he played in the qualifying rounds for Inter?

[Seanie]

Yeah played in the qualifying round

[colster]

Originally posted by finlma
Plenty of Dubs have played in the European Cup: Moran, McGrath. Even the League of Ireland players have played European Cup. Not too many have played Champions League though.

Neither Moran or MacGrath played in the EC.
MaCGrath never won the league during his career and Moran won it late on in his career with BlackBurn I think but didn't play in the CL.

If you are talking of the European Cup rather than the Champions League then Liam Whelan played for Utd and was killed in the Munich crash.

[Schumi]

Originally posted by fergalr
Is Damien Duff the first Dub to play (and score) in the Champions League? Glen Crowe?? Or is this just the group stages?

[fergalr]

Originally posted by Schumi
Glen Crowe?? Or is this just the group stages?
I was just thinking of the post 1992 Champions League proper (ie not including qualifiying rounds).

So off the top of my head, ones that have played include Duff, Roy Keane, O'Shea, Given, O'Brien, Miller, Garry Kelly, Harte, McPhail(?), Maybury.

Of these only Duff and Maybury are Dubs.

There must be more .....?

[Schumi]

Denis Irwin would have played as well wouldn't he?

[UCD_4_Life]

Originally posted by Schumi
Denis Irwin would have played as well wouldn't he?

He did.

I'm sure Keith Gillespie would've made an appearance or two for United too.

Did McPhail play for Leeds in the CL at any stage?

Maybe Ritchie Partridge at Liverpool?

[John83]

Originally posted by UCD_4_Life
Maybe Ritchie Partridge at Liverpool?

Houllier seemed reluctant to play an attacking player in Europe. Partrige hardly got a look in the Worthington Cup, never mind the european one.

[finlma]

The only Irish players I can think of to have scored in the Champions League group stages are:
Roy Keane
Ian Harte
Damian Duff

Surely there are more????

[Dodge]

Don't think so.

BTW David Connolly also played in the CL for Feyernoord

[John83]

Where's that little ****e from then?

[tricky_colour]

Originally posted by Schumi
Denis Irwin would have played as well wouldn't he?

I would have though so.
Also Irwin used to take penalties for Man U didn't he?
Assuming so it would be a little surprising if he never scored.
Maybe Man U were never award a penalty in the competion
when he was playing or maybe someone else took them
or maybe he missed them (all!)?
Or maybe I am confusing him with Ian Harte for some reason
(taking penalties for Ireland), but I think I am right.
Maybe i will have to do some searching on google etc..

[tricky_colour]

I seem to remember Liam Miller scored for Celtic in the C. L.
against Anderlect a few days ago, although he is from Cork
I think.

[tricky_colour]

Well I did some googling.

Denis Irwin scored the Man U's 200th goal in the European Cup/Champions
League against Anderlecht.
He also made a club record 50 appearances in the competition,
so he probably got a few more.
(Info maybe slightly out of date).

He is also, like Liam Miller, from Cork. A good sign perhaps?
Its quite a coincidence that both goals I found were against
Anderlecht and both by players born in Cork!!!
Incidently my dad is from Cork!!!
Although he never scored against Anderlecht, or indeed played
football with anyone of any significance - apart from me - as a child.
I seem to remember he wasn't particularly too good then.
He had a slight weight problem! (A bit like Ian Harte!!).:p

[pineapple stu]

Originally posted by John83
Where's that little ****e from then?

London, of Galway parents.

[John83]

Originally posted by pineapple stu
London, of Galway parents.

Figures. ;)

[Junior]

Originally posted by tricky_colour
I seem to remember Liam Miller scored for Celtic in the C. L.
against Anderlect a few days ago, although he is from Cork
I think.

also scored against Lyon, a month or so back (at Celtic Park)

[fan in reading]

Originally posted by John83
Figures. ;)

care to expand?

[John83]

Originally posted by fan in reading
care to expand?
Not really, I'd just start an arguement!

Basically, it's a nod to the widespread belief that "plastic paddies" are less likely to work their socks off for the team, something I'd have no compunctions of accusing Connolly of, but which I don't agree with in general.

Now, if anyone wants to argue about it, get your own thread. One which I'll eternally ignore.

[tricky_colour]

Originally posted by John83
Not really, I'd just start an arguement!

Basically, it's a nod to the widespread belief that "plastic paddies" are less likely to work their socks off for the team, something I'd have no compunctions of accusing Connolly of, but which I don't agree with in general.

Now, if anyone wants to argue about it, get your own thread. One which I'll eternally ignore.

Its not your thread though, if you start a new one you can ignore
it.

Whether a player works his socks off or not depends on several
factors, as many 'real padies' don't appear to work their
socks off. *Appear* being an operative word as if your socks
don't appear they cannot be worker off, although socks of
a colour other than green maybe worked off for a better
paying team.
Smelly socks perhaps?

[John83]

Originally posted by tricky_colour
Its not your thread though, if you start a new one you can ignore
it.

Whether a player works his socks off or not depends on several
factors, as many 'real padies' don't appear to work their
socks off. *Appear* being an operative word as if your socks
don't appear they cannot be worker off, although socks of
a colour other than green maybe worked off for a better
paying team.
Smelly socks perhaps?

Is this forum even modded? :rolleyes:

[sadloserkid]

Originally posted by John83
Is this forum even modded? :rolleyes:

Some people need a moderator all of their own! :)