Munster Senior League

**Nedge** · 20/04/2012, 11:21 AM

Bandon awarded 3- 0 win for game against Ballincollig.

**Clifford** · 20/04/2012, 12:42 PM

Originally Posted by Nedge

Bandon awarded 3- 0 win for game against Ballincollig.

More illegal players I assume? Thing is beyond a joke now.

The bigger picture for me is that Clubs are really struggling to hold onto players. Gonna be interesting next season to see how many clubs can field sides at all. Then the **** will hit the fan.

Are a few AUL teams being considered for the MSL? That might help I suppose. I know nothing about that though, only picked it up off the AUL thread on this site.

**Shinguard** · 20/04/2012, 12:52 PM

Originally Posted by Goggs

I presume by your militant response Shinguard that your a blazer(MSl representative)or you suffer from severe tunnel vision your not looking at the overall picture here the rules were put in place to stop teams fielding senior players Midleton went the opposite and fielded players who werent getting regular football week in week out ie the subs and fielded a few 17 year olds to blood them for next season now if that comes under the guise of cheating that is just sad and common sense should prevail.In essence there being punished for fielding a weakened side yes there are rules but rules are usually broken to benefit a team not to weaken it.

You said it yourself " there are rules". Except for Midleton I presume.

**six-yard-box** · 20/04/2012, 1:31 PM

Originally Posted by Clifford

More illegal players I assume? Thing is beyond a joke now.

The bigger picture for me is that Clubs are really struggling to hold onto players. Gonna be interesting next season to see how many clubs can field sides at all. Then the **** will hit the fan.

Are a few AUL teams being considered for the MSL? That might help I suppose. I know nothing about that though, only picked it up off the AUL thread on this site.

I heard Wilton kinsale leeside park and buttevant all are applying to go up. And that if casement want to come up they'll be awarded a place no bother. Dixie any truth in the rumour yere putting in an mjl team next year too?

**Dixie's Cousin** · 20/04/2012, 1:44 PM

Why would Casement drop out of the MSL to reapply? Makes no sense! as for the MJL team where did you hear that?

**Goggs** · 20/04/2012, 1:51 PM

Originally Posted by Shinguard

You said it yourself " there are rules". Except for Midleton I presume.

That's the best reply you have am I talking to an 8year old or an adult.

**Shinguard** · 20/04/2012, 2:00 PM

Originally Posted by Goggs

That's the best reply you have am I talking to an 8year old or an adult.

An 8 year old of course but an 8 year old who understands the rules which by the way are given to each club secretary every year. Except Midleton I presume.

**six-yard-box** · 20/04/2012, 2:20 PM

Originally Posted by Dixie's Cousin

Why would Casement drop out of the MSL to reapply? Makes no sense! as for the MJL team where did you hear that?

couldnt get a squad together so had no choice i think at the time. at yere match last night!!

**Dixie's Cousin** · 20/04/2012, 2:30 PM

Didn't hear that myself

**Mighty almighty** · 20/04/2012, 6:31 PM

Ur wrong shin guard because there is two other teams also thrown out....but u should no that😉....shouldn't you....yes rules are rules shin guard but our point is why would you put in a rule to stop underage players progressing...let's be honest this rule was to stop senior players from playing in it,which does make sense,but makes no sense to stop underage from progressing!!

**archie** · 20/04/2012, 8:41 PM

Originally Posted by Mighty almighty

Ur wrong shin guard because there is two other teams also thrown out....but u should no that....shouldn't you....yes rules are rules shin guard but our point is why would you put in a rule to stop underage players progressing...let's be honest this rule was to stop senior players from playing in it,which does make sense,but makes no sense to stop underage from progressing!!

Local Cup Rules, The John Hayes Cup, "Only players registered in the Junior First Division are eligible to play in this competition"I think this is straight forward enough,
With regard to this competition or any other rule, get your club to submit a "change of rule proposal for the AGM" to the MSL (re youth players or whatever)before 30th April as per rule 42, Thats the way to go, and stop ranting about the MSL and every rule in the book on here.

**AvondaleNutter** · 20/04/2012, 9:13 PM

I'm getting confused between the two threads lads. Can we keep this for senior only :-)

**Glenbuck** · 21/04/2012, 4:12 PM

Hall 1 up on Marys. Came away with 15 to go. Witnessed an unbelievable decision in this game. Hall player was straight through on goal and ref blew up to book a Marys player on the half way line for dissent. Why not leave the ball go dead. Incredible !!!!

**Chiefscout** · 21/04/2012, 4:48 PM

Cors 2 mayfield 3
Marys 0 hall 1

**duckdu** · 21/04/2012, 4:54 PM

bandon 0-0 fermoy

**Dixie's Cousin** · 21/04/2012, 5:20 PM

Any result from Carrigaline and UCC?

**Clifford** · 21/04/2012, 5:23 PM

Yeah 0-0 today away to Bandon. Fair result in the end as we played all the ball but never tested their keeper. They contained us and in the last 15 mins broke well to make Mick Devine make 3 great stops.

So it goes to last game of the season again in div 1 with 3/4 teams still able to go up. Great fun to be part of it and pleasure playing Bandon today. Committed and honest from both sides. ref did well as well Tomas long I think it was. Always nice to compliment them when they do well.