PC: Gary Lineker - Ian Rush

[Stevo Da Gull]

Gary Lineker
Date of birth: 30 November 1960
Place of birth: Leicester, England
Height: 1.77 m (5 ft 9+1⁄2 in)
Weight: 11 04
Position: Striker
Nationality: English
Int apps: 80
Int goals: 48

Career Honours:


Barcelona CF

Copa Del Rey: 1988
UEFA Cup Winners Cup: 1989


Tottenham Hotspur

FA Cup 1991

Personal Honours:


Fifa World Cup - Golden Boot: 1986 (Mexico)
English league top scorer: 1985, 1986, 1990

Appearance Stats:


Senior Club Appearances: 567 (406 in England)
Senior League Appearances: 466 (340 in England)
Goal Tally: 283 in total. 244 in league football

....

Ian Rush
Date of birth: 20-10-1961
Place of birth: St Asaph
Height: 6.00
Weight: 12.06
Position: Forward
Nationality: Welsh
International Caps: 73
International Goals: 28

Career Honours:


Liverpool FC

European Cup 83/84
First Division (5) 81/82, 82/83, 83/84, 85/86, 89/90
FA Cup (3) 85/86, 88/89, 91/92
League Cup (5) 80/81, 81/82, 82/83, 83/84, 94/95

Personal Honours:


1983 PFA Young Player of the Year
1984 PFA Players' Player of the Year
1984 FWA Footballer of the Year
1984 European Golden Boot
1984 First Division Top Scorer
Record FA Cup Final goalscorer with 5 goals

Appearance Stats:


Senior Club Appearances: 810
Senior League Apearances: 603 (572 in England)
Goal Tally: 388 in total. 254 in league football.

[Stevo Da Gull]

Almost posted Linekers Barca honours as 1888 and 1889 :D

[gustavo]

Lineker for me

[superfrank]

Lineker for me. His GPG is miles better. 244 in 340 English league games, opposed to Rush's 254 in 572.

Can't really compare their international records, England were a million times better than Wales back then.

[joeSoap]

Rushie for me. One of the, if not the greatest 6 yard poachers to ever play the game.

[lofty9]

Rushie for me. One of the, if not the greatest 6 yard poachers to ever play the game.

Lineker for me, One of the, if not the greatest 6 yard poachers to ever play the game. :D

[gustavo]

i

oh and dont let his international record fool you, it was padded out considerably by scoring 4 against egypt etc

As are most international scoring records

[noby]

Lineker for me. His GPG is miles better. 244 in 340 English league games, opposed to Rush's 254 in 572.



I think you're reading the stats wrong there (or they're not very clear). 244 was Lineker's career total. He still had a better gpg ratio, but it's Rush all the way for me.

[joeSoap]

Lineker:

Overall: 1 goal in every 2.005 games
League: 1 goal in every 1.9 games
International: 1 goal in every 1.666 games

Rush:

Overall: 1 goal in every 2.087 games.
League: 1 goal in every 2.37 games
International: 1 goal in every 2.69 games

Overall, the only place where Lineker is far more prolific is Internationally. Given that Rushie is a poor Taff, its a no brainer. I wonder what his England tally would have been if he was a English? Just as good I'd say.

[drinkfeckarse]

I'm a Liverpool fan so I'm probably being biased in saying Rush. What I can honestly say is that both of them were supreme goalscorers and clinical finishers. However, Rushie's all round game was far superior to Linekers and his last few seasons were basically spent playing the 2nd striker role and doing the donkey work which wouldn't have helped his goals per game ratio.

Rush would never give the defenders a moments piece and his link play was excellent IMO. Lineker on the other hand was a lazy git who just hung around the box :D

Rush did the donkey work for Fowler to score plenty of his goals and did the same at Newcastle.

[Pike B]

Ian Rush all day. Scored more, achieved more, and was just better at everything, from heading and long range, to defending from the front and hold up play. Easy one this...

[centre mid]

I'm probably biased also as an Everton fan, but Lineker for me also. A bet poacher and also did it when he left England, the fact that he missed out on the all time England goalscoring record will probably haunt him. Its probably not fair to compare them on International statistics as Lineker obviously played in a more potent team.

[BohsPartisan]

Lineker. During the 85/86 his record was phenomenal. Plus he managed to be relatively successful when he moved overseas, unlike Rush who was a flop at Juve. Plus rush was sad enough to do that April fools "joke" in Shoot!

[stojkovic]

Rush.

Never forgave Lineker for equalising in Poland in 91.

[superfrank]

I think you're reading the stats wrong there (or they're not very clear). 244 was Lineker's career total. He still had a better gpg ratio, but it's Rush all the way for me.
Right you are. I'd still go for Lineker. No turning back at this stage anyway.

[The Optimist]

Rush without a doubt!

[5ForKeeps]

Ian Rush no contest.

[cobra]

Rushie for me

[lofty9]

Ian Rush no contest.

No surprise considering your sig.

I can't imagine a Liverpool fan would vote for Lineker.
Rush played in THE TOP team in Europe at the time, making chance after chance for him. Flopped badly at Juventus, failed to integrate into a different way of life and football system.

Lineker did it with every club he played with, he'd have scored more at Barca if it wasn't for Cruyff crazy selection of him as a right winger.

Scored a hatrick vs Real Madrid too, which made him an everlasting hero there. Thought, I was making things up ^, so I had to check .

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=TEGivftftC8

[Macy]

Lineker. Rush did it as part of the anfield machine, whereas Lineker proved he could do it at different clubs, in different leagues at different levels.

[Longfordian]

Lineker for the reasons as mentioned above, also at least he was never complaining that they didn't have Rice Krispies and that it was "like a foreign country over there".