Republic of Ireland V Moldova - Friday 6th October 2017 - World Cup 2018 Qualifier
I've been thinking over the days since the Serbia defeat about this Ireland team and where it goes from here. There are 3 main themes to what I've come up with so far.
The first is that O'Neill has been let down by his players. The knives are out for him, but i won't fault him for that, yet. I will fault him if he fails to act on that. Performances have dropped off dramatically since the superb start to the group. I think that start led O'Neill (correctly) to want to show faith in the players who brought him that start, but they haven't been able to maintain the standard they set for themselves. Georgia was a complacent performance by complacent players. Say what you like about O'Neill and his tactical approach, but he didn't send his team out with instructions to play like that. Serbia was better but still not good enough. Key players who should be the mainstays of this squad aren't performing. Robbie Brady is the example of this my mind keeps going to but there are others. He simply hasn’t been good enough. His ability is obvious but if isn't delivering on the pitch he shouldn't be in the team.
The second theme I've been returning to again and again is that the age profile of our squad is now far to old. Again this is possibly a result of the loyalty of O'Neill to players who have performed for him at the Euros and the early part of this group meaning certain people have been allowed to go on too long, but O'Neill now has to act on that. Whelan's legs have clearly gone from under him. Regardless of what Dunphy says, Hoolahan came off after an hour because he is a 35 year old who hasn't played much this season and he was blowing out his arse. Walters hasn't looked fit since before the Euros. We don't have room for half-fit passengers unfortunately, and the squad needs more of a balance of youth and experience. That is going to mean tough decisions about loyal servants who have been faithfully showing up for squads for years, often without much in the way of game time. It's tough on them, especially as I'd throw a few of the younger lads replacing them into the team, but there is no room for sentimentality in picking international squads unfortunately.
Moldova is our next chance to address these issues. Performance has to be a metric in picking the side. The guys who were in possession and didn't perform the last days should go onto the bench, no matter who they are. Those who in my opinion did their jobs over the 2 games were Duffy, Clark, Meyler, McClean and (despite the grief I've given him down the years) Stephen Ward, so they are the only ones I would retain.
The 3rd theme i have is that i think this difficult situation presents us with an opportunity to address one of the great problems we have faced this last decade or so. That is our tendency to finally give guys their chance at 28+, and only realising how good they are once they are already in their 30s. Wes Hoolahan being one of the most obvious examples of this, it's slightly ironic that i suggest him being one of the victims of resolving it, but from the very little I've seen of Liam Kelly he plays a similar role for his club, he certainly appears to be good enough, and he plays with that lack of fear that kids his age tend to. He is playing more regularly that Hoolahan so why shouldn't he get his chance? He's 4 years older that Robbie Keane was when he got his chance and that worked out OK.
With all that in mind I'm suggesting a team for Moldova a bit like
---- Elliot / Westwood ----
Doherty Duffy Clark Ward
---- Meyler Hendrick ----
- Horgan Kelly McClean -
----- Maguire/Hogan -----
There are a lot of new faces there. The likes of Brady & Long would have a role to play off the bench, and would probably come back for Cardiff if they looked like they had got the message when they came on.
I've been mulling this one over for a few days now before i did a long post like this. I'm still convinced that our best chance is a high tempo, aggressive, direct style of play, but the need for some sort of change is obvious. Some of the ideas here are a little rough around the edges but I'm throwing this out for debate to see if you guys have any thoughts that can help me put a bit of polish on my thoughts.