Named N' Shamed

[Peat Burns]

The worst refs in the EL

Lets start by mmmmmm

Whelan :mad: :mad: :mad:

[dortie]

Perry...I hate Derry !

[Enda M]

Whelan,Buttimur,o'neill,hilda,kelly ah sure every singal one is ****

[Dr.Nightdub]

Jim O'Neill. End of thread.

[sadloserkid]

Kelly from Athlone.

[Bosco]

Eh nobodys mentioned hancock yet:confused:

[patsh]

I think the sight of McKeon must give a few clubs the horrors...;)

[A face]

O'Neil is a smarmy cnut to boot !!

[SÓC]

O'Neill then McKeon.

[DruggyDrog]

O'Neill is just awful. but Eddie Barr is really trying to overtake him

[Éanna]

McKeon. O'Neill is just stupid.

[Peat Burns]

i think this tread would be alot shorter if i named it
"the good refs in the eL":rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes:

[Peat Burns]

oh yea and i couldnt forget McKeon hes a w**k*r

[RedX]

O'Neill is bad but he could be with or against you and if against you pray.Worst ref in Cork over the last couple of seasons without a doubt is McKeon.Absolutely terrible...

[Robinski]

McKeon, he's atrocious.

[Éanna]

does it strike anyone else as being highly ironic that the 2 refs featuring most often in this thread seem to get most of the big matches in this country? :rolleyes:

[Peat Burns]

what does that say about the standard of refs in ireland???
:( :( :(

[Enda M]

evry one of them are terrible

[Peat Burns]

true

[Footie_Fan]

You call yourselves football people? Ha! No ref - no game. Just cause they gave one decision against your team that in fairness was probably the correct one you deem them bad refs. Why don't you guys step into the centre circle and try it?

[tiktok]

Originally posted by Footie_Fan
You call yourselves football people? Ha! No ref - no game. Just cause they gave one decision against your team that in fairness was probably the correct one you deem them bad refs. Why don't you guys step into the centre circle and try it?

you clearly don't know what you're talking about Footie Fan, there are two refs being mentioned consistently here, by fans of many different clubs, that might imply that there is a genuine problem.

I think McKeon is poor, but O'Neill is an idiot, he finds it hard to keep up with the game and never gets a real grip on it, he's always struggling to maintain control and it often results in needless bookings being handed out. Not accusing him of any bias, i think he's as bad for all clubs.

and FF this is based on years of attending LOI games, not on one decision hat went against us (in which case it would still be O'Hanlon:D )

[Footie_Fan]

Originally posted by tiktok
you clearly don't know what you're talking about Footie Fan, there are two refs being mentioned consistently here, by fans of many different clubs, that might imply that there is a genuine problem.

I think McKeon is poor, but O'Neill is an idiot, he finds it hard to keep up with the game and never gets a real grip on it, he's always struggling to maintain control and it often results in needless bookings being handed out. Not accusing him of any bias, i think he's as bad for all clubs.

and FF this is based on years of attending LOI games, not on one decision hat went against us (in which case it would still be O'Hanlon:D )

Well have you ever referred at the highest level of irish football or at any level? Have you any qualification in the Laws of the Game? These refs obviously deserve their place on EL panel otherwise the wouldn't have made it. They are continually retested etc on laws and fitness.

And comments like this

Originally posted by Enda M
evry one of them are terrible

are downright stupid.

[Macy]

Originally posted by Footie_Fan
These refs obviously deserve their place on EL panel otherwise the wouldn't have made it. They are continually retested etc on laws and fitness.
Why, because they're the best of a bad lot?

[tiktok]

Originally posted by Footie_Fan
These refs obviously deserve their place on EL panel otherwise the wouldn't have made it. They are continually retested etc on laws and fitness.


being able to recite the laws in a test and the ability to apply them with common sense are two different things entirely, fitness will allow you to keep up with the pace of a game but little else.

i accept that they're continually assessed, but the irish problem seems to be a lack of referees waiting in the wings to replace them.

one of the refs mentioned here has also been asked to 'take a break' for a month this season after it was noted by one of those assessors that he didn't send off a player who pushed him while arguing over a penalty. his fitness might have gotten him there in time to take the push, but his interpretation of the laws was a bit off.

and i find it strange that no one on this board (as i'm ranting) has mentioned that our head assessor of referees just gave the FAI cup final to his son, on the latters 1st (open to correction, maybe 2nd) season as a top flight ref.

[Éanna]

Originally posted by Macy
Why, because they're the best of a bad lot?
stop saying things like that. I hate agreeing with you :)